Villefortrose,halfashamedofbeingsurprisedinsuchaparoxysmofgrief. Theterribleofficehehadheldfortwenty–fiveyearshadsucceededinmakinghimmoreorlessthanman. Hisglance,atfirstwandering,fixeditselfuponMorrel. “Whoareyou,sir,”heasked,“thatforgetthatthisisnotthemannertoenterahousestrickenwithdeath?Go,sir,go!” ButMorrelremainedmotionless;hecouldnotdetachhiseyesfromthatdisorderedbed,andthepalecorpseoftheyounggirlwhowaslyingonit.“Go!—doyouhear?” saidVillefort,whiled’AvrignyadvancedtoleadMorrelout. Maximilianstaredforamomentatthecorpse,gazedallaroundtheroom,thenuponthetwomen;heopenedhismouthtospeak,butfindingitimpossibletogiveutterancetotheinnumerableideasthatoccupiedhisbrain,hewentout,thrustinghishandsthroughhishairinsuchamannerthatVillefortandd’Avrigny,foramomentdivertedfromtheengrossingtopic,exchangedglances,whichseemedtosay,—”Heismad!” Butinlessthanfiveminutesthestaircasegroanedbeneathanextraordinaryweight. Morrelwasseencarrying,withsuperhumanstrength,thearm–chaircontainingNoirtierup–stairs. Whenhereachedthelandingheplacedthearm–chaironthefloorandrapidlyrolleditintoValentine’sroom. Thiscouldonlyhavebeenaccomplishedbymeansofunnaturalstrengthsuppliedbypowerfulexcitement. ButthemostfearfulspectaclewasNoirtierbeingpushedtowardsthebed,hisfaceexpressingallhismeaning,andhiseyessupplyingthewantofeveryotherfaculty. ThatpalefaceandflamingglanceappearedtoVillefortlikeafrightfulapparition. Eachtimehehadbeenbroughtintocontactwithhisfather,somethingterriblehadhappened.“Seewhattheyhavedone!” criedMorrel,withonehandleaningonthebackofthechair,andtheotherextendedtowardsValentine.“See,myfather,see!” Villefortdrewbackandlookedwithastonishmentontheyoungman,who,almostastrangertohim,calledNoirtierhisfather. Atthismomentthewholesouloftheoldmanseemedcentredinhiseyeswhichbecamebloodshot;theveinsofthethroatswelled;hischeeksandtemplesbecamepurple,asthoughhewasstruckwithepilepsy;nothingwaswantingtocompletethisbuttheutteranceofacry. Andthecryissuedfromhispores,ifwemaythusspeak—acryfrightfulinitssilence. D’Avrignyrushedtowardstheoldmanandmadehiminhaleapowerfulrestorative. “Sir,”criedMorrel,seizingthemoisthandoftheparalytic,“theyaskmewhoIam,andwhatrightIhavetobehere.Oh,youknowit,tellthem,tellthem!” Andtheyoungman’svoicewaschokedbysobs. Asfortheoldman,hischestheavedwithhispantingrespiration. Onecouldhavethoughtthathewasundergoingtheagoniesprecedingdeath. Atlength,happierthantheyoungman,whosobbedwithoutweeping,tearsglistenedintheeyesofNoirtier. “Tellthem,”saidMorrelinahoarsevoice,“tellthemthatIamherbetrothed. Tellthemshewasmybeloved,mynoblegirl,myonlyblessingintheworld. Tellthem—oh,tellthem,thatcorpsebelongstome!” Theyoungmanoverwhelmedbytheweightofhisanguish,fellheavilyonhiskneesbeforethebed,whichhisfingersgraspedwithconvulsiveenergy. D’Avrigny,unabletobearthesightofthistouchingemotion,turnedaway;andVillefort,withoutseekinganyfurtherexplanation,andattractedtowardshimbytheirresistiblemagnetismwhichdrawsustowardsthosewhohavelovedthepeopleforwhomwemourn,extendedhishandtowardstheyoungman. ButMorrelsawnothing;hehadgraspedthehandofValentine,andunabletoweepventedhisagonyingroansashebitthesheets. Forsometimenothingwasheardinthatchamberbutsobs,exclamations,andprayers. AtlengthVillefort,themostcomposedofall,spoke:“Sir,”saidhetoMaximilian,“yousayyoulovedValentine,thatyouwerebetrothedtoher. Iknewnothingofthisengagement,ofthislove,yetI,herfather,forgiveyou,forIseethatyourgriefisrealanddeep;andbesidesmyownsorrowistoogreatforangertofindaplaceinmyheart. Butyouseethattheangelwhomyouhopedforhasleftthisearth—shehasnothingmoretodowiththeadorationofmen. Takealastfarewell,sir,ofhersadremains;takethehandyouexpectedtopossessoncemorewithinyourown,andthenseparateyourselffromherforever. Valentinenowrequiresonlytheministrationsofthepriest.” “Youaremistaken,sir,”exclaimedMorrel,raisinghimselfononeknee,hisheartpiercedbyamoreacutepangthananyhehadyetfelt—”youaremistaken;Valentine,dyingasshehas,notonlyrequiresapriest,butanavenger. You,M.deVillefort,sendforthepriest;Iwillbetheavenger.” “Whatdoyoumean,sir?”askedVillefort,tremblingatthenewideainspiredbythedeliriumofMorrel. “Itellyou,sir,thattwopersonsexistinyou;thefatherhasmournedsufficiently,nowlettheprocureurfulfilhisoffice.” TheeyesofNoirtierglistened,andd’Avrignyapproached. “Gentlemen,”saidMorrel,readingallthatpassedthroughthemindsofthewitnessestothescene,“IknowwhatIamsaying,andyouknowaswellasIdowhatIamabouttosay—Valentinehasbeenassassinated!” Villeforthunghishead,d’Avrignyapproachednearer,andNoirtiersaid“Yes”withhiseyes. “Now,sir,”continuedMorrel,“inthesedaysnoonecandisappearbyviolentmeanswithoutsomeinquiriesbeingmadeastothecauseofherdisappearance,evenwereshenotayoung,beautiful,andadorablecreaturelikeValentine. Mr.Procureur,”saidMorrelwithincreasingvehemence,“nomercyisallowed;Idenouncethecrime;itisyourplacetoseektheassassin.” Theyoungman’simplacableeyesinterrogatedVillefort,who,onhisside,glancedfromNoirtiertod’Avrigny. Butinsteadoffindingsympathyintheeyesofthedoctorandhisfather,heonlysawanexpressionasinflexibleasthatofMaximilian.“Yes,”indicatedtheoldman. “Assuredly,”saidd’Avrigny. “Sir,”saidVillefort,strivingtostruggleagainstthistripleforceandhisownemotion,—”sir,youaredeceived;noonecommitscrimeshere.Iamstrickenbyfate. Itishorrible,indeed,butnooneassassinates.” TheeyesofNoirtierlightedupwithrage,andd’Avrignypreparedtospeak. Morrel,however,extendedhisarm,andcommandedsilence. “AndIsaythatmurdersarecommittedhere,”saidMorrel,whosevoice,thoughlowerintone,lostnoneofitsterribledistinctness:“Itellyouthatthisisthefourthvictimwithinthelastfourmonths. Itellyou,Valentine’slifewasattemptedbypoisonfourdaysago,thoughsheescaped,owingtotheprecautionsofM.Noirtier. Itellyouthatthedosehasbeendouble,thepoisonchanged,andthatthistimeithassucceeded. ItellyouthatyouknowthesethingsaswellasIdo,sincethisgentlemanhasforewarnedyou,bothasadoctorandasafriend.” “Oh,yourave,sir,”exclaimedVillefort,invainendeavoringtoescapethenetinwhichhewastaken. “Irave?”saidMorrel;“well,then,IappealtoM.d’Avrignyhimself. Askhim,sir,ifherecollectsthewordsheutteredinthegardenofthishouseonthenightofMadamedeSaint–Meran’sdeath. Youthoughtyourselvesalone,andtalkedaboutthattragicaldeath,andthefatalityyoumentionedthenisthesamewhichhascausedthemurderofValentine.” Villefortandd’Avrignyexchangedlooks. “Yes,yes,”continuedMorrel;“recallthescene,forthewordsyouthoughtwereonlygiventosilenceandsolitudefellintomyears. Certainly,afterwitnessingtheculpableindolencemanifestedbyM.deVilleforttowardshisownrelations,Ioughttohavedenouncedhimtotheauthorities;thenIshouldnothavebeenanaccomplicetothydeath,asInowam,sweet,belovedValentine;buttheaccompliceshallbecometheavenger. Thisfourthmurderisapparenttoall,andifthyfatherabandonthee,Valentine,itisI,andIswearit,thatshallpursuetheassassin.” Andthistime,asthoughnaturehadatleasttakencompassiononthevigorousframe,nearlyburstingwithitsownstrength,thewordsofMorrelwerestifledinhisthroat;hisbreastheaved;thetears,solongrebellious,gushedfromhiseyes;andhethrewhimselfweepingonhiskneesbythesideofthebed. Thend’Avrignyspoke.“AndI,too,”heexclaimedinalowvoice,“IunitewithM.Morrelindemandingjusticeforcrime;mybloodboilsattheideaofhavingencouragedamurdererbymycowardlyconcession.” “Oh,mercifulheavens!”murmuredVillefort.Morrelraisedhishead,andreadingtheeyesoftheoldman,whichgleamedwithunnaturallustre,—”Stay,”hesaid,“M.Noirtierwishestospeak.” “Yes,”indicatedNoirtier,withanexpressionthemoreterrible,fromallhisfacultiesbeingcentredinhisglance. “Doyouknowtheassassin?”askedMorrel. “Andwillyoudirectus?”exclaimedtheyoungman.“Listen,M.d’Avrigny,listen!” NoirtierlookeduponMorrelwithoneofthosemelancholysmileswhichhadsooftenmadeValentinehappy,andthusfixedhisattention. Then,havingrivetedtheeyesofhisinterlocutoronhisown,heglancedtowardsthedoor. “Doyouwishmetoleave?”saidMorrel,sadly. “Alas,alas,sir,havepityonme!” Theoldman’seyesremainedfixedonthedoor. “MayI,atleast,return?”askedMorrel. “WhomamItotakewithme?Theprocureur?” “YouwishtoremainalonewithM.deVillefort?” “Oh,”saidVillefort,inexpressiblydelightedtothinkthattheinquiriesweretobemadebyhimalone,—”oh,besatisfied,Icanunderstandmyfather.” D’Avrignytooktheyoungman’sarm,andledhimoutoftheroom. Amorethandeathlikesilencethenreignedinthehouse. Attheendofaquarterofanhourafalteringfootstepwasheard,andVillefortappearedatthedooroftheapartmentwhered’AvrignyandMorrelhadbeenstaying,oneabsorbedinmeditation,theotheringrief. “Youcancome,”hesaid,andledthembacktoNoirtier.MorrellookedattentivelyonVillefort. Hisfacewaslivid,largedropsrolleddownhisface,andinhisfingersheheldthefragmentsofaquillpenwhichhehadtorntoatoms. “Gentlemen,”hesaidinahoarsevoice,“givemeyourwordofhonorthatthishorriblesecretshallforeverremainburiedamongstourselves!”Thetwomendrewback. “Ientreatyou.”—continuedVillefort. “But,”saidMorrel,“theculprit—themurderer—theassassin.” “Donotalarmyourself,sir;justicewillbedone,”saidVillefort. “Myfatherhasrevealedtheculprit’sname;myfatherthirstsforrevengeasmuchasyoudo,yetevenheconjuresyouasIdotokeepthissecret.Doyounot,father?” “Yes,”resolutelyrepliedNoirtier.Morrelsufferedanexclamationofhorrorandsurprisetoescapehim. “Oh,sir,”saidVillefort,arrestingMaximilianbythearm,“ifmyfather,theinflexibleman,makesthisrequest,itisbecauseheknows,beassured,thatValentinewillbeterriblyrevenged.Isitnotso,father?” Theoldmanmadeasignintheaffirmative. Villefortcontinued:“Heknowsme,andIhavepledgedmywordtohim. Restassured,gentlemen,thatwithinthreedays,inalesstimethanjusticewoulddemand,therevengeIshallhavetakenforthemurderofmychildwillbesuchastomaketheboldesthearttremble;”andashespokethesewordshegroundhisteeth,andgraspedtheoldman’ssenselesshand. “Willthispromisebefulfilled,M.Noirtier?”askedMorrel,whiled’Avrignylookedinquiringly. “Yes,”repliedNoirtierwithanexpressionofsinisterjoy. “Swear,then,”saidVillefort,joiningthehandsofMorrelandd’Avrigny,“swearthatyouwillsparethehonorofmyhouse,andleavemetoavengemychild.” D’Avrignyturnedroundandutteredaveryfeeble“Yes,”butMorrel,disengaginghishand,rushedtothebed,andafterhavingpressedthecoldlipsofValentinewithhisown,hurriedlyleft,utteringalong,deepgroanofdespairandanguish. Wehavebeforestatedthatalltheservantshadfled. M.deVillefortwasthereforeobligedtorequestM.d’Avrignytosuperintendallthearrangementsconsequentuponadeathinalargecity,moreespeciallyadeathundersuchsuspiciouscircumstances. Itwassomethingterribletowitnessthesilentagony,themutedespairofNoirtier,whosetearssilentlyrolleddownhischeeks. Villefortretiredtohisstudy,andd’Avrignylefttosummonthedoctorofthemayoralty,whoseofficeitistoexaminebodiesafterdecease,andwhoisexpresslynamed“thedoctorofthedead.” M.Noirtiercouldnotbepersuadedtoquithisgrandchild. AttheendofaquarterofanhourM.d’Avrignyreturnedwithhisassociate;theyfoundtheoutergateclosed,andnotaservantremaininginthehouse;Villeforthimselfwasobligedtoopentothem. Buthestoppedonthelanding;hehadnotthecouragetoagainvisitthedeathchamber. Thetwodoctors,therefore,enteredtheroomalone. Noirtierwasnearthebed,pale,motionless,andsilentasthecorpse. Thedistrictdoctorapproachedwiththeindifferenceofamanaccustomedtospendhalfhistimeamongstthedead;hethenliftedthesheetwhichwasplacedovertheface,andjustunclosedthelips. “Alas,”saidd’Avrigny,“sheisindeeddead,poorchild!” “Yes,”answeredthedoctorlaconically,droppingthesheethehadraised. Noirtierutteredakindofhoarse,rattlingsound;theoldman’seyessparkled,andthegooddoctorunderstoodthathewishedtobeholdhischild. Hethereforeapproachedthebed,andwhilehiscompanionwasdippingthefingerswithwhichhehadtouchedthelipsofthecorpseinchlorideoflime,heuncoveredthecalmandpaleface,whichlookedlikethatofasleepingangel. Atear,whichappearedintheoldman’seye,expressedhisthankstothedoctor. Thedoctorofthedeadthenlaidhispermitonthecornerofthetable,andhavingfulfilledhisduty,wasconductedoutbyd’Avrigny. Villefortmetthematthedoorofhisstudy;havinginafewwordsthankedthedistrictdoctor,heturnedtod’Avrigny,andsaid,—”Andnowthepriest.” “IsthereanyparticularpriestyouwishtopraywithValentine?”askedd’Avrigny. “No.”saidVillefort;“fetchthenearest.” “Thenearest,”saidthedistrictdoctor,“isagoodItalianabbe,wholivesnextdoortoyou.ShallIcallonhimasIpass?” “D’Avrigny,”saidVillefort,“besokind,Ibeseechyou,astoaccompanythisgentleman. Hereisthekeyofthedoor,sothatyoucangoinandoutasyouplease;youwillbringthepriestwithyou,andwillobligemebyintroducinghimintomychild’sroom.” “Ionlywishtobealone.Youwillexcuseme,willyounot? Apriestcanunderstandafather’sgrief.” AndM.deVillefort,givingthekeytod’Avrigny,againbadefarewelltothestrangedoctor,andretiredtohisstudy,wherehebegantowork. Forsometemperamentsworkisaremedyforallafflictions. Asthedoctorsenteredthestreet,theysawamaninacassockstandingonthethresholdofthenextdoor. “ThisistheabbeofwhomIspoke,”saidthedoctortod’Avrigny.D’Avrignyaccostedthepriest. “Sir,”hesaid,“areyoudisposedtoconferagreatobligationonanunhappyfatherwhohasjustlosthisdaughter? ImeanM.deVillefort,theking’sattorney.” “Ah,”saidthepriest,inamarkedItalianaccent;“yes,Ihaveheardthatdeathisinthathouse.” “ThenIneednottellyouwhatkindofserviceherequiresofyou.” “Iwasabouttooffermyself,sir,”saidthepriest;“itisourmissiontoforestallourduties.” “Iknowit,sir;theservantswhofledfromthehouseinformedme.IalsoknowthathernameisValentine,andIhavealreadyprayedforher.” “Thankyou,sir,”saidd’Avrigny;“sinceyouhavecommencedyoursacredoffice,deigntocontinueit.Comeandwatchbythedead,andallthewretchedfamilywillbegratefultoyou.” “Iamgoing,sir;andIdonothesitatetosaythatnoprayerswillbemoreferventthanmine.” D’Avrignytookthepriest’shand,andwithoutmeetingVillefort,whowasengagedinhisstudy,theyreachedValentine’sroom,whichonthefollowingnightwastobeoccupiedbytheundertakers. Onenteringtheroom,Noirtier’seyesmetthoseoftheabbe,andnodoubthereadsomeparticularexpressioninthem,forheremainedintheroom. D’Avrignyrecommendedtheattentionofthepriesttothelivingaswellastothedead,andtheabbepromisedtodevotehisprayerstoValentineandhisattentionstoNoirtier. Inorder,doubtless,thathemightnotbedisturbedwhilefulfillinghissacredmission,thepriestroseassoonasd’Avrignydeparted,andnotonlyboltedthedoorthroughwhichthedoctorhadjustleft,butalsothatleadingtoMadamedeVillefort’sroom.