AtthesamemomentM.deVillefort’svoicewasheardcallingfromhisstudy,“Whatisthematter?” MorrellookedatNoirtierwhohadrecoveredhisself–command,andwithaglanceindicatedtheclosetwhereoncebeforeundersomewhatsimilarcircumstances,hehadtakenrefuge. Hehadonlytimetogethishatandthrowhimselfbreathlessintotheclosetwhentheprocureur’sfootstepwasheardinthepassage. Villefortsprangintotheroom,rantoValentine,andtookherinhisarms. “Aphysician,aphysician,—M.d’Avrigny!” criedVillefort;“orratherIwillgoforhimmyself.” Heflewfromtheapartment,andMorrelatthesamemomentdartedoutattheotherdoor. Hehadbeenstrucktotheheartbyafrightfulrecollection—theconversationhehadheardbetweenthedoctorandVillefortthenightofMadamedeSaint–Meran’sdeath,recurredtohim;thesesymptoms,toalessalarmingextent,werethesamewhichhadprecededthedeathofBarrois. AtthesametimeMonteCristo’svoiceseemedtoresoundinhisearwiththewordshehadheardonlytwohoursbefore,“Whateveryouwant,Morrel,cometome;Ihavegreatpower.” Morerapidlythanthought,hedarteddowntheRueMatignon,andthencetotheAvenuedesChampsElysees. MeanwhileM.deVillefortarrivedinahiredcabrioletatM.d’Avrigny’sdoor. Herangsoviolentlythattheporterwasalarmed. Villefortranup–stairswithoutsayingaword. Theporterknewhim,andlethimpass,onlycallingtohim,“Inhisstudy,MonsieurProcureur—inhisstudy!” Villefortpushed,orratherforced,thedooropen.“Ah,”saidthedoctor,“isityou?” “Yes,”saidVillefort,closingthedoorafterhim,“itisI,whoamcomeinmyturntoaskyouifwearequitealone.Doctor,myhouseisaccursed!” “What?”saidthelatterwithapparentcoolness,butwithdeepemotion,“haveyouanotherinvalid?” “Yes,doctor,”criedVillefort,clutchinghishair,“yes!” D’Avrigny’slookimplied,“Itoldyouitwouldbeso.” Thenheslowlyutteredthesewords,“Whoisnowdyinginyourhouse? WhatnewvictimisgoingtoaccuseyouofweaknessbeforeGod?” AmournfulsobburstfromVillefort’sheart;heapproachedthedoctor,andseizinghisarm,—”Valentine,”saidhe,“itisValentine’sturn!” “Yourdaughter?”criedd’Avrignywithgriefandsurprise. “Youseeyouweredeceived,”murmuredthemagistrate;“comeandseeher,andonherbedofagonyentreatherpardonforhavingsuspectedher.” “Eachtimeyouhaveappliedtome,”saidthedoctor,“ithasbeentoolate;stillIwillgo.Butletusmakehaste,sir;withtheenemiesyouhavetodowiththereisnotimetobelost.” “Oh,thistime,doctor,youshallnothavetoreproachmewithweakness.ThistimeIwillknowtheassassin,andwillpursuehim.” “Letustryfirsttosavethevictimbeforewethinkofrevengingher,”saidd’Avrigny.“Come.” ThesamecabrioletwhichhadbroughtVilleforttookthembackatfullspeed,andatthismomentMorrelrappedatMonteCristo’sdoor. ThecountwasinhisstudyandwasreadingwithanangrylooksomethingwhichBertucciohadbroughtinhaste. HearingthenameofMorrel,whohadlefthimonlytwohoursbefore,thecountraisedhishead,arose,andsprangtomeethim.“Whatisthematter,Maximilian?” askedhe;“youarepale,andtheperspirationrollsfromyourforehead.”Morrelfellintoachair. “Yes,”saidhe,“Icamequickly;Iwantedtospeaktoyou.” “Areallyourfamilywell?”askedthecount,withanaffectionatebenevolence,whosesinceritynoonecouldforamomentdoubt. “Thankyou,count—thankyou,”saidtheyoungman,evidentlyembarrassedhowtobegintheconversation;“yes,everyoneinmyfamilyiswell.” “Somuchthebetter;yetyouhavesomethingtotellme?”repliedthecountwithincreasedanxiety. “Yes,”saidMorrel,“itistrue;Ihavebutnowleftahousewheredeathhasjustentered,toruntoyou.” “AreyouthencomefromM.deMorcerf’s?”askedMonteCristo. “No,”saidMorrel;“issomeonedeadinhishouse?” “Thegeneralhasjustblownhisbrainsout,”repliedMonteCristowithgreatcoolness. “Oh,whatadreadfulevent!”criedMaximilian. “Notforthecountess,orforAlbert,”saidMonteCristo;“adeadfatherorhusbandisbetterthanadishonoredone,—bloodwashesoutshame.” “Poorcountess,”saidMaximilian,“Ipityherverymuch;sheissonobleawoman!” “PityAlbertalso,Maximilian;forbelievemeheistheworthysonofthecountess.Butletusreturntoyourself.Youhavehastenedtome—canIhavethehappinessofbeingusefultoyou?” “Yes,Ineedyourhelp:thatisIthoughtlikeamadmanthatyoucouldlendmeyourassistanceinacasewhereGodalonecansuccorme.” “Tellmewhatitis,”repliedMonteCristo. “Oh,”saidMorrel,“Iknownot,indeed,ifImayrevealthissecrettomortalears,butfatalityimpelsme,necessityconstrainsme,count”—Morrelhesitated.“DoyouthinkIloveyou?” saidMonteCristo,takingtheyoungman’shandaffectionatelyinhis. “Oh,youencourageme,andsomethingtellsmethere,”placinghishandonhisheart,“thatIoughttohavenosecretfromyou.” “Youareright,Morrel;Godisspeakingtoyourheart,andyourheartspeakstoyou.Tellmewhatitsays.” “Count,willyouallowmetosendBaptistintoinquireaftersomeoneyouknow?” “Iamatyourservice,andstillmoremyservants.” “Oh,Icannotliveifsheisnotbetter.” “ShallIringforBaptistin?” “No,Iwillgoandspeaktohimmyself.”Morrelwentout,calledBaptistin,andwhisperedafewwordstohim.Thevaletrandirectly.“Well,haveyousent?”askedMonteCristo,seeingMorrelreturn. “Yes,andnowIshallbemorecalm.” “YouknowIamwaiting,”saidMonteCristo,smiling. “Yes,andIwilltellyou.OneeveningIwasinagarden;aclumpoftreesconcealedme;noonesuspectedIwasthere. Twopersonspassednearme—allowmetoconcealtheirnamesforthepresent;theywerespeakinginanundertone,andyetIwassointerestedinwhattheysaidthatIdidnotloseasingleword.” “Thisisagloomyintroduction,ifImayjudgefromyourpallorandshuddering,Morrel.” “Oh,yes,verygloomy,myfriend.Someonehadjustdiedinthehousetowhichthatgardenbelonged. OneofthepersonswhoseconversationIoverheardwasthemasterofthehouse;theother,thephysician. Theformerwasconfidingtothelatterhisgriefandfear,foritwasthesecondtimewithinamonththatdeathhadsuddenlyandunexpectedlyenteredthathousewhichwasapparentlydestinedtodestructionbysomeexterminatingangel,asanobjectofGod’sanger.” “Ah,indeed?”saidMonteCristo,lookingearnestlyattheyoungman,andbyanimperceptiblemovementturninghischair,sothatheremainedintheshadewhilethelightfellfullonMaximilian’sface. “Yes,”continuedMorrel,“deathhadenteredthathousetwicewithinonemonth.” “Andwhatdidthedoctoranswer?”askedMonteCristo. “Hereplied—hereplied,thatthedeathwasnotanaturalone,andmustbeattributed”— “Indeed?”saidMonteCristowithaslightcoughwhichinmomentsofextremeemotionhelpedhimtodisguiseablush,orhispallor,ortheintenseinterestwithwhichhelistened;“indeed,Maximilian,didyouhearthat?” “Yes,mydearcount,Iheardit;andthedoctoraddedthatifanotherdeathoccurredinasimilarwayhemustappealtojustice.” MonteCristolistened,orappearedtodoso,withthegreatestcalmness. “Well,”saidMaximilian,“deathcameathirdtime,andneitherthemasterofthehousenorthedoctorsaidaword. Deathisnow,perhaps,strikingafourthblow. Count,whatamIboundtodo,beinginpossessionofthissecret?” “Mydearfriend,”saidMonteCristo,“youappeartoberelatinganadventurewhichweallknowbyheart. Iknowthehousewhereyouheardit,oroneverysimilartoit;ahousewithagarden,amaster,aphysician,andwheretherehavebeenthreeunexpectedandsuddendeaths. Well,Ihavenotinterceptedyourconfidence,andyetIknowallthataswellasyou,andIhavenoconscientiousscruples.No,itdoesnotconcernme. YousayanexterminatingangelappearstohavedevotedthathousetoGod’sanger—well,whosaysyoursuppositionisnotreality? Donotnoticethingswhichthosewhoseinterestitistoseethempassover. IfitisGod’sjustice,insteadofhisanger,whichiswalkingthroughthathouse,Maximilian,turnawayyourfaceandlethisjusticeaccomplishitspurpose.”Morrelshuddered. Therewassomethingmournful,solemn,andterribleinthecount’smanner. “Besides,”continuedhe,insochangedatonethatnoonewouldhavesupposeditwasthesamepersonspeaking—”besides,whosaysthatitwillbeginagain?” “Ithasreturned,count,”exclaimedMorrel;“thatiswhyIhastenedtoyou.” “Well,whatdoyouwishmetodo?Doyouwishme,forinstance,togiveinformationtotheprocureur?” MonteCristoutteredthelastwordswithsomuchmeaningthatMorrel,startingup,criedout,“YouknowofwhomIspeak,count,doyounot?” “Perfectlywell,mygoodfriend;andIwillproveittoyoubyputtingthedotstothe‘i,’orratherbynamingthepersons. YouwerewalkingoneeveninginM.deVillefort’sgarden;fromwhatyourelate,IsupposeittohavebeentheeveningofMadamedeSaint–Meran’sdeath. YouheardM.deVilleforttalkingtoM.d’AvrignyaboutthedeathofM.deSaint–Meran,andthatnolesssurprising,ofthecountess. M.d’Avrignysaidhebelievedtheybothproceededfrompoison;andyou,honestman,haveeversincebeenaskingyourheartandsoundingyourconsciencetoknowifyououghttoexposeorconcealthissecret.Whydoyoutormentthem? ‘Conscience,whathastthoutodowithme?’asSternesaid. Mydearfellow,letthemsleepon,iftheyareasleep;letthemgrowpaleintheirdrowsiness,iftheyaredisposedtodoso,andpraydoyouremaininpeace,whohavenoremorsetodisturbyou.” DeepgriefwasdepictedonMorrel’sfeatures;heseizedMonteCristo’shand.“Butitisbeginningagain,Isay!” “Well,”saidtheCount,astonishedathisperseverance,whichhecouldnotunderstand,andlookingstillmoreearnestlyatMaximilian,“letitbeginagain,—itislikethehouseoftheAtreidae;[*]Godhascondemnedthem,andtheymustsubmittotheirpunishment. Theywillalldisappear,likethefabricschildrenbuildwithcards,andwhichfall,onebyone,underthebreathoftheirbuilder,eveniftherearetwohundredofthem. ThreemonthssinceitwasM.deSaint–Meran;MadamedeSaint–Merantwomonthssince;theotherdayitwasBarrois;to–day,theoldNoirtier,oryoungValentine.”“Youknewit?” criedMorrel,insuchaparoxysmofterrorthatMonteCristostarted,—hewhomthefallingheavenswouldhavefoundunmoved;“youknewit,andsaidnothing?” *IntheoldGreeklegendtheAtreidae,orchildrenof Atreus,weredoomedtopunishmentbecauseoftheabominable crimeoftheirfather.TheAgamemnonofAeschylusisbased “Andwhatisittome?”repliedMonteCristo,shrugginghisshoulders;“doIknowthosepeople? andmustIlosetheonetosavetheother? Faith,no,forbetweentheculpritandthevictimIhavenochoice.” “ButI,”criedMorrel,groaningwithsorrow,“Iloveher!” “Youlove?—whom?”criedMonteCristo,startingtohisfeet,andseizingthetwohandswhichMorrelwasraisingtowardsheaven. “Ilovemostfondly—Ilovemadly—Iloveasamanwhowouldgivehislife–bloodtospareheratear—IloveValentinedeVillefort,whoisbeingmurderedatthismoment!Doyouunderstandme? Iloveher;andIaskGodandyouhowIcansaveher?” MonteCristoutteredacrywhichthoseonlycanconceivewhohaveheardtheroarofawoundedlion. “Unhappyman,”criedhe,wringinghishandsinhisturn;“youloveValentine,—thatdaughterofanaccursedrace!” NeverhadMorrelwitnessedsuchanexpression—neverhadsoterribleaneyeflashedbeforehisface—neverhadthegeniusofterrorhehadsooftenseen,eitheronthebattle–fieldorinthemurderousnightsofAlgeria,shakenaroundhimmoredreadfulfire.Hedrewbackterrified. AsforMonteCristo,afterthisebullitionheclosedhiseyesasifdazzledbyinternallight. Inamomentherestrainedhimselfsopowerfullythatthetempestuousheavingofhisbreastsubsided,asturbulentandfoamingwavesyieldtothesun’sgenialinfluencewhenthecloudhaspassed. Thissilence,self–control,andstrugglelastedabouttwentyseconds,thenthecountraisedhispallidface. “See,”saidhe,“mydearfriend,howGodpunishesthemostthoughtlessandunfeelingmenfortheirindifference,bypresentingdreadfulscenestotheirview. I,whowaslookingon,aneagerandcuriousspectator,—I,whowaswatchingtheworkingofthismournfultragedy,—I,wholikeawickedangelwaslaughingattheevilmencommittedprotectedbysecrecy(asecretiseasilykeptbytherichandpowerful),IaminmyturnbittenbytheserpentwhosetortuouscourseIwaswatching,andbittentotheheart!” Morrelgroaned.“Come,come,”continuedthecount,“complaintsareunavailing,beaman,bestrong,befullofhope,forIamhereandwillwatchoveryou.”Morrelshookhisheadsorrowfully.“Itellyoutohope.Doyouunderstandme?”criedMonteCristo. “RememberthatIneverutteredafalsehoodandamneverdeceived. Itistwelveo’clock,Maximilian;thankheaventhatyoucameatnoonratherthanintheevening,orto–morrowmorning. Listen,Morrel—itisnoon;ifValentineisnotnowdead,shewillnotdie.” “Howso?”criedMorrel,“whenIleftherdying?” MonteCristopressedhishandstohisforehead. Whatwaspassinginthatbrain,soloadedwithdreadfulsecrets? Whatdoestheangeloflightortheangelofdarknesssaytothatmind,atonceimplacableandgenerous?Godonlyknows. MonteCristoraisedhisheadoncemore,andthistimehewascalmasachildawakingfromitssleep.“Maximilian,”saidhe,“returnhome. Icommandyounottostir—attemptnothing,nottoletyourcountenancebetrayathought,andIwillsendyoutidings.Go.” “Oh,count,youoverwhelmmewiththatcoolness.Haveyou,then,poweragainstdeath?Areyousuperhuman?Areyouanangel?” Andtheyoungman,whohadnevershrunkfromdanger,shrankbeforeMonteCristowithindescribableterror. ButMonteCristolookedathimwithsomelancholyandsweetasmile,thatMaximilianfeltthetearsfillinghiseyes. “Icandomuchforyou,myfriend,”repliedthecount.“Go;Imustbealone.” Morrel,subduedbytheextraordinaryascendancyMonteCristoexercisedovereverythingaroundhim,didnotendeavortoresistit.Hepressedthecount’shandandleft. HestoppedonemomentatthedoorforBaptistin,whomhesawintheRueMatignon,andwhowasrunning. Meanwhile,Villefortandd’Avrignyhadmadeallpossiblehaste,Valentinehadnotrevivedfromherfaintingfitontheirarrival,andthedoctorexaminedtheinvalidwithallthecarethecircumstancesdemanded,andwithaninterestwhichtheknowledgeofthesecretintensifiedtwofold. Villefort,closelywatchinghiscountenanceandhislips,awaitedtheresultoftheexamination. Noirtier,palerthaneventheyounggirl,moreeagerthanVillefortforthedecision,waswatchingalsointentlyandaffectionately. Atlastd’Avrignyslowlyutteredthesewords:—”sheisstillalive!” “Still?”criedVillefort;“oh,doctor,whatadreadfulwordisthat.” “Yes,”saidthephysician,“Irepeatit;sheisstillalive,andIamastonishedatit.” “Butisshesafe?”askedthefather. “Yes,sinceshelives.”Atthatmomentd’Avrigny’sglancemetNoirtier’seye. Itglistenedwithsuchextraordinaryjoy,sorichandfullofthought,thatthephysicianwasstruck. Heplacedtheyounggirlagainonthechair,—herlipswerescarcelydiscernible,theyweresopaleandwhite,aswellasherwholeface,—andremainedmotionless,lookingatNoirtier,whoappearedtoanticipateandcommendallhedid. “Sir,”saidd’AvrignytoVillefort,“callMademoiselleValentine’smaid,ifyouplease.” Villefortwenthimselftofindher;andd’AvrignyapproachedNoirtier.“Haveyousomethingtotellme?”askedhe. Theoldmanwinkedhiseyesexpressively,whichwemayrememberwashisonlywayofexpressinghisapproval. “Well,Iwillremainwithyou.”AtthismomentVillefortreturned,followedbythelady’smaid;andafterhercameMadamedeVillefort. “Whatisthematter,then,withthisdearchild? shehasjustleftme,andshecomplainedofbeingindisposed,butIdidnotthinkseriouslyofit.” Theyoungwomanwithtearsinhereyesandeverymarkofaffectionofatruemother,approachedValentineandtookherhand. D’AvrignycontinuedtolookatNoirtier;hesawtheeyesoftheoldmandilateandbecomeround,hischeeksturnpaleandtremble;theperspirationstoodindropsuponhisforehead. “Ah,”saidhe,involuntarilyfollowingNoirtier’seyes,whichwerefixedonMadamedeVillefort,whorepeated,—”Thispoorchildwouldbebetterinbed.Come,Fanny,wewillputhertobed.” M.d’Avrigny,whosawthatwouldbeameansofhisremainingalonewithNoirtier,expressedhisopinionthatitwasthebestthingthatcouldbedone;butheforbadethatanythingshouldbegiventoherexceptwhatheordered. TheycarriedValentineaway;shehadrevived,butcouldscarcelymoveorspeak,soshakenwasherframebytheattack. Shehad,however,justpowertogiveonepartinglooktohergrandfather,whoinlosingherseemedtoberesigninghisverysoul. D’Avrignyfollowedtheinvalid,wroteaprescription,orderedVilleforttotakeacabriolet,goinpersontoachemist’stogettheprescribedmedicine,bringithimself,andwaitforhiminhisdaughter’sroom. Then,havingrenewedhisinjunctionnottogiveValentineanything,hewentdownagaintoNoirtier,shutthedoorscarefully,andafterconvincinghimselfthatnoonewaslistening,—”Doyou,”saidhe,“knowanythingofthisyounglady’sillness?” “Wehavenotimetolose;Iwillquestion,anddoyouanswerme.”Noirtiermadeasignthathewasreadytoanswer.“Didyouanticipatetheaccidentwhichhashappenedtoyourgranddaughter?” “Yes.”D’Avrignyreflectedamoment;thenapproachingNoirtier,—”PardonwhatIamgoingtosay,”addedhe,“butnoindicationshouldbeneglectedinthisterriblesituation.DidyouseepoorBarroisdie?”Noirtierraisedhiseyestoheaven.“Doyouknowofwhathedied!” askedd’Avrigny,placinghishandonNoirtier’sshoulder. “Doyouthinkhediedanaturaldeath?”AsortofsmilewasdiscernibleonthemotionlesslipsofNoirtier. “ThenyouhavethoughtthatBarroiswaspoisoned?” “Doyouthinkthepoisonhefellavictimtowasintendedforhim?” “DoyouthinkthesamehandwhichunintentionallystruckBarroishasnowattackedValentine?” “Thenwillshedietoo?”askedd’Avrigny,fixinghispenetratinggazeonNoirtier. Hewatchedtheeffectofthisquestionontheoldman. “No,”repliedhewithanairoftriumphwhichwouldhavepuzzledthemostcleverdiviner.“Thenyouhope?”saidd’Avrigny,withsurprise. “Whatdoyouhope?”Theoldmanmadehimunderstandwithhiseyesthathecouldnotanswer. “Ah,yes,itistrue,”murmuredd’Avrigny. Then,turningtoNoirtier,—”Doyouhopetheassassinwillbetried?” “ThenyouhopethepoisonwilltakenoeffectonValentine?” “Itisnonewstoyou,”addedd’Avrigny,“totellyouthatanattempthasbeenmadetopoisonher?” Theoldmanmadeasignthatheentertainednodoubtuponthesubject. “ThenhowdoyouhopeValentinewillescape?” Noirtierkepthiseyessteadfastlyfixedonthesamespot. D’Avrignyfollowedthedirectionandsawthattheywerefixedonabottlecontainingthemixturewhichhetookeverymorning.“Ah,indeed?” saidd’Avrigny,struckwithasuddenthought,“hasitoccurredtoyou”—Noirtierdidnotlethimfinish.“Yes,”saidhe. “Topreparehersystemtoresistpoison?” “Byaccustomingherbydegrees”— “Yes,yes,yes,”saidNoirtier,delightedtobeunderstood. “Ofcourse.IhadtoldyouthattherewasbrucineinthemixtureIgiveyou.” “Andbyaccustominghertothatpoison,youhaveendeavoredtoneutralizetheeffectofasimilarpoison?”Noirtier’sjoycontinued. “Andyouhavesucceeded,”exclaimedd’Avrigny. “WithoutthatprecautionValentinewouldhavediedbeforeassistancecouldhavebeenprocured. Thedosehasbeenexcessive,butshehasonlybeenshakenbyit;andthistime,atanyrate,Valentinewillnotdie.” Asuperhumanjoyexpandedtheoldman’seyes,whichwereraisedtowardsheavenwithanexpressionofinfinitegratitude.AtthismomentVillefortreturned. “Here,doctor,”saidhe,“iswhatyousentmefor.” “Wasthispreparedinyourpresence?” “Yes,”repliedtheprocureur. “Haveyounotletitgooutofyourhands?” “No.”D’Avrignytookthebottle,pouredsomedropsofthemixtureitcontainedinthehollowofhishand,andswallowedthem. “Well,”saidhe,“letusgotoValentine;Iwillgiveinstructionstoeveryone,andyou,M.deVillefort,willyourselfseethatnoonedeviatesfromthem.” Atthemomentwhend’AvrignywasreturningtoValentine’sroom,accompaniedbyVillefort,anItalianpriest,ofseriousdemeanorandcalmandfirmtone,hiredforhisusethehouseadjoiningthehotelofM.deVillefort. Nooneknewhowthethreeformertenantsofthathouseleftit. Abouttwohoursafterwardsitsfoundationwasreportedtobeunsafe;butthereportdidnotpreventthenewoccupantestablishinghimselftherewithhismodestfurniturethesamedayatfiveo’clock. Theleasewasdrawnupforthree,six,ornineyearsbythenewtenant,who,accordingtotheruleoftheproprietor,paidsixmonthsinadvance. Thisnewtenant,who,aswehavesaid,wasanItalian,wascalledIlSignorGiacomoBusoni. Workmenwereimmediatelycalledin,andthatsamenightthepassengersattheendofthefaubourgsawwithsurprisethatcarpentersandmasonswereoccupiedinrepairingthelowerpartofthetotteringhouse.