Thatevening,afterMr.Jacksonhadtakenhimselfaway,andtheladieshadretiredtotheirchintz–curtainedbedroom,NewlandArchermountedthoughtfullytohisownstudy. Avigilanthandhad,asusual,keptthefirealiveandthelamptrimmed;andtheroom,withitsrowsandrowsofbooks,itsbronzeandsteelstatuettesof"TheFencers"onthemantelpieceanditsmanyphotographsoffamouspictures,lookedsingularlyhome–likeandwelcoming. AshedroppedintohisarmchairnearthefirehiseyesrestedonalargephotographofMayWelland,whichtheyounggirlhadgivenhiminthefirstdaysoftheirromance,andwhichhadnowdisplacedalltheotherportraitsonthetable. Withanewsenseofawehelookedatthefrankforehead,seriouseyesandgayinnocentmouthoftheyoungcreaturewhosesoul'scustodianhewastobe. Thatterrifyingproductofthesocialsystemhebelongedtoandbelievedin,theyounggirlwhoknewnothingandexpectedeverything,lookedbackathimlikeastrangerthroughMayWelland'sfamiliarfeatures;andoncemoreitwasborneinonhimthatmarriagewasnotthesafeanchoragehehadbeentaughttothink,butavoyageonunchartedseas. ThecaseoftheCountessOlenskahadstirredupoldsettledconvictionsandsetthemdriftingdangerouslythroughhismind. Hisownexclamation:"Womenshouldbefree—asfreeasweare,"strucktotherootofaproblemthatitwasagreedinhisworldtoregardasnon–existent. "Nice"women,howeverwronged,wouldneverclaimthekindoffreedomhemeant,andgenerous–mindedmenlikehimselfweretherefore—intheheatofargument—themorechivalrouslyreadytoconcedeittothem. Suchverbalgenerositieswereinfactonlyahumbuggingdisguiseoftheinexorableconventionsthattiedthingstogetherandboundpeopledowntotheoldpattern. Butherehewaspledgedtodefend,onthepartofhisbetrothed'scousin,conductthat,onhisownwife'spart,wouldjustifyhimincallingdownonherallthethundersofChurchandState. Ofcoursethedilemmawaspurelyhypothetical;sincehewasn'tablackguardPolishnobleman,itwasabsurdtospeculatewhathiswife'srightswouldbeifheWERE. ButNewlandArcherwastooimaginativenottofeelthat,inhiscaseandMay's,thetiemightgallforreasonsfarlessgrossandpalpable. Whatcouldheandshereallyknowofeachother,sinceitwashisduty,asa"decent"fellow,toconcealhispastfromher,andhers,asamarriageablegirl,tohavenopasttoconceal? Whatif,forsomeoneofthesubtlerreasonsthatwouldtellwithbothofthem,theyshouldtireofeachother,misunderstandorirritateeachother? Hereviewedhisfriends'marriages—thesupposedlyhappyones—andsawnonethatanswered,evenremotely,tothepassionateandtendercomradeshipwhichhepicturedashispermanentrelationwithMayWelland. Heperceivedthatsuchapicturepresupposed,onherpart,theexperience,theversatility,thefreedomofjudgment,whichshehadbeencarefullytrainednottopossess;andwithashiverofforebodinghesawhismarriagebecomingwhatmostoftheothermarriagesabouthimwere:adullassociationofmaterialandsocialinterestsheldtogetherbyignoranceontheonesideandhypocrisyontheother. LawrenceLeffertsoccurredtohimasthehusbandwhohadmostcompletelyrealisedthisenviableideal. Asbecamethehigh–priestofform,hehadformedawifesocompletelytohisownconveniencethat,inthemostconspicuousmomentsofhisfrequentlove–affairswithothermen'swives,shewentaboutinsmilingunconsciousness,sayingthat"Lawrencewassofrightfullystrict";andhadbeenknowntoblushindignantly,andaverthergaze,whensomeonealludedinherpresencetothefactthatJuliusBeaufort(asbecamea"foreigner"ofdoubtfulorigin)hadwhatwasknowninNewYorkas"anotherestablishment." ArchertriedtoconsolehimselfwiththethoughtthathewasnotquitesuchanassasLarryLefferts,norMaysuchasimpletonaspoorGertrude;butthedifferencewasafteralloneofintelligenceandnotofstandards. Inrealitytheyalllivedinakindofhieroglyphicworld,wheretherealthingwasneversaidordoneoreventhought,butonlyrepresentedbyasetofarbitrarysigns;aswhenMrs.Welland,whoknewexactlywhyArcherhadpressedhertoannounceherdaughter'sengagementattheBeaufortball(andhadindeedexpectedhimtodonoless),yetfeltobligedtosimulatereluctance,andtheairofhavinghadherhandforced,quiteas,inthebooksonPrimitiveManthatpeopleofadvancedculturewerebeginningtoread,thesavagebrideisdraggedwithshrieksfromherparents'tent. Theresult,ofcourse,wasthattheyounggirlwhowasthecentreofthiselaboratesystemofmystificationremainedthemoreinscrutableforherveryfranknessandassurance. Shewasfrank,poordarling,becauseshehadnothingtoconceal,assuredbecausesheknewofnothingtobeonherguardagainst;andwithnobetterpreparationthanthis,shewastobeplungedovernightintowhatpeopleevasivelycalled"thefactsoflife." Theyoungmanwassincerelybutplacidlyinlove. Hedelightedintheradiantgoodlooksofhisbetrothed,inherhealth,herhorsemanship,hergraceandquicknessatgames,andtheshyinterestinbooksandideasthatshewasbeginningtodevelopunderhisguidance. (ShehadadvancedfarenoughtojoinhiminridiculingtheIdylsoftheKing,butnottofeelthebeautyofUlyssesandtheLotusEaters.) Shewasstraightforward,loyalandbrave;shehadasenseofhumour(chieflyprovedbyherlaughingatHISjokes);andhesuspected,inthedepthsofherinnocently–gazingsoul,aglowoffeelingthatitwouldbeajoytowaken. Butwhenhehadgonethebriefroundofherhereturneddiscouragedbythethoughtthatallthisfranknessandinnocencewereonlyanartificialproduct. Untrainedhumannaturewasnotfrankandinnocent;itwasfullofthetwistsanddefencesofaninstinctiveguile. Andhefelthimselfoppressedbythiscreationoffactitiouspurity,socunninglymanufacturedbyaconspiracyofmothersandauntsandgrandmothersandlong–deadancestresses,becauseitwassupposedtobewhathewanted,whathehadarightto,inorderthathemightexercisehislordlypleasureinsmashingitlikeanimagemadeofsnow. Therewasacertaintritenessinthesereflections:theywerethosehabitualtoyoungmenontheapproachoftheirweddingday. Buttheyweregenerallyaccompaniedbyasenseofcompunctionandself–abasementofwhichNewlandArcherfeltnotrace. Hecouldnotdeplore(asThackeray'sheroessooftenexasperatedhimbydoing)thathehadnotablankpagetoofferhisbrideinexchangefortheunblemishedoneshewastogivetohim. HecouldnotgetawayfromthefactthatifhehadbeenbroughtupasshehadtheywouldhavebeennomorefittofindtheirwayaboutthantheBabesintheWood;norcouldhe,forallhisanxiouscogitations,seeanyhonestreason(any,thatis,unconnectedwithhisownmomentarypleasure,andthepassionofmasculinevanity)whyhisbrideshouldnothavebeenallowedthesamefreedomofexperienceashimself. Suchquestions,atsuchanhour,wereboundtodriftthroughhismind;buthewasconsciousthattheiruncomfortablepersistenceandprecisionwereduetotheinopportunearrivaloftheCountessOlenska. Herehewas,attheverymomentofhisbetrothal—amomentforpurethoughtsandcloudlesshopes—pitchforkedintoacoilofscandalwhichraisedallthespecialproblemshewouldhavepreferredtoletlie."HangEllenOlenska!" hegrumbled,ashecoveredhisfireandbegantoundress. Hecouldnotreallyseewhyherfateshouldhavetheleastbearingonhis;yethedimlyfeltthathehadonlyjustbeguntomeasuretherisksofthechampionshipwhichhisengagementhadforceduponhim. Afewdayslatertheboltfell. TheLovellMingottshadsentoutcardsforwhatwasknownas"aformaldinner"(thatis,threeextrafootmen,twodishesforeachcourse,andaRomanpunchinthemiddle),andhadheadedtheirinvitationswiththewords"TomeettheCountessOlenska,"inaccordancewiththehospitableAmericanfashion,whichtreatsstrangersasiftheywereroyalties,oratleastastheirambassadors. TheguestshadbeenselectedwithaboldnessanddiscriminationinwhichtheinitiatedrecognisedthefirmhandofCatherinetheGreat. AssociatedwithsuchimmemorialstandbysastheSelfridgeMerrys,whowereaskedeverywherebecausetheyalwayshadbeen,theBeauforts,onwhomtherewasaclaimofrelationship,andMr.SillertonJacksonandhissisterSophy(whowentwhereverherbrothertoldherto),weresomeofthemostfashionableandyetmostirreproachableofthedominant"youngmarried"set;theLawrenceLeffertses,Mrs.LeffertsRushworth(thelovelywidow),theHarryThorleys,theReggieChiversesandyoungMorrisDagonetandhiswife(whowasavanderLuyden). Thecompanyindeedwasperfectlyassorted,sinceallthemembersbelongedtothelittleinnergroupofpeoplewho,duringthelongNewYorkseason,disportedthemselvestogetherdailyandnightlywithapparentlyundiminishedzest. Forty–eighthourslatertheunbelievablehadhappened;everyonehadrefusedtheMingotts'invitationexcepttheBeaufortsandoldMr.Jacksonandhissister. TheintendedslightwasemphasisedbythefactthateventheReggieChiverses,whowereoftheMingottclan,wereamongthoseinflictingit;andbytheuniformwordingofthenotes,inallofwhichthewriters"regrettedthattheywereunabletoaccept,"withoutthemitigatingpleaofa"previousengagement"thatordinarycourtesyprescribed. NewYorksocietywas,inthosedays,fartoosmall,andtooscantinitsresources,foreveryoneinit(includinglivery–stable–keepers,butlersandcooks)nottoknowexactlyonwhicheveningspeoplewerefree;anditwasthuspossiblefortherecipientsofMrs.LovellMingott'sinvitationstomakecruellycleartheirdeterminationnottomeettheCountessOlenska. Theblowwasunexpected;buttheMingotts,astheirwaywas,metitgallantly. Mrs.LovellMingottconfidedthecasetoMrs.Welland,whoconfidedittoNewlandArcher;who,aflameattheoutrage,appealedpassionatelyandauthoritativelytohismother;who,afterapainfulperiodofinwardresistanceandoutwardtemporising,succumbedtohisinstances(asshealwaysdid),andimmediatelyembracinghiscausewithanenergyredoubledbyherprevioushesitations,putonhergreyvelvetbonnetandsaid:"I'llgoandseeLouisavanderLuyden." TheNewYorkofNewlandArcher'sdaywasasmallandslipperypyramid,inwhich,asyet,hardlyafissurehadbeenmadeorafootholdgained. AtitsbasewasafirmfoundationofwhatMrs.Archercalled"plainpeople";anhonourablebutobscuremajorityofrespectablefamilieswho(asinthecaseoftheSpicersortheLeffertsesortheJacksons)hadbeenraisedabovetheirlevelbymarriagewithoneoftherulingclans. People,Mrs.Archeralwayssaid,werenotasparticularastheyusedtobe;andwitholdCatherineSpicerrulingoneendofFifthAvenue,andJuliusBeauforttheother,youcouldn'texpecttheoldtraditionstolastmuchlonger. FirmlynarrowingupwardfromthiswealthybutinconspicuoussubstratumwasthecompactanddominantgroupwhichtheMingotts,Newlands,ChiversesandMansonssoactivelyrepresented. Mostpeopleimaginedthemtobetheveryapexofthepyramid;buttheythemselves(atleastthoseofMrs.Archer'sgeneration)wereawarethat,intheeyesoftheprofessionalgenealogist,onlyastillsmallernumberoffamiliescouldlayclaimtothateminence. "Don'ttellme,"Mrs.Archerwouldsaytoherchildren,"allthismodernnewspaperrubbishaboutaNewYorkaristocracy. Ifthereisone,neithertheMingottsnortheMansonsbelongtoit;no,northeNewlandsortheChiverseseither. Ourgrandfathersandgreat–grandfatherswerejustrespectableEnglishorDutchmerchants,whocametothecoloniestomaketheirfortune,andstayedherebecausetheydidsowell. Oneofyourgreat–grandfatherssignedtheDeclaration,andanotherwasageneralonWashington'sstaff,andreceivedGeneralBurgoyne'sswordafterthebattleofSaratoga. Thesearethingstobeproudof,buttheyhavenothingtodowithrankorclass. NewYorkhasalwaysbeenacommercialcommunity,andtherearenotmorethanthreefamiliesinitwhocanclaimanaristocraticoriginintherealsenseoftheword." Mrs.Archerandhersonanddaughter,likeeveryoneelseinNewYork,knewwhotheseprivilegedbeingswere:theDagonetsofWashingtonSquare,whocameofanoldEnglishcountyfamilyalliedwiththePittsandFoxes;theLannings,whohadintermarriedwiththedescendantsofCountdeGrasse,andthevanderLuydens,directdescendantsofthefirstDutchgovernorofManhattan,andrelatedbypre–revolutionarymarriagestoseveralmembersoftheFrenchandBritisharistocracy. TheLanningssurvivedonlyinthepersonoftwoveryoldbutlivelyMissLannings,wholivedcheerfullyandreminiscentlyamongfamilyportraitsandChippendale;theDagonetswereaconsiderableclan,alliedtothebestnamesinBaltimoreandPhiladelphia;butthevanderLuydens,whostoodaboveallofthem,hadfadedintoakindofsuper–terrestrialtwilight,fromwhichonlytwofiguresimpressivelyemerged;thoseofMr.andMrs.HenryvanderLuyden. Mrs.HenryvanderLuydenhadbeenLouisaDagonet,andhermotherhadbeenthegranddaughterofColonelduLac,ofanoldChannelIslandfamily,whohadfoughtunderCornwallisandhadsettledinMaryland,afterthewar,withhisbride,LadyAngelicaTrevenna,fifthdaughteroftheEarlofSt.Austrey. ThetiebetweentheDagonets,theduLacsofMaryland,andtheiraristocraticCornishkinsfolk,theTrevennas,hadalwaysremainedcloseandcordial. Mr.andMrs.vanderLuydenhadmorethanoncepaidlongvisitstothepresentheadofthehouseofTrevenna,theDukeofSt.Austrey,athiscountry–seatinCornwallandatSt.AustreyinGloucestershire;andhisGracehadfrequentlyannouncedhisintentionofsomedayreturningtheirvisit(withouttheDuchess,whofearedtheAtlantic). Mr.andMrs.vanderLuydendividedtheirtimebetweenTrevenna,theirplaceinMaryland,andSkuytercliff,thegreatestateontheHudsonwhichhadbeenoneofthecolonialgrantsoftheDutchgovernmenttothefamousfirstGovernor,andofwhichMr.vanderLuydenwasstill"Patroon." TheirlargesolemnhouseinMadisonAvenuewasseldomopened,andwhentheycametotowntheyreceivedinitonlytheirmostintimatefriends. "Iwishyouwouldgowithme,Newland,"hismothersaid,suddenlypausingatthedooroftheBrowncoupe. "Louisaisfondofyou;andofcourseit'sonaccountofdearMaythatI'mtakingthisstep—andalsobecause,ifwedon'tallstandtogether,there'llbenosuchthingasSocietyleft."