Wornoutbyanxiouswatching,Mr.Lorryfellasleepathispost. Onthetenthmorningofhissuspense,hewasstartledbytheshiningofthesunintotheroomwhereaheavyslumberhadovertakenhimwhenitwasdarknight. Herubbedhiseyesandrousedhimself;buthedoubted,whenhehaddoneso,whetherhewasnotstillasleep. For,goingtothedooroftheDoctor’sroomandlookingin,heperceivedthattheshoemaker’sbenchandtoolswereputasideagain,andthattheDoctorhimselfsatreadingatthewindow. Hewasinhisusualmorningdress,andhisface(whichMr.Lorrycoulddistinctlysee),thoughstillverypale,wascalmlystudiousandattentive. Evenwhenhehadsatisfiedhimselfthathewasawake,Mr.Lorryfeltgiddilyuncertainforsomefewmomentswhetherthelateshoemakingmightnotbeadisturbeddreamofhisown;for,didnothiseyesshowhimhisfriendbeforehiminhisaccustomedclothingandaspect,andemployedasusual;andwasthereanysignwithintheirrange,thatthechangeofwhichhehadsostronganimpressionhadactuallyhappened? Itwasbuttheinquiryofhisfirstconfusionandastonishment,theanswerbeingobvious. Iftheimpressionwerenotproducedbyarealcorrespondingandsufficientcause,howcamehe,JarvisLorry,there? Howcamehetohavefallenasleep,inhisclothes,onthesofainDoctorManette’sconsulting-room,andtobedebatingthesepointsoutsidetheDoctor’sbedroomdoorintheearlymorning? Withinafewminutes,MissProssstoodwhisperingathisside. Ifhehadhadanyparticleofdoubtleft,hertalkwouldofnecessityhaveresolvedit;buthewasbythattimeclear-headed,andhadnone. Headvisedthattheyshouldletthetimegobyuntiltheregularbreakfast-hour,andshouldthenmeettheDoctorasifnothingunusualhadoccurred. Ifheappearedtobeinhiscustomarystateofmind,Mr.Lorrywouldthencautiouslyproceedtoseekdirectionandguidancefromtheopinionhehadbeen,inhisanxiety,soanxioustoobtain. MissPross,submittingherselftohisjudgment,theschemewasworkedoutwithcare. Havingabundanceoftimeforhisusualmethodicaltoilette,Mr.Lorrypresentedhimselfatthebreakfast-hourinhisusualwhitelinen,andwithhisusualneatleg. TheDoctorwassummonedintheusualway,andcametobreakfast. SofarasitwaspossibletocomprehendhimwithoutoversteppingthosedelicateandgradualapproacheswhichMr.Lorryfelttobetheonlysafeadvance,heatfirstsupposedthathisdaughter’smarriagehadtakenplaceyesterday. Anincidentalallusion,purposelythrownout,tothedayoftheweek,andthedayofthemonth,sethimthinkingandcounting,andevidentlymadehimuneasy. Inallotherrespects,however,hewassocomposedlyhimself,thatMr.Lorrydeterminedtohavetheaidhesought.Andthataidwashisown. Therefore,whenthebreakfastwasdoneandclearedaway,andheandtheDoctorwerelefttogether,Mr.Lorrysaid,feelingly: “MydearManette,Iamanxioustohaveyouropinion,inconfidence,onaverycuriouscaseinwhichIamdeeplyinterested;thatistosay,itisverycurioustome;perhaps,toyourbetterinformationitmaybelessso.” Glancingathishands,whichwerediscolouredbyhislatework,theDoctorlookedtroubled,andlistenedattentively.Hehadalreadyglancedathishandsmorethanonce. “DoctorManette,”saidMr.Lorry,touchinghimaffectionatelyonthearm,“thecaseisthecaseofaparticularlydearfriendofmine. Praygiveyourmindtoit,andadvisemewellforhissake—andaboveall,forhisdaughter’s—hisdaughter’s,mydearManette.” “IfIunderstand,”saidtheDoctor,inasubduedtone,“somementalshock—?” “Beexplicit,”saidtheDoctor.“Sparenodetail.” Mr.Lorrysawthattheyunderstoodoneanother,andproceeded. “MydearManette,itisthecaseofanoldandaprolongedshock,ofgreatacutenessandseveritytotheaffections,thefeelings,the—the—asyouexpressit—themind.Themind. Itisthecaseofashockunderwhichthesuffererwasbornedown,onecannotsayforhowlong,becauseIbelievehecannotcalculatethetimehimself,andtherearenoothermeansofgettingatit. Itisthecaseofashockfromwhichthesuffererrecovered,byaprocessthathecannottracehimself—asIonceheardhimpubliclyrelateinastrikingmanner. Itisthecaseofashockfromwhichhehasrecovered,socompletely,astobeahighlyintelligentman,capableofcloseapplicationofmind,andgreatexertionofbody,andofconstantlymakingfreshadditionstohisstockofknowledge,whichwasalreadyverylarge. But,unfortunately,therehasbeen,”hepausedandtookadeepbreath—”aslightrelapse.” TheDoctor,inalowvoice,asked,“Ofhowlongduration?” “Howdiditshowitself?Iinfer,”glancingathishandsagain,“intheresumptionofsomeoldpursuitconnectedwiththeshock?” “Now,didyoueverseehim,”askedtheDoctor,distinctlyandcollectedly,thoughinthesamelowvoice,“engagedinthatpursuitoriginally?” “Andwhentherelapsefellonhim,washeinmostrespects—orinallrespects—ashewasthen?” “Youspokeofhisdaughter.Doeshisdaughterknowoftherelapse?” “No.Ithasbeenkeptfromher,andIhopewillalwaysbekeptfromher.Itisknownonlytomyself,andtooneotherwhomaybetrusted.” TheDoctorgraspedhisband,andmurmured,“Thatwasverykind.Thatwasverythoughtful!”Mr.Lorrygraspedhishandinreturn,andneitherofthetwospokeforalittlewhile. “Now,mydearManette,”saidMr.Lorry,atlength,inhismostconsiderateandmostaffectionateway,“Iamameremanofbusiness,andunfittocopewithsuchintricateanddifficultmatters. Idonotpossessthekindofinformationnecessary;Idonotpossessthekindofintelligence;Iwantguiding. ThereisnomaninthisworldonwhomIcouldsorelyforrightguidance,asonyou. Tellme,howdoesthisrelapsecomeabout?Istheredangerofanother?Couldarepetitionofitbeprevented? Howshouldarepetitionofitbetreated?Howdoesitcomeaboutatall?WhatcanIdoformyfriend? Nomanevercanhavebeenmoredesirousinhishearttoserveafriend,thanIamtoservemine,ifIknewhow. ButIdon’tknowhowtooriginate,insuchacase. Ifyoursagacity,knowledge,andexperience,couldputmeontherighttrack,Imightbeabletodosomuch;unenlightenedandundirected,Icandosolittle. Praydiscussitwithme;prayenablemetoseeitalittlemoreclearly,andteachmehowtobealittlemoreuseful.” DoctorManettesatmeditatingaftertheseearnestwordswerespoken,andMr.Lorrydidnotpresshim. “Ithinkitprobable,”saidtheDoctor,breakingsilencewithaneffort,“thattherelapseyouhavedescribed,mydearfriend,wasnotquiteunforeseenbyitssubject.” “Wasitdreadedbyhim?”Mr.Lorryventuredtoask. “Verymuch.”Hesaiditwithaninvoluntaryshudder. “Youhavenoideahowsuchanapprehensionweighsonthesufferer’smind,andhowdifficult—howalmostimpossible—itis,forhimtoforcehimselftoutteraworduponthetopicthatoppresseshim.” “Wouldhe,”askedMr.Lorry,“besensiblyrelievedifhecouldprevailuponhimselftoimpartthatsecretbroodingtoanyone,whenitisonhim?” “Ithinkso.Butitis,asIhavetoldyou,nexttoimpossible.Ievenbelieveit—insomecases—tobequiteimpossible.” “Now,”saidMr.Lorry,gentlylayinghishandontheDoctor’sarmagain,afterashortsilenceonbothsides,“towhatwouldyoureferthisattack?“ “Ibelieve,”returnedDoctorManette,“thattherehadbeenastrongandextraordinaryrevivalofthetrainofthoughtandremembrancethatwasthefirstcauseofthemalady. Someintenseassociationsofamostdistressingnaturewerevividlyrecalled,Ithink. Itisprobablethattherehadlongbeenadreadlurkinginhismind,thatthoseassociationswouldberecalled—say,undercertaincircumstances—say,onaparticularoccasion. Hetriedtopreparehimselfinvain;perhapstheefforttopreparehimselfmadehimlessabletobearit.” “Wouldherememberwhattookplaceintherelapse?”askedMr.Lorry,withnaturalhesitation. TheDoctorlookeddesolatelyroundtheroom,shookhishead,andanswered,inalowvoice,“Notatall.” “Now,astothefuture,”hintedMr.Lorry. “Astothefuture,”saidtheDoctor,recoveringfirmness,“Ishouldhavegreathope. AsitpleasedHeaveninitsmercytorestorehimsosoon,Ishouldhavegreathope. He,yieldingunderthepressureofacomplicatedsomething,longdreadedandlongvaguelyforeseenandcontendedagainst,andrecoveringafterthecloudhadburstandpassed,Ishouldhopethattheworstwasover.” “Well,well!That’sgoodcomfort.Iamthankful!”saidMr.Lorry. “Iamthankful!”repeatedtheDoctor,bendinghisheadwithreverence. “Therearetwootherpoints,”saidMr.Lorry,“onwhichIamanxioustobeinstructed.Imaygoon?” “Youcannotdoyourfriendabetterservice.”TheDoctorgavehimhishand. “Tothefirst,then.Heisofastudioushabit,andunusuallyenergetic;heapplieshimselfwithgreatardourtotheacquisitionofprofessionalknowledge,totheconductingofexperiments,tomanythings.Now,doeshedotoomuch?” “Ithinknot.Itmaybethecharacterofhismind,tobealwaysinsingularneedofoccupation. Thatmaybe,inpart,naturaltoit;inpart,theresultofaffliction. Thelessitwasoccupiedwithhealthythings,themoreitwouldbeindangerofturningintheunhealthydirection. Hemayhaveobservedhimself,andmadethediscovery.” “Youaresurethatheisnotundertoogreatastrain?” “IthinkIamquitesureofit.” “MydearManette,ifhewereoverworkednow—” “MydearLorry,Idoubtifthatcouldeasilybe.Therehasbeenaviolentstressinonedirection,anditneedsacounterweight.” “Excuseme,asapersistentmanofbusiness.Assumingforamoment,thatheWASoverworked;itwouldshowitselfinsomerenewalofthisdisorder?” “Idonotthinkso.Idonotthink,”saidDoctorManettewiththefirmnessofself-conviction,“thatanythingbuttheonetrainofassociationwouldrenewit. Ithinkthat,henceforth,nothingbutsomeextraordinaryjarringofthatchordcouldrenewit. Afterwhathashappened,andafterhisrecovery,Ifinditdifficulttoimagineanysuchviolentsoundingofthatstringagain. Itrust,andIalmostbelieve,thatthecircumstanceslikelytorenewitareexhausted.” Hespokewiththediffidenceofamanwhoknewhowslightathingwouldoversetthedelicateorganisationofthemind,andyetwiththeconfidenceofamanwhohadslowlywonhisassuranceoutofpersonalenduranceanddistress. Itwasnotforhisfriendtoabatethatconfidence. Heprofessedhimselfmorerelievedandencouragedthanhereallywas,andapproachedhissecondandlastpoint. Hefeltittobethemostdifficultofall;but,rememberinghisoldSundaymorningconversationwithMissPross,andrememberingwhathehadseeninthelastninedays,heknewthathemustfaceit. “Theoccupationresumedundertheinfluenceofthispassingafflictionsohappilyrecoveredfrom,”saidMr.Lorry,clearinghisthroat,“wewillcall—Blacksmith’swork,Blacksmith’swork. Wewillsay,toputacaseandforthesakeofillustration,thathehadbeenused,inhisbadtime,toworkatalittleforge. Wewillsaythathewasunexpectedlyfoundathisforgeagain. Isitnotapitythatheshouldkeepitbyhim?” TheDoctorshadedhisforeheadwithhishand,andbeathisfootnervouslyontheground. “Hehasalwayskeptitbyhim,”saidMr.Lorry,withananxiouslookathisfriend.“Now,woulditnotbebetterthatheshouldletitgo?” Still,theDoctor,withshadedforehead,beathisfootnervouslyontheground. “Youdonotfinditeasytoadviseme?”saidMr.Lorry.“Iquiteunderstandittobeanicequestion.AndyetIthink—”Andthereheshookhishead,andstopped. “Yousee,”saidDoctorManette,turningtohimafteranuneasypause,“itisveryhardtoexplain,consistently,theinnermostworkingsofthispoorman’smind. Heonceyearnedsofrightfullyforthatoccupation,anditwassowelcomewhenitcame;nodoubtitrelievedhispainsomuch,bysubstitutingtheperplexityofthefingersfortheperplexityofthebrain,andbysubstituting,ashebecamemorepractised,theingenuityofthehands,fortheingenuityofthementaltorture;thathehasneverbeenabletobearthethoughtofputtingitquiteoutofhisreach. Evennow,whenIbelieveheismorehopefulofhimselfthanhehaseverbeen,andevenspeaksofhimselfwithakindofconfidence,theideathathemightneedthatoldemployment,andnotfindit,giveshimasuddensenseofterror,likethatwhichonemayfancystrikestotheheartofalostchild.” Helookedlikehisillustration,asheraisedhiseyestoMr.Lorry’sface. “Butmaynot—mind!Iaskforinformation,asaploddingmanofbusinesswhoonlydealswithsuchmaterialobjectsasguineas,shillings,andbank-notes—maynottheretentionofthethinginvolvetheretentionoftheidea? Ifthethingweregone,mydearManette,mightnotthefeargowithit? Inshort,isitnotaconcessiontothemisgiving,tokeeptheforge?” “Yousee,too,”saidtheDoctor,tremulously,“itissuchanoldcompanion.” “Iwouldnotkeepit,”saidMr.Lorry,shakinghishead;forhegainedinfirmnessashesawtheDoctordisquieted.“Iwouldrecommendhimtosacrificeit.Ionlywantyourauthority.Iamsureitdoesnogood.Come! Givemeyourauthority,likeadeargoodman. Forhisdaughter’ssake,mydearManette!” Verystrangetoseewhatastruggletherewaswithinhim! “Inhername,then,letitbedone;Isanctionit.But,Iwouldnottakeitawaywhilehewaspresent.Letitberemovedwhenheisnotthere;lethimmisshisoldcompanionafteranabsence.” Mr.Lorryreadilyengagedforthat,andtheconferencewasended. Theypassedthedayinthecountry,andtheDoctorwasquiterestored. Onthethreefollowingdaysheremainedperfectlywell,andonthefourteenthdayhewentawaytojoinLucieandherhusband. Theprecautionthathadbeentakentoaccountforhissilence,Mr.Lorryhadpreviouslyexplainedtohim,andhehadwrittentoLucieinaccordancewithit,andshehadnosuspicions. Onthenightofthedayonwhichheleftthehouse,Mr.Lorrywentintohisroomwithachopper,saw,chisel,andhammer,attendedbyMissProsscarryingalight. There,withcloseddoors,andinamysteriousandguiltymanner,Mr.Lorryhackedtheshoemaker’sbenchtopieces,whileMissProssheldthecandleasifshewereassistingatamurder—forwhich,indeed,inhergrimness,shewasnounsuitablefigure. Theburningofthebody(previouslyreducedtopiecesconvenientforthepurpose)wascommencedwithoutdelayinthekitchenfire;andthetools,shoes,andleather,wereburiedinthegarden. Sowickeddodestructionandsecrecyappeartohonestminds,thatMr.LorryandMissPross,whileengagedinthecommissionoftheirdeedandintheremovalofitstraces,almostfelt,andalmostlooked,likeaccomplicesinahorriblecrime.