“FayfieldJunction!ChangeforElveston!” Whatsubtlememorycouldtherebe,linkedtothesecommonplacewords,thatcausedsuchafloodofhappythoughtstofillmybrain? IdismountedfromthecarriageinastateofjoyfulexcitementforwhichIcouldnotatfirstaccount. True,Ihadtakenthisveryjourney,andatthesamehouroftheday,sixmonthsago;butmanythingshadhappenedsincethen,andanoldman’smemoryhasbutaslenderholdonrecentevents:Isought“themissinglink”invain. SuddenlyIcaughtsightofabench—theonlyoneprovidedonthecheerlessplatform—withaladyseatedonit,andthewholeforgottensceneflasheduponmeasvividlyasifitwerehappeningoveragain. “Yes,”Ithought.“Thisbareplatformis,forme,richwiththememoryofadearfriend! Shewassittingonthatverybench,andinvitedmetoshareit,withsomequotationfromShakespeare—Iforgetwhat. I’lltrytheEarl’splanfortheDramatizationofLife,andfancythatfiguretobeLadyMuriel;andIwo’n’tundeceivemyselftoosoon!” SoIstrolledalongtheplatform,resolutely“makingbelieve”(aschildrensay)thatthecasualpassenger,seatedonthatbench,wastheLadyMurielIrememberedsowell. Shewasfacingawayfromme,whichaidedtheelaboratecheateryIwaspracticingonmyself:but,thoughIwascareful,inpassingthespot,tolooktheotherway,inordertoprolongthepleasantillusion,itwasinevitablethat,whenIturnedtowalkbackagain,Ishouldseewhoitwas.ItwasLadyMurielherself! Thewholescenenowreturnedvividlytomymemory;and,tomakethisrepetitionofitstrangerstill,therewasthesameoldman,whomIrememberedseeingsoroughlyorderedoff,bytheStation-Master,tomakeroomforhistitledpassenger. Thesame,but“withadifference”:nolongertotteringfeeblyalongtheplatform,butactuallyseatedatLadyMuriel’sside,andinconversationwithher! “Yes,putitinyourpurse,”shewassaying,“andrememberyou’retospenditallforMinnie. Andmindyoubringhersomethingnice,that’lldoherrealgood!Andgivehermylove!” Sointentwassheonsayingthesewords,that,althoughthesoundofmyfootstephadmadeherliftherheadandlookatme,shedidnotatfirstrecognizeme. IraisedmyhatasIapproached,andthenthereflashedacrossherfaceagenuinelookofjoy,whichsoexactlyrecalledthesweetfaceofSylvie,whenlastwemetinKensingtonGardens,thatIfeltquitebewildered. Ratherthandisturbthepooroldmanatherside,sherosefromherseat,andjoinedmeinmywalkupanddowntheplatform,andforaminuteortwoourconversationwasasutterlytrivialandcommonplaceasifweweremerelytwocasualguestsinaLondondrawing-room. Eachofusseemedtoshrink,justatfirst,fromtouchingonthedeeperinterestswhichlinkedourlivestogether. TheElvestontrainhaddrawnupattheplatform,whilewetalked;and,inobediencetotheStationMaster’sobsequioushintof“Thisway,myLady!Time’sup!” ,weweremakingthebestofourwaytowardstheendwhichcontainedthesolefirst-classcarriage,andwerejustpassingthenow-emptybench,whenLadyMurielnoticed,lyingonit,thepurseinwhichhergifthadjustbeensocarefullybestowed,theownerofwhich,allunconsciousofhisloss,wasbeinghelpedintoacarriageattheotherendofthetrain.Shepouncedonitinstantly.“Pooroldman!” “Hemustn’tgooff,andthinkhe’slostit!” “Letmerunwithit!Icangoquickerthanyou!”Isaid. Butshewasalreadyhalf-waydowntheplatformflying(”running”ismuchtoomundaneawordforsuchfairy-likemotion)atapacethatleftallpossibleeffortsofminehopelesslyintherear. ShewasbackagainbeforeIhadwellcompletedmyaudaciousboastofspeedinrunning,andwassaying,quitedemurely,asweenteredourcarriage,“andyoureallythinkyoucouldhavedoneitquicker?” “No,indeed!”Ireplied.“Iplead‘Guilty’ofgrossexaggeration,andthrowmyselfonthemercyoftheCourt!” “TheCourtwilloverlookit—forthisonce!”Thenhermannersuddenlychangedfromplayfulnesstoananxiousgravity. “Youarenotlookingyourbest!”shesaidwithananxiousglance.“Infact,Ithinkyoulookmoreofaninvalidthanwhenyouleftus.IverymuchdoubtifLondonagreeswithyou?” “ItmaybetheLondonair,”Isaid,“oritmaybethehardwork—ormyratherlonelylife:anyhow,I’venotbeenfeelingverywell,lately.ButElvestonwillsoonsetmeupagain. Arthur’sprescription—he’smydoctor,youknow,andIheardfromhimthismorning—is‘plentyofozone,andnewmilk,andpleasantsociety’!” “Pleasantsociety?”saidLadyMuriel,withaprettymake-believeofconsideringthequestion. “Well,reallyIdon’tknowwherewecanfindthatforyou!Wehavesofewneighbours.Butnewmilkwecanmanage. DogetitofmyoldfriendMrs.Hunter,upthere,onthehill-side.Youmayrelyuponthequality. AndherlittleBessiecomestoschooleveryday,andpassesyourlodgings.Soitwouldbeveryeasytosendit.” “I’llfollowyouradvicewithpleasure,”Isaid;“andI’llgoandarrangeaboutitto-morrow.IknowArthurwillwantawalk.” “You’llfinditquiteaneasywalk—underthreemiles,Ithink.” “Well,nowthatwe’vesettledthatpoint,letmeretortyourownremarkuponyourself.Idon’tthinkyou’relookingquiteyourbest!” “Idaresaynot,”sherepliedinalowvoice;andasuddenshadowseemedtooverspreadherface.“I’vehadsometroubleslately. It’samatteraboutwhichI’vebeenlongwishingtoconsultyou,butIcouldn’teasilywriteaboutit.I’msogladtohavethisopportunity!” “Doyouthink”,shebeganagain,afteraminute’ssilence,andwithavisibleembarrassmentofmannermostunusualinher,“thatapromise,deliberatelyandsolemnlygiven,isalwaysbindingexcept,ofcourse,whereitsfulfillmentwouldinvolvesomeactualsin?” “Ica’n’tthinkofanyotherexceptionatthismoment,”Isaid.“Thatbranchofcasuistryisusually,Ibelieve,treatedasaquestionoftruthanduntruth—” “Surelythatistheprinciple?”sheeagerlyinterrupted.“IalwaysthoughttheBible-teachingaboutitconsistedofsuchtexts‘lienotonetoanother’?” “Ihavethoughtaboutthatpoint,”Ireplied;“anditseemstomethattheessenceoflyingistheintentionofdeceiving. Ifyougiveapromise,fullyintendingtofulfillit,youarecertainlyactingtruthfullythen;and,ifyouafterwardsbreakit,thatdoesnotinvolveanydeceptionIcannotcallituntruthful.” Anotherpauseofsilenceensued.LadyMuriel’sfacewashardtoread:shelookedpleased,Ithought,butalsopuzzled;andIfeltcurioustoknowwhetherherquestionhad,asIbegantosuspect,somebearingonthebreakingoffofherengagementwithCaptain(nowMajor)Lindon. “Youhaverelievedmefromagreatfear,”shesaid“butthethingisofcoursewrong,somehow.Whattextswouldyouquote,toproveitwrong?” “Anythatenforcethepaymentofdebts.IfApromisessomethingtoB,BhasaclaimuponA.AndA’ssin,ifhebreakshispromise,seemstomemoreanalogoustostealingthantolying.” “It’sanewwayoflookingatit—tome,”shesaid;“butitseemsatrueway,also. However,Iwo’n’tdealingeneralities,withanoldfriendlikeyou!Forweareoldfriendssomehow. Doyouknow,Ithinkwebeganasoldfriends?’ shesaidwithaplayfulnessoftonethatillaccordedwiththetearsthatglistenedinhereyes. “Thankyouverymuchforsayingso,”Ireplied. “Iliketothinkofyouasanoldfriend,”(“—thoughyoudon’tlookit!” wouldhavebeenthealmostnecessarysequence,withanyotherlady;butsheandIseemedtohavelongpassedoutofthetimewhencompliments,oranysuchtrivialities,werepossible). Herethetrainpausedatastation,wheretwoorthreepassengersenteredthecarriage;sonomorewassaidtillwehadreachedourjourney’send. OnourarrivalatElveston,shereadilyadoptedmysuggestionthatweshouldwalkuptogether;so,assoonasourluggagehadbeendulytakenchargeof—hersbytheservantwhometheratthestation,andminebyoneoftheporters—wesetouttogetheralongthefamiliarlanes,nowlinkedinmymemorywithsomanydelightfulassociations. LadyMurielatoncerecommencedtheconversationatthepointwhereithadbeeninterrupted. “YouknewofmyengagementtomycousinEric.Didyoualsohear—” “Yes,”Iinterrupted,anxioustospareherthepainofgivinganydetails.“Iheardithadallcometoanend.” “Iwouldliketotellyouhowithappened,”shesaid;“asthatistheverypointIwantyouradviceabout. Ihadlongrealizedthatwewerenotinsympathyinreligiousbelief. HisideasofChristianityareveryshadowy;andevenastotheexistenceofaGodhelivesinasortofdreamland.Butithasnotaffectedhislife! Ifeelsure,now,thatthemostabsoluteAtheistmaybeleading,thoughwalkingblindfold,apureandnoblelife. Andifyouknewhalfthegooddeeds—”shebrokeoffsuddenly,andturnedawayherhead. “Ientirelyagreewithyou,”Isaid.“AndhavewenotourSaviour’sownpromisethatsuchalifeshallsurelyleadtothelight?” “Yes,Iknowit,”shesaidinabrokenvoice,stillkeepingherheadturnedaway.“AndsoItoldhim. Hesaidhewouldbelieve,formysake,ifhecould. Andhewishedformysake,hecouldseethingsasIdid.Butthatisallwrong!”shewentonpassionately. “Godcannotapprovesuchlowmotivesasthat!StillitwasnotIthatbrokeitoff. Iknewhelovedme;andIhadpromised;and—’ “Thenitwashethatbrokeitoff?” “Hereleasedmeunconditionally.”Shefacedmeagainnow,havingquiterecoveredherusualcalmnessofmanner. “Thenwhatdifficultyremains?” “Itisthis,thatIdon’tbelievehediditofhisownfreewill. Now,supposinghediditagainsthiswill,merelytosatisfymyscruples,wouldnothisclaimonmeremainjustasstrongasever? Andwouldnotmypromisebeasbindingasever? Myfathersays‘no’;butIca’n’thelpfearingheisbiasedbyhisloveforme.AndI’veaskednooneelse. Ihavemanyfriends—friendsforthebrightsunnyweather;notfriendsforthecloudsandstormsoflife;notoldfriendslikeyou!” “Letmethinkalittle,”Isaid:andforsome. minuteswewalkedoninsilence,while,painedtotheheartatseeingthebittertrialthathadcomeuponthispureandgentlesoul,Istroveinvaintoseemywaythroughthetangledskeinofconflictingmotives. “Ifsheloveshimtruly”,(Iseemedatlasttograspthecluetotheproblem)“isnotthat,forherthevoiceofGod? Mayshenothopethatsheissenttohim,evenasAnaniaswassenttoSaulinhisblindness,thathemayreceivehissight. OncemoreIseemedtohearArthurwhisperingWhatknowestthou,Owife,whetherthoushaltsavethyhusband?” andIbrokethesilencewiththewords“Ifyoustilllovehimtruly—” “Idonot!”shehastilyinterrupted.“Atleast—notinthatway. IbelieveIlovedhimwhenIpromised,butIwasveryyoung:itishardtoknow. But,whateverthefeelingwas,itisdeadnow. ThemotiveonhissideisLove:onmineitis—Duty!” Againtherewasalongsilence.Thewholeskeinofthoughtwastangledworsethanever.Thistimeshebrokethesilence.“Don’tmisunderstandme!”shesaid. “WhenIsaidmyheartwasnothis,Ididnotmeanitwasanyoneelse’s! AtpresentIfeelboundtohim;and,tillIknowIamabsolutelyfree,inthesightofGod,toloveanyotherthanhim,I’llnevereventhinkofanyoneelse—inthatway,Imean.Iwoulddiesooner!” Ihadneverimaginedmygentlefriendcapableofsuchpassionateutterances. IventuredonnofurtherremarkuntilwehadnearlyarrivedattheHall-gate;but,thelongerIreflected,thecleareritbecametomethatnocallofDutydemandedthesacrifice—possiblyofthehappinessofalife—whichsheseemedreadytomake. Itriedtomakethiscleartoheralso,addingsomewarningsonthedangersthatsurelyawaitedaunioninwhichmutuallovewaswanting. “Theonlyargumentforit,worthconsidering,”Isaidinconclusion,“seemstobehissupposedreluctanceinreleasingyoufromyourpromise. Ihavetriedtogivetothatargumentitsfullweight,andmyconclusionisthatitdoesnotaffecttherightsofthecase,orinvalidatethereleasehehasgivenyou. Mybeliefisthatyouareentirelyfreetoactasnowseemsright.” “Iamverygratefultoyou,”shesaidearnestly.“Believeit,please!Ica’n’tputitintoproperwords!” andthesubjectwasdroppedbymutualconsentandIonlylearned,longafterwards,thatourdiscussionhadreallyservedtodispelthedoubtsthathadharassedhersolong. WepartedattheHall-gate,andIfoundArthureagerlyawaitingmyarrival;and,beforewepartedforthenight,Ihadheardthewholestory—howhehadputoffhisjourneyfromdaytoday,feelingthathecouldnotgoawayfromtheplacetillhisfatehadbeenirrevocablysettledbytheweddingtakingplace:howthepreparationsforthewedding,andtheexcitementintheneighbourhood,hadsuddenlycometoanend,andhehadlearned(fromMajorLindon,whocalledtowishhimgood-bye)thattheengagementhadbeenbrokenoffbymutualconsent:howhehadinstantlyabandonedallhisplansforgoingabroad,andhaddecidedtostayonatElveston,forayearortwoatanyrate,tillhisnewly-awakenedhopesshouldprovetrueorfalse;andhow,sincethatmemorableday,hehadavoidedallmeetingswithLadyMuriel,fearingtobetrayhisfeelingsbeforehehadhadanysufficientevidenceastohowsheregardedhim. “Butitisnearlysixweekssinceallthathappened,”hesaidinconclusion,“andwecanmeetintheordinaryway,now,withnoneedforanypainfulallusions. Iwouldhavewrittentotellyouallthis:onlyIkepthopingfromdaytodaythat—thattherewouldbemoretotell!” “Andhowshouldtherebemore,youfoolishfellow,”Ifondlyurged,“ifyouneverevengonearher?Doyouexpecttheoffertocomefromher?” Arthurwasbetrayedintoasmile.“No,”hesaid,“Ihardlyexpectthat.ButI’madesperatecoward.Theresnodoubtaboutit!” “Andwhatreasonshaveyouheardofforbreakingofftheengagement?” “Agoodmany,”Arthurreplied,andproceededtocountthemonhisfingers. “First,itwasfoundthatshewasdyingof—something;sohebrokeitoff. Thenitwasfoundthathewasdyingof—someotherthing;soshebrokeitoff. ThentheMajorturnedouttobeaconfirmedgamester;sotheEarlbrokeitoff. ThentheEarlinsultedhim;sotheMajorbrokeitoff. Itgotagooddealbrokenoff,allthingsconsidered!” “Youhaveallthisontheverybestauthority,ofcourse?” “Oh,certainly!Andcommunicatedinthestrictestconfidence!WhateverdefectsElvestonsocietysuffersfromwantofinformationisn’toneofthem!” “Norreticence,either,itseems.But,seriously,doyouknowtherealreason?” IdidnotfeelthatIhadanyrighttoenlightenhim;soIchangedthesubject,tothelessengrossingoneof“newmilk”,andweagreedthatIshouldwalkover,nextdaytoHunter’sfarm,Arthurundertakingtosetmepartoftheway,afterwhichhehadtoreturntokeepabusinessengagement.