Slowlyastheministerwalked,hehadalmostgonebybeforeHesterPrynnecouldgathervoiceenoughtoattracthisobservation.Atlengthshesucceeded. “ArthurDimmesdale!”shesaid,faintlyatfirst,thenlouder,buthoarsely—“ArthurDimmesdale!” “Whospeaks?”answeredtheminister. Gatheringhimselfquicklyup,hestoodmoreerect,likeamantakenbysurpriseinamoodtowhichhewasreluctanttohavewitnesses. Throwinghiseyesanxiouslyinthedirectionofthevoice,heindistinctlybeheldaformunderthetrees,cladingarmentssosombre,andsolittlerelievedfromthegraytwilightintowhichthecloudedskyandtheheavyfoliagehaddarkenedthenoontide,thatheknewnotwhetheritwereawomanorashadow. Itmaybethathispathwaythroughlifewashauntedthusbyaspectrethathadstolenoutfromamonghisthoughts. Hemadeastepnigher,anddiscoveredthescarletletter. “Hester!HesterPrynne!’,saidhe;“isitthou?Artthouinlife?” “Evenso.”sheanswered.“Insuchlifeashasbeenminethesesevenyearspast!Andthou,ArthurDimmesdale,dostthouyetlive?” Itwasnowonderthattheythusquestionedoneanother’sactualandbodilyexistence,andevendoubtedoftheirown. Sostrangelydidtheymeetinthedimwoodthatitwaslikethefirstencounterintheworldbeyondthegraveoftwospiritswhohadbeenintimatelyconnectedintheirformerlife,butnowstoodcoldlyshudderinginmutualdread,asnotyetfamiliarwiththeirstate,norwontedtothecompanionshipofdisembodiedbeings. Eachaghost,andawe–strickenattheotherghost. Theywereawe–strickenlikewiseatthemselves,becausethecrisisflungbacktothemtheirconsciousness,andrevealedtoeachheartitshistoryandexperience,aslifeneverdoes,exceptatsuchbreathlessepochs. Thesoulbehelditsfeaturesinthemirrorofthepassingmoment. Itwaswithfear,andtremulously,and,asitwere,byaslow,reluctantnecessity,thatArthurDimmesdaleputforthhishand,chillasdeath,andtouchedthechillhandofHesterPrynne. Thegrasp,coldasitwas,tookawaywhatwasdreariestintheinterview. Theynowfeltthemselves,atleast,inhabitantsofthesamesphere. Withoutawordmorespoken—neitherhenorsheassumingtheguidance,butwithanunexpressedconsent—theyglidedbackintotheshadowofthewoodswhenceHesterhademerged,andsatdownontheheapofmosswheresheandPearlhadbeforebeensitting. Whentheyfoundvoicetospeak,itwasatfirstonlytoutterremarksandinquiriessuchasanytwoacquaintancesmighthavemade,aboutthegloomysky,thethreateningstorm,and,next,thehealthofeach. Thustheywentonward,notboldly,butstepbystep,intothethemesthatwerebroodingdeepestintheirhearts. Solongestrangedbyfateandcircumstances,theyneededsomethingslightandcasualtorunbeforeandthrowopenthedoorsofintercourse,sothattheirrealthoughtsmightbeledacrossthethreshold. Afterawhile,theministerfixedhiseyesonHesterPrynne’s. “Hester,”saidhe,“hastthoufoundpeace?” Shesmileddrearily,lookingdownuponherbosom. “None!—Nothingbutdespair!”heanswered. “WhatelsecouldIlookfor,beingwhatIam,andleadingsuchalifeasmine? WereIanatheist—amandevoidofconscience—awretchwithcoarseandbrutalinstincts—Imighthavefoundpeacelongerenow.Nay,Inevershouldhavelostit. But,asmattersstandwithmysoul,whateverofgoodcapacitythereoriginallywasinme,allofGod’sgiftsthatwerethechoicesthavebecometheministersofspiritualtorment.Hester,Iammostmiserable!” “Thepeoplereverencethee,”saidHester.“Andsurelythouworkestgoodamongthem!Doththisbringtheenocomfort?” “Moremisery,Hester!—Onlythemoremisery!” answeredtheclergymanwithabittersmile. “AsconcernsthegoodwhichImayappeartodo,Ihavenofaithinit.Itmustneedsbeadelusion. Whatcanaruinedsoullikemineeffecttowardstheredemptionofothersouls? —Orapollutedsoultowardstheirpurification? Andasforthepeople’sreverence,wouldthatitwereturnedtoscornandhatred! Canstthoudeemit,Hester,aconsolationthatImuststandupinmypulpit,andmeetsomanyeyesturnedupwardtomyface,asifthelightofheavenwerebeamingfromit! —Mustseemyflockhungryforthetruth,andlisteningtomywordsasifatongueofPentecostwerespeaking! —Andthenlookinward,anddiscerntheblackrealityofwhattheyidolize? Ihavelaughed,inbitternessandagonyofheart,atthecontrastbetweenwhatIseemandwhatIam!AndSatanlaughsatit!” “Youwrongyourselfinthis,”saidHestergently. “Youhavedeeplyandsorelyrepented.Yoursinisleftbehindyouinthedayslongpast. Yourpresentlifeisnotlessholy,inverytruth,thanitseemsinpeople’seyes. Istherenorealityinthepenitencethussealedandwitnessedbygoodworks? Andwhereforeshoulditnotbringyoupeace?” “No,Hester—no!”repliedtheclergyman. “Thereisnosubstanceinit]Itiscoldanddead,andcandonothingforme!Ofpenance,Ihavehadenough!Ofpenitence,therehasbeennone! Else,Ishouldlongagohavethrownoffthesegarmentsofmockholiness,andhaveshownmyselftomankindastheywillseemeatthejudgment–seat. Happyareyou,Hester,thatwearthescarletletteropenlyuponyourbosom!Mineburnsinsecret! Thoulittleknowestwhatareliefitis,afterthetormentofasevenyears’cheat,tolookintoaneyethatrecognizesmeforwhatIam! HadIonefriend—orwereitmyworstenemy! —Towhom,whensickenedwiththepraisesofallothermen,Icoulddailybetakemyself,andknownasthevilestofallsinners,methinksmysoulmightkeepitselfalivethereby.Eventhusmuchoftruthwouldsaveme!Butnow,itisallfalsehood!—Allemptiness!—Alldeath!” HesterPrynnelookedintohisface,buthesitatedtospeak. Yet,utteringhislong–restrainedemotionssovehementlyashedid,hiswordshereofferedhertheverypointofcircumstancesinwhichtointerposewhatshecametosay.Sheconqueredherfears,andspoke: “Suchafriendasthouhastevennowwishedfor,”saidshe,“withwhomtoweepoverthysin,thouhastinme,thepartnerofit!” Againshehesitated,butbroughtoutthewordswithaneffort“Thouhastlonghadsuchanenemy,anddwellestwithhim,underthesameroof!” Theministerstartedtohisfeet,gaspingforbreath,andclutchingathisheart,asifhewouldhavetornitoutofhisbosom. “Ha!Whatsayestthou?”criedhe.“Anenemy!Andundermineownroof!Whatmeanyou?” HesterPrynnewasnowfullysensibleofthedeepinjuryforwhichshewasresponsibletothisunhappyman,inpermittinghimtolieforsomanyyears,or,indeed,forasinglemoment,atthemercyofonewhosepurposescouldnotbeotherthanmalevolent. Theverycontiguityofhisenemy,beneathwhatevermaskthelattermightconcealhimself,wasenoughtodisturbthemagneticsphereofabeingsosensitiveasArthurDimmesdale. TherehadbeenaperiodwhenHesterwaslessalivetothisconsideration;or,perhaps,inthemisanthropyofherowntrouble,shelefttheministertobearwhatshemightpicturetoherselfasamoretolerabledoom. Butoflate,sincethenightofhisvigil,allhersympathiestowardshimhadbeenbothsoftenedandinvigorated.Shenowreadhisheartmoreaccurately. ShedoubtednotthatthecontinualpresenceofRogerChillingworth—thesecretpoisonofhismalignity,infectingalltheairabouthim—andhisauthorizedinterference,asaphysician,withtheminister’sphysicalandspiritualinfirmities—thatthesebadopportunitieshadbeenturnedtoacruelpurpose. Bymeansofthem,thesufferer’sconsciencehadbeenkeptinanirritatedstate,thetendencyofwhichwas,nottocurebywholesomepain,buttodisorganizeandcorrupthisspiritualbeing. Itsresult,onearth,couldhardlyfailtobeinsanity,andhereafter,thateternalalienationfromtheGoodandTrue,ofwhichmadnessisperhapstheearthlytype. Suchwastheruintowhichshehadbroughttheman,once—nay,whyshouldwenotspeakit?—Stillsopassionatelyloved! Hesterfeltthatthesacrificeoftheclergyman’sgoodname,anddeathitself,asshehadalreadytoldRogerChillingworth,wouldhavebeeninfinitelypreferabletothealternativewhichshehadtakenuponherselftochoose. Andnow,ratherthanhavehadthisgrievouswrongtoconfess,shewouldgladlyhavelaiddownontheforestleaves,anddiedthere,atArthurDimmesdale’sfeet. “Oh,Arthur!”criedshe,“forgiveme! Inallthingselse,Ihavestriventobetrue! TruthwastheonevirtuewhichImighthaveheldfast,anddidholdfast,throughallextremity;savewhenthygood—thylife—thyfame—wereputinquestion!ThenIconsentedtoadeception. Butalieisnevergood,eventhoughdeaththreatenontheotherside!DostthounotseewhatIwouldsay?Thatoldman!—Thephysician!—HewhomtheycallRogerChillingworth!—Hewasmyhusband!” Theministerlookedatherforaninstant,withallthatviolenceofpassion,which—intermixedinmoreshapesthanonewithhishigher,purer,softerqualities—was,infact,theportionofhimwhichthedevilclaimed,andthroughwhichhesoughttowintherest. NeverwasthereablackerorafiercerfrownthanHesternowencountered. Forthebriefspacethatitlasted,itwasadarktransfiguration. Buthischaracterhadbeensomuchenfeebledbysuffering,thatevenitslowerenergieswereincapableofmorethanatemporarystruggle. Hesankdownontheground,andburiedhisfaceinhishands. “Imighthaveknownit,”murmuredhe.“Ididknowit! Wasnotthesecrettoldme,inthenaturalrecoilofmyheartatthefirstsightofhim,andasoftenasIhaveseenhimsince?WhydidInotunderstand? Oh,HesterPrynne,thoulittle,littleknowestallthehorrorofthisthing!Andtheshame!—Theindelicacy! —Thehorribleuglinessofthisexposureofasickandguiltyhearttotheveryeyethatwouldgloatoverit! Woman,woman,thouartaccountableforthis!—Icannotforgivethee!” “Thoushaltforgiveme!”criedHester,flingingherselfonthefallenleavesbesidehim.“LetGodpunish!Thoushaltforgive!” Withsuddenanddesperatetendernessshethrewherarmsaroundhim,andpressedhisheadagainstherbosom,littlecaringthoughhischeekrestedonthescarletletter. Hewouldhavereleasedhimself,butstroveinvaintodoso. Hesterwouldnotsethimfree,lestheshouldlookhersternlyintheface. Alltheworldhadfrownedonher—forsevenlongyearshaditfrowneduponthislonelywoman—andstillsheboreitall,noreveronceturnedawayherfirm,sadeyes. Heaven,likewise,hadfrowneduponher,andshehadnotdied. Butthefrownofthispale,weak,sinful,andsorrow–strickenmanwaswhatHestercouldnotbear,andlive! “Wiltthouyetforgiveme?”sherepeated,overandoveragain.“Wiltthounotfrown?Wiltthouforgive?” “Idoforgiveyou,Hester,”repliedtheministeratlength,withadeeputterance,outofanabyssofsadness,butnoanger.“Ifreelyforgiveyounow.MayGodforgiveusboth. Wearenot,Hester,theworstsinnersintheworld. Thereisoneworsethaneventhepollutedpriest! Thatoldman’srevengehasbeenblackerthanmysin. Hehasviolated,incoldblood,thesanctityofahumanheart.ThouandI,Hester,neverdidso!” “Never,never!”whisperedshe.“Whatwedidhadaconsecrationofitsown.Wefeltitso!Wesaidsotoeachother.Hastthouforgottenit?” “Hush,Hester!”saidArthurDimmesdale,risingfromtheground.“No;Ihavenotforgotten!” Theysatdownagain,sidebyside,andhandclaspedinhand,onthemossytrunkofthefallentree. Lifehadneverbroughtthemagloomierhour;itwasthepointwhithertheirpathwayhadsolongbeentending,anddarkeningever,asitstolealong—andyetitunclosedacharmthatmadethemlingeruponit,andclaimanother,andanother,and,afterall,anothermoment. Theforestwasobscurearoundthem,andcreakedwithablastthatwaspassingthroughit. Theboughsweretossingheavilyabovetheirheads;whileonesolemnoldtreegroaneddolefullytoanother,asiftellingthesadstoryofthepairthatsatbeneath,orconstrainedtoforbodeeviltocome. Andyettheylingered.Howdrearylookedtheforest–trackthatledbackwardtothesettlement,whereHesterPrynnemusttakeupagaintheburdenofherignominyandtheministerthehollowmockeryofhisgoodname!Sotheylingeredaninstantlonger. Nogoldenlighthadeverbeensopreciousasthegloomofthisdarkforest. Hereseenonlybyhiseyes,thescarletletterneednotburnintothebosomofthefallenwoman! Hereseenonlybyhereyes,ArthurDimmesdale,falsetoGodandman,mightbe,foronemomenttrue! Hestartedatathoughtthatsuddenlyoccurredtohim. “Hester!”criedhe,“hereisanewhorror!RogerChillingworthknowsyourpurposetorevealhistruecharacter.Willhecontinue,then,tokeepoursecret?Whatwillnowbethecourseofhisrevenge?” “Thereisastrangesecrecyinhisnature,”repliedHester,thoughtfully;“andithasgrownuponhimbythehiddenpracticesofhisrevenge. Ideemitnotlikelythathewillbetraythesecret. Hewilldoubtlessseekothermeansofsatiatinghisdarkpassion.” “AndI!—HowamItolivelonger,breathingthesameairwiththisdeadlyenemy?” exclaimedArthurDimmesdale,shrinkingwithinhimself,andpressinghishandnervouslyagainsthisheart—agesturethathadgrowninvoluntarywithhim.“Thinkforme,Hester!Thouartstrong.Resolveforme!” “Thoumustdwellnolongerwiththisman,”saidHester,slowlyandfirmly.“Thyheartmustbenolongerunderhisevileye!” “Itwerefarworsethandeath!”repliedtheminister.“Buthowtoavoidit?Whatchoiceremainstome? ShallIliedownagainonthesewitheredleaves,whereIcastmyselfwhenthoudidsttellmewhathewas? MustIsinkdownthere,anddieatonce?” “Alas!whataruinhasbefallenthee!”saidHester,withthetearsgushingintohereyes.“Wiltthoudieforveryweakness?Thereisnoothercause!” “ThejudgmentofGodisonme,”answeredtheconscience–strickenpriest.“Itistoomightyformetostrugglewith!” “Heavenwouldshowmercy,”rejoinedHester,“hadstthoubutthestrengthtotakeadvantageofit.” “Bethoustrongforme!”answeredhe.“Advisemewhattodo.” “Istheworld,then,sonarrow?”exclaimedHesterPrynne,fixingherdeepeyesontheminister’s,andinstinctivelyexercisingamagneticpoweroveraspiritsoshatteredandsubduedthatitcouldhardlyholditselferect. “Doththeuniverseliewithinthecompassofyondertown,whichonlyalittletimeagowasbutaleaf–strewndesert,aslonelyasthisaroundus?Whitherleadsyonderforest–track? Backwardtothesettlement,thousayest!Yes;but,onward,too! Deeperitgoes,anddeeperintothewilderness,lessplainlytobeseenateverystep;untilsomefewmileshencetheyellowleaveswillshownovestigeofthewhiteman’stread.Therethouartfree! Sobriefajourneywouldbringtheefromaworldwherethouhastbeenmostwretched,toonewherethoumayeststillbehappy! IstherenotshadeenoughinallthisboundlessforesttohidethyheartfromthegazeofRogerChillingworth?” “Yes,Hester;butonlyunderthefallenleaves!”repliedtheminister,withasadsmile. “Thenthereisthebroadpathwayofthesea!”continuedHester.“Itbroughttheehither. Ifthousochoose,itwillbeartheebackagain. Inournativeland,whetherinsomeremoteruralvillage,orinvastLondon—or,surely,inGermany,inFrance,inpleasantItaly—thouwouldstbebeyondhispowerandknowledge! Andwhathastthoutodowithalltheseironmen,andtheiropinions? Theyhavekeptthybetterpartinbondagetoolongalready!” “Itcannotbe!”answeredtheminister,listeningasifhewerecalledupontorealiseadream.“Iampowerlesstogo. WretchedandsinfulasIam,IhavehadnootherthoughtthantodragonmyearthlyexistenceinthespherewhereProvidencehathplacedme. Lostasmyownsoulis,IwouldstilldowhatImayforotherhumansouls! Idarenotquitmypost,thoughanunfaithfulsentinel,whosesurerewardisdeathanddishonour,whenhisdrearywatchshallcometoanend!” “Thouartcrushedunderthissevenyears’weightofmisery,”repliedHester,ferventlyresolvedtobuoyhimupwithherownenergy. “Butthoushaltleaveitallbehindthee! Itshallnotcumberthysteps,asthoutreadestalongtheforest–path:neithershaltthoufreighttheshipwithit,ifthouprefertocrossthesea. Leavethiswreckandruinherewhereithathhappened.Meddlenomorewithit!Beginallanew! Hastthouexhaustedpossibilityinthefailureofthisonetrial?Notso! Thefutureisyetfulloftrialandsuccess.Thereishappinesstobeenjoyed!Thereisgoodtobedone! Exchangethisfalselifeofthineforatrueone. Be,ifthyspiritsummontheetosuchamission,theteacherandapostleoftheredmen. Or,asismorethynature,beascholarandasageamongthewisestandthemostrenownedofthecultivatedworld.Preach!Write!Act!Doanything,savetoliedownanddie! GiveupthisnameofArthurDimmesdale,andmakethyselfanother,andahighone,suchasthoucanstwearwithoutfearorshame. Whyshouldstthoutarrysomuchasoneotherdayinthetormentsthathavesognawedintothylife? thathavemadetheefeebletowillandtodo? thatwillleavetheepowerlesseventorepent?Up,andaway!” “Oh,Hester!”criedArthurDimmesdale,inwhoseeyesafitfullight,kindledbyherenthusiasm,flashedupanddiedaway,“thoutellestofrunningaracetoamanwhosekneesaretotteringbeneathhim!Imustdiehere! Thereisnotthestrengthorcourageleftmetoventureintothewide,strange,difficultworldalone!” Itwasthelastexpressionofthedespondencyofabrokenspirit.Helackedenergytograspthebetterfortunethatseemedwithinhisreach. Herepeatedtheword—“Alone,Hester!” “Thoushallnotgoalone!”answeredshe,inadeepwhisper.Then,allwasspoken!