InherlatesingularinterviewwithMr.Dimmesdale,HesterPrynnewasshockedattheconditiontowhichshefoundtheclergymanreduced.Hisnerveseemedabsolutelydestroyed. Hismoralforcewasabasedintomorethanchildishweakness. Itgrovelledhelplessontheground,evenwhilehisintellectualfacultiesretainedtheirpristinestrength,orhadperhapsacquiredamorbidenergy,whichdiseaseonlycouldhavegiventhem. Withherknowledgeofatrainofcircumstanceshiddenfromallothers,shecouldreadilyinferthat,besidesthelegitimateactionofhisownconscience,aterriblemachineryhadbeenbroughttobear,andwasstilloperating,onMr.Dimmesdale’swell–beingandrepose. Knowingwhatthispoorfallenmanhadoncebeen,herwholesoulwasmovedbytheshudderingterrorwithwhichhehadappealedtoher—theoutcastwoman—forsupportagainsthisinstinctivelydiscoveredenemy. Shedecided,moreover,thathehadarighttoherutmostaid. Littleaccustomed,inherlongseclusionfromsociety,tomeasureherideasofrightandwrongbyanystandardexternaltoherself,Hestersaw—orseemedtosee—thattherelayaresponsibilityuponherinreferencetotheclergyman,whichsheownedtonoother,nortothewholeworldbesides. Thelinksthatunitedhertotherestofhumankind—linksofflowers,orsilk,orgold,orwhateverthematerial—hadallbeenbroken. Herewastheironlinkofmutualcrime,whichneitherhenorshecouldbreak. Likeallotherties,itbroughtalongwithititsobligations. HesterPrynnedidnotnowoccupypreciselythesamepositioninwhichwebeheldherduringtheearlierperiodsofherignominy.Yearshadcomeandgone.Pearlwasnowsevenyearsold. Hermother,withthescarletletteronherbreast,glitteringinitsfantasticembroidery,hadlongbeenafamiliarobjecttothetownspeople. Asisapttobethecasewhenapersonstandsoutinanyprominencebeforethecommunity,and,atthesametime,interferesneitherwithpublicnorindividualinterestsandconvenience,aspeciesofgeneralregardhadultimatelygrownupinreferencetoHesterPrynne. Itistothecreditofhumannaturethat,exceptwhereitsselfishnessisbroughtintoplay,itlovesmorereadilythanithates. Hatred,byagradualandquietprocess,willevenbetransformedtolove,unlessthechangebeimpededbyacontinuallynewirritationoftheoriginalfeelingofhostility. InthismatterofHesterPrynnetherewasneitherirritationnorirksomeness. Sheneverbattledwiththepublic,butsubmitteduncomplaininglytoitsworstusage;shemadenoclaimuponitinrequitalforwhatshesuffered;shedidnotweighuponitssympathies. Then,also,theblamelesspurityofherlifeduringalltheseyearsinwhichshehadbeensetaparttoinfamywasreckonedlargelyinherfavour. Withnothingnowtolose,inthesightofmankind,andwithnohope,andseeminglynowish,ofgaininganything,itcouldonlybeagenuineregardforvirtuethathadbroughtbackthepoorwanderertoitspaths. Itwasperceived,too,thatwhileHesterneverputforwardeventhehumblesttitletoshareintheworld’sprivileges—furtherthantobreathethecommonairandearndailybreadforlittlePearlandherselfbythefaithfullabourofherhands—shewasquicktoacknowledgehersisterhoodwiththeraceofmanwheneverbenefitsweretobeconferred. Nonesoreadyasshetogiveofherlittlesubstancetoeverydemandofpoverty,eventhoughthebitter–heartedpauperthrewbackagibeinrequitalofthefoodbroughtregularlytohisdoor,orthegarmentswroughtforhimbythefingersthatcouldhaveembroideredamonarch’srobe. Nonesoself–devotedasHesterwhenpestilencestalkedthroughthetown. Inallseasonsofcalamity,indeed,whethergeneralorofindividuals,theoutcastofsocietyatoncefoundherplace. Shecame,notasaguest,butasarightfulinmate,intothehouseholdthatwasdarkenedbytrouble,asifitsgloomytwilightwereamediuminwhichshewasentitledtoholdintercoursewithherfellow–creatureThereglimmeredtheembroideredletter,withcomfortinitsunearthlyray. Elsewherethetokenofsin,itwasthetaperofthesickchamber. Ithadeventhrownitsgleam,inthesufferer’sbardextremity,acrossthevergeoftime. Ithadshownhimwheretosethisfoot,whilethelightofearthwasfastbecomingdim,anderethelightoffuturitycouldreachhim. InsuchemergenciesHester’snatureshoweditselfwarmandrich—awell–springofhumantenderness,unfailingtoeveryrealdemand,andinexhaustiblebythelargest. Herbreast,withitsbadgeofshame,wasbutthesofterpillowfortheheadthatneededone. Shewasself–ordainedaSisterofMercy,or,wemayrathersay,theworld’sheavyhandhadsoordainedher,whenneithertheworldnorshelookedforwardtothisresult. Theletterwasthesymbolofhercalling. Suchhelpfulnesswasfoundinher—somuchpowertodo,andpowertosympathize—thatmanypeoplerefusedtointerpretthescarletAbyitsoriginalsignification. TheysaidthatitmeantAble,sostrongwasHesterPrynne,withawoman’sstrength. Itwasonlythedarkenedhousethatcouldcontainher. Whensunshinecameagain,shewasnotthere. Hershadowhadfadedacrossthethreshold. Thehelpfulinmatehaddeparted,withoutonebackwardglancetogatherupthemeedofgratitude,ifanywereintheheartsofthosewhomshehadservedsozealously. Meetingtheminthestreet,sheneverraisedherheadtoreceivetheirgreeting. Iftheywereresolutetoaccosther,shelaidherfingeronthescarletletter,andpassedon. Thismightbepride,butwassolikehumility,thatitproducedallthesofteninginfluenceofthelatterqualityonthepublicmind. Thepublicisdespoticinitstemper;itiscapableofdenyingcommonjusticewhentoostrenuouslydemandedasaright;butquiteasfrequentlyitawardsmorethanjustice,whentheappealismade,asdespotslovetohaveitmade,entirelytoitsgenerosity. InterpretingHesterPrynne’sdeportmentasanappealofthisnature,societywasinclinedtoshowitsformervictimamorebenigncountenancethanshecaredtobefavouredwith,or,perchance,thanshedeserved. Therulers,andthewiseandlearnedmenofthecommunity,werelongerinacknowledgingtheinfluenceofHester’sgoodqualitiesthanthepeople. Theprejudiceswhichtheysharedincommonwiththelatterwerefortifiedinthemselvesbyanironframe–workofreasoning,thatmadeitafartougherlabourtoexpelthem. Daybyday,nevertheless,theirsourandrigidwrinkleswererelaxingintosomethingwhich,intheduecourseofyears,mightgrowtobeanexpressionofalmostbenevolence. Thusitwaswiththemenofrank,onwhomtheireminentpositionimposedtheguardianshipofthepublicmorals. Individualsinprivatelife,meanwhile,hadquiteforgivenHesterPrynneforherfrailty;nay,more,theyhadbeguntolookuponthescarletletterasthetoken,notofthatonesinforwhichshehadbornesolonganddrearyapenance,butofhermanygooddeedssince. “Doyouseethatwomanwiththeembroideredbadge?”theywouldsaytostrangers. “ItisourHester—thetown’sownHester—whoissokindtothepoor,sohelpfultothesick,socomfortabletotheafflicted!” Then,itistrue,thepropensityofhumannaturetotelltheveryworstofitself,whenembodiedinthepersonofanother,wouldconstrainthemtowhispertheblackscandalofbygoneyears. Itwasnonethelessafact,however,thatintheeyesoftheverymenwhospokethus,thescarletletterhadtheeffectofthecrossonanun’sbosom. Itimpartedtothewearerakindofsacredness,whichenabledhertowalksecurelyamidallperil. Hadshefallenamongthieves,itwouldhavekepthersafe. Itwasreported,andbelievedbymany,thatanIndianhaddrawnhisarrowagainstthebadge,andthatthemissilestruckit,andfellharmlesstotheground. Theeffectofthesymbol—orrather,ofthepositioninrespecttosocietythatwasindicatedbyit—onthemindofHesterPrynneherselfwaspowerfulandpeculiar. Allthelightandgracefulfoliageofhercharacterhadbeenwitheredupbythisred–hotbrand,andhadlongagofallenaway,leavingabareandharshoutline,whichmighthavebeenrepulsivehadshepossessedfriendsorcompanionstoberepelledbyit. Eventheattractivenessofherpersonhadundergoneasimilarchange. Itmightbepartlyowingtothestudiedausterityofherdress,andpartlytothelackofdemonstrationinhermanners. Itwasasadtransformation,too,thatherrichandluxurianthairhadeitherbeencutoff,orwassocompletelyhiddenbyacap,thatnotashininglockofiteveroncegushedintothesunshine. Itwasdueinparttoallthesecauses,butstillmoretosomethingelse,thatthereseemedtobenolongeranythinginHester’sfaceforLovetodwellupon;nothinginHester’sform,thoughmajesticandstatuelike,thatPassionwouldeverdreamofclaspinginitsembrace;nothinginHester’sbosomtomakeiteveragainthepillowofAffection. Someattributehaddepartedfromher,thepermanenceofwhichhadbeenessentialtokeepherawoman. Suchisfrequentlythefate,andsuchthesterndevelopment,ofthefemininecharacterandperson,whenthewomanhasencountered,andlivedthrough,anexperienceofpeculiarseverity.Ifshebealltenderness,shewilldie. Ifshesurvive,thetendernesswilleitherbecrushedoutofher,or—andtheoutwardsemblanceisthesame—crushedsodeeplyintoherheartthatitcannevershowitselfmore. Thelatterisperhapsthetruesttheory. Shewhohasoncebeenawoman,andceasedtobeso,mightatanymomentbecomeawomanagain,iftherewereonlythemagictouchtoeffectthetransformation. WeshallseewhetherHesterPrynnewereeverafterwardssotouchedandsotransfigured. MuchofthemarblecoldnessofHester’simpressionwastobeattributedtothecircumstancethatherlifehadturned,inagreatmeasure,frompassionandfeelingtothought. Standingaloneintheworld—alone,astoanydependenceonsociety,andwithlittlePearltobeguidedandprotected—alone,andhopelessofretrievingherposition,evenhadshenotscornedtoconsideritdesirable—shecastawaythefragmentabrokenchain. Theworld’slawwasnolawforhermind. Itwasanageinwhichthehumanintellect,newlyemancipated,hadtakenamoreactiveandawiderrangethanformanycenturiesbefore. Menoftheswordhadoverthrownnoblesandkings. Menbolderthanthesehadoverthrownandrearranged—notactually,butwithinthesphereoftheory,whichwastheirmostrealabode—thewholesystemofancientprejudice,wherewithwaslinkedmuchofancientprinciple.HesterPrynneimbibedthisspirit. Sheassumedafreedomofspeculation,thencommonenoughontheothersideoftheAtlantic,butwhichourforefathers,hadtheyknownit,wouldhaveheldtobeadeadliercrimethanthatstigmatisedbythescarletletter. Inherlonesomecottage,bytheseashore,thoughtsvisitedhersuchasdaredtoenternootherdwellinginNewEngland;shadowyguests,thatwouldhavebeenasperilousasdemonstotheirentertainer,couldtheyhavebeenseensomuchasknockingatherdoor. Itisremarkablethatpersonswhospeculatethemostboldlyoftenconformwiththemostperfectquietudetotheexternalregulationsofsociety. Thethoughtsufficesthem,withoutinvestingitselfinthefleshandbloodofaction.SoitseemedtobewithHester. Yet,hadlittlePearlnevercometoherfromthespiritualworld,itmighthavebeenfarotherwise. Thenshemighthavecomedowntousinhistory,handinhandwithAnnHutchinson,asthefoundressofareligioussect. Shemight,inoneofherphases,havebeenaprophetess. Shemight,andnotimprobablywould,havesuffereddeathfromthesterntribunalsoftheperiod,forattemptingtounderminethefoundationsofthePuritanestablishment. But,intheeducationofherchild,themother’senthusiasmthoughthadsomethingtowreakitselfupon. Providence,inthepersonofthislittlegirl,hadassignedtoHester’scharge,thegermandblossomofwomanhood,tobecherishedanddevelopedamidahostofdifficulties.Everythingwasagainsther.Theworldwashostile. Thechild’sownnaturehadsomethingwronginitwhichcontinuallybetokenedthatshehadbeenbornamiss—theeffluenceofhermother’slawlesspassion—andoftenimpelledHestertoask,inbitternessofheart,whetheritwereforillorgoodthatthepoorlittlecreaturehadbeenbornatall. Indeed,thesamedarkquestionoftenroseintohermindwithreferencetothewholeraceofwomanhood. Wasexistenceworthacceptingeventothehappiestamongthem? Asconcernedherownindividualexistence,shehadlongagodecidedinthenegative,anddismissedthepointassettled. Atendencytospeculation,thoughitmaykeepwomenquiet,asitdoesman,yetmakeshersad. Shediscerns,itmaybe,suchahopelesstaskbeforeher. Asafirststep,thewholesystemofsocietyistobetorndownandbuiltupanew. Thentheverynatureoftheoppositesex,oritslonghereditaryhabit,whichhasbecomelikenature,istobeessentiallymodifiedbeforewomancanbeallowedtoassumewhatseemsafairandsuitableposition. Finally,allotherdifficultiesbeingobviated,womancannottakeadvantageofthesepreliminaryreformsuntilsheherselfshallhaveundergoneastillmightierchange,inwhich,perhaps,theetherealessence,whereinshehashertruestlife,willbefoundtohaveevaporated. Awomanneverovercomestheseproblemsbyanyexerciseofthought. Theyarenottobesolved,oronlyinoneway. Ifherheartchancetocomeuppermost,theyvanish. ThusHesterPrynne,whosehearthadlostitsregularandhealthythrob,wanderedwithoutaclueinthedarklabyrinthofmind;nowturnedasidebyaninsurmountableprecipice;nowstartingbackfromadeepchasm. Therewaswildandghastlysceneryallaroundher,andahomeandcomfortnowhere. Attimesafearfuldoubtstrovetopossesshersoul,whetheritwerenotbettertosendPearlatoncetoHeaven,andgoherselftosuchfuturityasEternalJusticeshouldprovide. Thescarletletterhadnotdoneitsoffice. Now,however,herinterviewwiththeReverendMr.Dimmesdale,onthenightofhisvigil,hadgivenheranewthemeofreflection,andhelduptoheranobjectthatappearedworthyofanyexertionandsacrificeforitsattainment. Shehadwitnessedtheintensemiserybeneathwhichtheministerstruggled,or,tospeakmoreaccurately,hadceasedtostruggle. Shesawthathestoodonthevergeoflunacy,ifhehadnotalreadysteppedacrossit. Itwasimpossibletodoubtthat,whateverpainfulefficacytheremightbeinthesecretstingofremorse,adeadliervenomhadbeeninfusedintoitbythehandthatprofferedrelief. Asecretenemyhadbeencontinuallybyhisside,underthesemblanceofafriendandhelper,andhadavailedhimselfoftheopportunitiesthusaffordedfortamperingwiththedelicatespringsofMr.Dimmesdale’snature. Hestercouldnotbutaskherselfwhethertherehadnotoriginallybeenadefectoftruth,courage,andloyaltyonherownpart,inallowingtheministertobethrownintopositionwheresomuchevilwastobeforebodedandnothingauspicioustobehoped. HeronlyjustificationlayinthefactthatshehadbeenabletodiscernnomethodofrescuinghimfromablackerruinthanhadoverwhelmedherselfexceptbyacquiescinginRogerChillingworth’sschemeofdisguise. Underthatimpulseshehadmadeherchoice,andhadchosen,asitnowappeared,themorewretchedalternativeofthetwo. Shedeterminedtoredeemhererrorsofarasitmightyetbepossible. Strengthenedbyyearsofhardandsolemntrial,shefeltherselfnolongersoinadequatetocopewithRogerChillingworthasonthatnight,abasedbysinandhalf–maddenedbytheignominythatwasstillnew,whentheyhadtalkedtogetherintheprison–chamber. Shehadclimbedherwaysincethentoahigherpoint. Theoldman,ontheotherhand,hadbroughthimselfnearertoherlevel,or,perhaps,belowit,bytherevengewhichhehadstoopedfor. Infine,HesterPrynneresolvedtomeetherformerhusband,anddowhatmightbeinherpowerfortherescueofthevictimonwhomhehadsoevidentlysethisgripe.Theoccasionwasnotlongtoseek. Oneafternoon,walkingwithPearlinaretiredpartofthepeninsula,shebeheldtheoldphysicianwithabasketononearmandastaffintheotherhand,stoopingalongthegroundinquestofrootsandherbstoconcocthismedicinewithal.