Itwasdarkenoughwhenwestartedtomakeitnoeasymattertofindourwayacrossthemoors,butasweadvanceditgrewlighterandlighter,untilbythetimewereachedFullarton’scabinitwasbroaddaylight. Earlyasitwas,hewasupandabout,fortheWigtownpeasantsareanearlyrisingrace. Weexplainedourmissiontohiminasfewwordsaspossible,andhavingmadehisbargain—whatScoteverneglectedthatpreliminary? —heagreednotonlytoletushavetheuseofhisdogbuttocomewithushimself. Mordaunt,inhisdesireforprivacy,wouldhavedemurredatthisarrangement,butIpointedouttohimthatwehadnoideawhatwasinstoreforus,andtheadditionofastrong,able-bodiedmantoourpartymightprovetobeoftheutmostconsequence. Again,thedogwaslesslikelytogiveustroubleifwehaditsmastertocontrolit.Myargumentscarriedtheday,andthebipedaccompaniedusaswellashisfour-footedcompanion. Therewassomelittlesimilaritybetweenthetwo,forthemanwasatowsy-headedfellowwithagreatmopofyellowhairandastragglingbeard,whilethedogwasofthelong-haired,unkemptbreedlookinglikeananimatedbundleofoakum. AllourwaytotheHallitsownerkeptretailinginstancesofthecreature’ssagacityandpowersofscent,which,accordingtohisaccount,werelittlelessthanmiraculous. Hisanecdoteshadapooraudience,Ifear,formymindwasfilledwiththestrangestorywhichIhadbeenreading,whileMordauntstrodeonwithwildeyesandfeverishcheeks,withoutathoughtforanythingbuttheproblemwhichwehadtosolve. AgainandagainaswetoppedaneminenceIsawhimlookeagerlyroundhiminthefainthopeofseeingsometraceoftheabsentee,butoverthewholeexpanseofmoorlandtherewasnosignofmovementoroflife.Allwasdeadandsilentanddeserted. OurvisittotheHallwasaverybriefone,foreveryminutenowwasofimportance. Mordauntrushedinandemergedwithanoldcoatofhisfather’s,whichhehandedtoFullarton,whohelditouttothedog. Theintelligentbrutesniffedatitallover,thenranwhiningalittlewaydowntheavenue,camebacktosniffthecoatagain,andfinallyelevatingitsstumpofatailintriumph,utteredasuccessionofsharpyelpstoshowthatitwassatisfiedthatithadstruckthetrail. Itsownertiedalongcordtoitscollartopreventitfromgoingtoofastforus,andweallsetoffuponoursearch,thedogtuggingandtrainingatitsleashinitsexcitementasitfollowedinthegeneral’sfootsteps. Ourwaylayforacoupleofhundredyardsalongthehighroad,andthenpassedthroughagapInthehedgeandontothemoor,acrosswhichwewereledinabee-linetothenorthward. Thesunhadbythistimerisenabovethehorizon,andthewholecountrysidelookedsofreshandsweet,fromtheblue,sparklingseatothepurplemountains,thatitwasdifficulttorealizehowweirdanduncannywastheenterpriseuponwhichwewereengaged. Thescentmusthavelainstronglyupontheground,forthedogneverhesitatednorstopped,draggingitsmasteralongatapacewhichrenderedconversationimpossible. Atoneplace,incrossingasmallstream,weseemedtogetoffthetrailforafewminutes,butourkeen-nosedallysoonpickeditupontheothersideandfolloweditoverthetracklessmoor,whiningandyelpingallthetimeinitseagerness. Hadwenotallthreebeenfleetoffootandlongofwind,wecouldnothavepersistedinthecontinuous,rapidjourneyovertheroughestofground,withtheheatheroftenwell-nighuptoourwaists. Formyownpart,Ihavenoideanow,lookingback,whatgoalitwaswhichIexpectedtoreachattheendofourpursuit. Icanrememberthatmymindwasfullofthevaguestandmostvaryingspeculations. CoulditbethatthethreeBuddhistshadhadacraftinreadinessoffthecoast,andhadembarkedwiththeirprisonersfortheEast? Thedirectionoftheirtrackseemedatfirsttofavourthissupposition,foritlayinthelineoftheupperendofthebay,butitendedbybranchingoffandstrikingdirectlyinland. Clearlytheoceanwasnottobeourterminus. Byteno’clockwehadwalkedcloseupontwelvemiles,andwerecompelledtocallahaltforafewminutestorecoverourbreath,forthelastmileortwowehadbeenbreastingthelong,wearyingslopeoftheWigtownhills. Fromthesummitofthisrange,whichisnowheremorethanathousandfeetinheight,wecouldsee,lookingnorthward,suchasceneofbleaknessanddesolationascanhardlybematchedinanycountry. Rightawaytothehorizonstretchedthebroadexpanseofmudandofwater,mingledandmixedtogetherinthewildestchaos,likeaportionofsomeworldintheprocessofformation. Hereandthereonthedun-colouredsurfaceofthisgreatmarshtherehadburstoutpatchesofsicklyyellowreedsandoflivid,greenishscum,whichonlyservedtoheightenandintensifythegloomyeffectofthedull,melancholyexpanse. Onthesidenearesttoussomeabandonedpeat-cuttingsshowedthatubiquitousmanhadbeenatworkthere,butbeyondthesefewpettyscarstherewasnosignanywhereofhumanlife. Notevenacrownoraseagullflappeditswayoverthathideousdesert. ThisisthegreatBogofCree.Itisasalt-watermarshformedbyaninroadofthesea,andsointersectedisitwithdangerousswampsandtreacherouspitfallsofliquidmud,thatnomanwouldventurethroughitunlesshehadtheguidanceofoneofthefewpeasantswhoretainthesecretofitspaths. Asweapproachedthefringeofrusheswhichmarkeditsborder,afoul,danksmellroseupfromthestagnantwilderness,asfromimpurewateranddecayingvegetation—anearthy,noisomesmellwhichpoisonedthefreshuplandair. Soforbiddingandgloomywastheaspectoftheplacethatourstoutcrofterhesitated,anditwasallthatwecoulddotopersuadehimtoproceed. Ourlurcher,however,notbeingsubjecttothedelicateimpressionsofourhigherorganization,stillranyelpingalongwithitsnoseonthegroundandeveryfibreofitsbodyquiveringwithexcitementandeagerness. Therewasnodifficultyaboutpickingourwaythroughthemorass,forwhereverthefivecouldgowethreecouldfollow. Ifwecouldhavehadanydoubtsastoourdog’sguidancetheywouldallhavebeenremovednow,forinthesoft,black,oozingsoilwecoulddistinctlytracethetracksofthewholeparty. Fromthesewecouldseethattheyhadwalkedabreast,and,furthermore,thateachwasaboutequidistantfromtheother. Clearly,then,nophysicalforcehadbeenusedintakingthegeneralandhiscompanionalong. Thecompulsionhadbeenpsychicalandnotmaterial. Oncewithintheswamp,wehadtobecarefulnottodeviatefromthenarrowtrack,whichofferedafirmfoothold. Oneachsidelayshallowsheetsofstagnantwateroverlyingatreacherousbottomofsemi-fluidmud,whichroseabovethesurfacehereandthereinmoist,swelteringbanks,mottledoverwithoccasionalpatchesofunhealthyvegetation. Greatpurpleandyellowfungihadbrokenoutinadenseeruption,asthoughNaturewereafflictedwithafouldisease,whichmanifesteditselfbythiscropofplaguespots. Hereandtheredark,crab-likecreaturesscuttledacrossourpath,andhideous,flesh-colouredwormswriggledandwrithedamidthesicklyreeds. Swarmsofbuzzing,pipinginsectsroseupateverystepandformedadensecloudaroundourheads,settlingonourhandsandfacesandinoculatinguswiththeirfilthyvenom. NeverhadIventuredintosopestilentandforbiddingaplace. MordauntHeatherstonestrodeon,however,withasetpurposeuponhisswarthybrow,andwecouldbutfollowhim,determinedtostandbyhimtotheendoftheadventure. Asweadvanced,thepathgrewnarrowerandnarroweruntil,aswesawbythetracks,ourpredecessorshadbeencompelledtowalkinsinglefile. Fullartonwasleadinguswiththedog,Mordauntbehindhim,whileIbroughtuptherear. Thepeasanthadbeensulkyandsurlyforalittletimeback,hardlyansweringwhenspokento,buthenowstoppedshortandpositivelyrefusedtogoastepfarther. portraitofSirArthurConanDoyle “It’sno’canny,”hesaid,“besidesIkenwhereitwillleadustae’” “TaetheHoleo’Cree,”heanswered.“It’snofarfraehere,I’mthinking.” “TheHoleofCree!Whatisthat,then?” “It’sagreat,muckleholeinthegroundthatgangsawa’doonsodeepthatnaebodycouldeverreachthebottom. Indeedtherearefolkwhasaysthatit’sjustadoorleadin’intaethebottomlesspititsel’” “Youhavebeenthere,then?”Iasked. “Beenthere!”hecried.“WhatwouldIbedoin’attheHoleo’Cree?No,I’veneverbeenthere,noranyothermaninhissenses.” “Howdoyouknowaboutit,then?” “Mygreat-grandfeytherhadbeenthere,andthat’showIken,”Fullartonanswered. “Hewasfou’oneSaturdaynichtandhewentforabet. Hedidnaliketaetalkabootitafterwards,andhewouldnatella’whatbefellhim,buthewasayefearedo’theveryname. He’sthefirstFullartonthat’sbeenattheHoleo’Cree,andhe’llbethelastforme. Ifye’lltak’myadviceye’lljustgiethematterupandgangnameagain,forthere’snaguidtaebegotooto’thisplace.” “Weshallgoonwithyouorwithoutyou,”Mordauntanswered.“Letushaveyourdogandwecanpickyouuponourwayback.” “Na,na,”hecried,“I’llno’haemydogscaretwi’bogles,andrunningdownAuldNickasifhewereahare.Thedogshallbidewi’me.” “Thedogshallgowithus,”saidmycompanion,withhiseyesblazing.“Wehavenotimetoarguewithyou.Here’safive-poundnote. Letushavethedog,or,byHeaven,Ishalltakeitbyforceandthrowyouinthebogifyouhinderus.” IcouldrealizetheHeatherstoneoffortyyearsagowhenIsawthefierceandsuddenwrathwhichlitupthefeaturesofhisson. Eitherthebribeorthethreathadthedesiredeffect,forthefellowgrabbedatthemoneywithonehandwhilewiththeotherhesurrenderedtheleashwhichheldthelurcher. Leavinghimtoretracehissteps,wecontinuedtomakeourwayintotheutmostrecessesofthegreatswamp. Thetortuouspathgrewlessandlessdefinedasweproceeded,andwasevencoveredinplaceswithwater,buttheincreasingexcitementofthehoundandthesightofthedeepfootmarksinthemudstimulatedustopushon. Atlast,afterstrugglingthroughagroveofhighbulrushes,wecameonaspotthegloomyhorrorofwhichmighthavefurnishedDantewithafreshterrorforhis“Inferno.” Thewholeboginthispartappearedtohavesunkin,formingagreat,funnel-shapeddepression,whichterminatedinthecentreinacircularriftoropeningaboutfortyfeetindiameter. Itwasawhirlpool—aperfectmaelstromofmud,slopingdownoneverysidetothissilentandawfulchasm. Clearlythiswasthespotwhich,underthenameoftheHoleofCree,boresuchasinisterreputationamongtherustics. Icouldnotwonderatitsimpressingtheirimagination,foramoreweirdorgloomyscene,oronemoreworthyoftheavenuewhichledtoit,couldnotbeconceived. Thestepspasseddownthedeclivitywhichsurroundedtheabyss,andwefollowedthemwithasinkingfeelinginourhearts,aswerealizedthatthiswastheendofoursearch. Alittlewayfromthedownwardpathwasthereturntrailmadebythefeetofthosewhohadcomebackfromthechasm’sedge. Oureyesfelluponthesetracksatthesamemoment,andweeachgaveacryofhorror,andstoodgazingspeechlesslyatthem. Forthere,inthoseblurredfootmarks,thewholedramawasrevealed. Fivehadgonedown,butonlythreehadreturned. Noneshalleverknowthedetailsofthatstrangetragedy. Therewasnomarkofstrugglenorsignofattemptatescape. WekneltattheedgeoftheHoleandendeavouredtopiercetheunfathomablegloomwhichshroudedit. Afaint,sicklyexhalationseemedtorisefromitsdepths,andtherewasadistanthurrying,clatteringsoundasofwatersinthebowelsoftheearth. Agreatstonelayembeddedinthemud,andthisIhurledover,butweneverheardthudorsplashtoshowthatithadreachedthebottom. Aswehungoverthenoisomechasmasounddidatlastrisetoourearsoutofitsmurkydepths. High,clear,andthrobbing,ittinkledforaninstantoutoftheabyss,tobesucceededbythesamedeadlystillnesswhichhadprecededit. Ididnotwishtoappearsuperstitious,ortoputdowntoextraordinarycausesthatwhichmayhaveanaturalexplanation. Thatonekeennotemayhavebeensomestrangewatersoundproducedfardowninthebowelsoftheearth. ItmayhavebeenthatoritmayhavebeenthatsinisterbellofwhichIhadheardsomuch. Bethisasitmay,itwastheonlysignthatrosetousfromthelastterribleresting-placeofthetwowhohadpaidthedebtwhichhadsolongbeenowing. Wejoinedourvoicesinacallwiththeunreasoningobstinacywithwhichmenwillclingtohope,butnoanswercamebacktoussaveahollowmoaningfromthedepthsbeneath. Footsoreandheart-sick,weretracedourstepsandclimbedtheslimyslopeoncemore. “Whatshallwedo,Mordaunt?”Iasked,inasubduedvoice.“Wecanbutpraythattheirsoulsmayrestinpeace.” YoungHeatherstonelookedatmewithflashingeyes. “Thismaybeallaccordingtooccultlaws,”hecried,“butweshallseewhatthelawsofEnglandhavetosayuponit. Isupposeachelamaybehangedaswellasanyotherman. Itmaynotbetoolateyettorunthemdown.Here,gooddog,gooddog-here!” Hepulledthehoundoverandsetitonthetrackofthethreemen. Thecreaturesniffedatitonceortwice,andthen,fallinguponitsstomach,withbristlinghairandprotrudingtongue,itlayshiveringandtrembling,averyembodimentofcanineterror. “Yousee,”Isaid,“itisnousecontendingagainstthosewhohavepowersattheircommandtowhichwecannotevengiveaname. Thereisnothingforitbuttoaccepttheinevitable,andtohopethatthesepoormenmaymeetwithsomecompensationinanotherworldforallthattheyhavesufferedinthis.” “Andbefreefromalldevilishreligionsandtheirmurderousworshippers!”Mordauntcriedfuriously. JusticecompelledmetoacknowledgeinmyownheartthatthemurderousspirithadbeensetonfootbytheChristianbeforeitwastakenupbytheBuddhists,butIforboretoremarkuponit,forfearofirritatingmycompanion. ForalongtimeIcouldnotdrawhimawayfromthesceneofhisfather’sdeath,butatlast,byrepeatedargumentsandreasonings,Isucceededinmakinghimrealizehowuselessandunprofitableanyfurthereffortsonourpartmustnecessarilyprove,andininducinghimtoreturnwithmetoCloomber. Oh,thewearisome,tediousjourney!Ithadseemedlongenoughwhenwehadsomeslightflickerofhope,oratleastofexpectation,beforeus,butnowthatourworstfearswerefulfilleditappearedinterminable. Wepickedupourpeasantguideattheoutskirtsofthemarsh,andhavingrestoredhisdogwelethimfindhisownwayhome,withouttellinghimanythingoftheresultsofourexpedition. Weourselvesploddedalldayoverthemoorswithheavyfeetandheavierheartsuntilwesawtheill-omenedtowerofCloomber,andatlast,asthesunwassetting,foundourselvesoncemorebeneathitsroof. Thereisnoneedformetoenterintofurtherdetails,nortodescribethegriefwhichourtidingsconveyedtomotherandtodaughter. Theirlongexpectationofsomecalamitywasnotsufficienttopreparethemfortheterriblereality. ForweeksmypoorGabrielhoveredbetweenlifeanddeath,andthoughshecameroundallast,thankstothenursingofmysisterandtheprofessionalskillofDr.JohnEasterling,shehasnevertothisdayentirelyrecoveredherformervigour. Mordaunt,too,sufferedmuchforsometime,anditwasonlyafterourremovaltoEdinburghthatheralliedfromtheshockwhichhehadundergone. AstopoorMrs.Heatherstone,neithermedicalattentionnorchangeofaircaneverhaveapermanenteffectuponher. Slowlyandsurely,butveryplacidly,shehasdeclinedinhealthandstrength,untilitisevidentthatinaveryfewweeksatthemostshewillhaverejoinedherhusbandandrestoredtohimtheonethingwhichhemusthavegrudgedtoleavebehind. TheLairdofBranksomecamehomefromItalyrestoredinhealth,withtheresultthatwewerecompelledtoreturnoncemoretoEdinburgh. Thechangewasagreeabletous,forrecenteventshadcastacloudoverourcountrylifeandhadsurroundeduswithunpleasantassociations. Besides,ahighlyhonourableandremunerativeappointmentinconnectionwiththeUniversitylibraryhadbecomevacant,andhad,throughthekindnessofthelateSirAlexanderGrant,beenofferedtomyfather,who,asmaybeimagined,lostnotimeinacceptingsocongenialapost. InthiswaywecamebacktoEdinburghverymuchmoreimportantpeoplethanweleftit,andwithnofurtherreasontobeuneasyaboutthedetailsofhousekeeping. But,intruth,thewholehouseholdhasbeendissolved,forIhavebeenmarriedforsomemonthstomydearGabriel,andEstheristobecomeMrs.Heatherstoneuponthe23rdofthemonth. Ifshemakeshimasgoodawifeashissisterhasmademe,wemaybothsetourselvesdownasfortunatemen. Thesemeredomesticepisodesare,asIhavealreadyexplained,introducedonlybecauseIcannotavoidalludingtothem. Myobjectindrawingupthisstatementandpublishingtheevidencewhichcorroboratesit,wascertainlynottoparademyprivateaffairsbeforethepublic,buttoleaveonrecordanauthenticnarrativeofamostremarkableseriesofevents. ThisIhaveendeavouredtodoinasmethodicalamanneraspossible,exaggeratingnothingandsuppressingnothing. Thereaderhasnowtheevidencebeforehim,andcanformhisownopinionsunaidedbymeastothecausesofthedisappearanceanddeathofRufusSmithandofJohnBerthierHeatherstone,V.C.,C.B. Thereisonlyonepointwhichisstilldarktome. WhythechelasofGhoolabShahshouldhaveremovedtheirvictimstothedesolateHoleofCreeinsteadoftakingtheirlivesatCloomber,is,Iconfess,amysterytome. Indealingwithoccultlaws,however,wemustallowforourowncompleteignoranceofthesubject. Didweknowmorewemightseethattherewassomeanalogybetweenthatfoulbogandthesacrilegewhichhadbeencommitted,andthattheirritualandcustomsdemandedthatjustsuchadeathwastheoneappropriatetothecrime. OnthispointIshouldbesorrytobedogmatic,butatleastwemustallowthattheBuddhistpriestsmusthavehadsomeverygoodcauseforthecourseofactionwhichtheysodeliberatelycarriedout. MonthsafterwardsIsawashortparagraphintheStarofIndiaannouncingthatthreeeminentBuddhists—LalHoomi,MowdarKhan,andRamSingh—hadjustreturnedinthesteamshipDeccanfromashorttriptoEurope. TheverynextitemwasdevotedtoanaccountofthelifeandservicesofMajor-GeneralHeatherstone,“whohaslatelydisappearedfromhiscountryhouseinWigtownshire,andwho,thereistoomuchreasontofear,hasbeendrowned.” Iwonderifbychancetherewasanyotherhumaneyebutminewhichtracedaconnectionbetweentheseparagraphs. InevershowedthemtomywifeortoMordaunt,andtheywillonlyknowoftheirexistencewhentheyreadthesepages. Idon’tknowthatthereisanyotherpointwhichneedsclearingup. Theintelligentreaderwillhavealreadyseenthereasonsforthegeneral’sfearofdarkfaces,ofwanderingmen(notknowinghowhispursuersmightcomeafterhim),andofvisitors(fromthesamecauseandbecausehishatefulbellwasliabletosoundatalltimes). Hisbrokensleepledhimtowanderaboutthehouseatnight,andthelampswhichheburntineveryroomwerenodoubttopreventhisimaginationfrompeoplingthedarknesswithterrors. Lastly,hiselaborateprecautionswere,ashehashimselfexplained,rathertheresultofafeverishdesiretodosomethingthanintheexpectationthathecouldreallywardoffhisfate. SciencewilltellyouthattherearenosuchpowersasthoseclaimedbytheEasternmystics.I,JohnFothergillWest,canconfidentlyanswerthatscienceiswrong. Forwhatisscience?Scienceistheconsensusofopinionofscientificmen,andhistoryhasshownthatitisslowtoacceptatruth. SciencesneeredatNewtonfortwentyyears. Scienceprovedmathematicallythatanironshipcouldnotswim,andsciencedeclaredthatasteamshipcouldnotcrosstheAtlantic. LikeGoethe’sMephistopheles,ourwiseprofessor’sforteis“stetsverneinen.” ThomasDidymusis,tousehisownjargon,hisprototype. Lethimlearnthatifhewillbutceasetobelieveintheinfallibilityofhisownmethods,andwilllooktotheEast,fromwhichallgreatmovementscome,hewillfindthereaschoolofphilosophersandofsavantswho,workingondifferentlinesfromhisown,aremanythousandyearsaheadofhiminalltheessentialsofknowledge.