ThethirdpersoninthetriowasLottie. Shewasasmallthinganddidnotknowwhatadversitymeant,andwasmuchbewilderedbythealterationshesawinheryoungadoptedmother. ShehadhearditrumoredthatstrangethingshadhappenedtoSara,butshecouldnotunderstandwhyshelookeddifferent—whysheworeanoldblackfrockandcameintotheschoolroomonlytoteachinsteadoftositinherplaceofhonorandlearnlessonsherself. TherehadbeenmuchwhisperingamongthelittleoneswhenithadbeendiscoveredthatSaranolongerlivedintheroomsinwhichEmilyhadsolongsatinstate. Lottie’schiefdifficultywasthatSarasaidsolittlewhenoneaskedherquestions. Atsevenmysteriesmustbemadeveryclearifoneistounderstandthem. “Areyouverypoornow,Sara?”shehadaskedconfidentiallythefirstmorningherfriendtookchargeofthesmallFrenchclass.“Areyouaspoorasabeggar?” Shethrustafathandintotheslimoneandopenedround,tearfuleyes. “Idon’twantyoutobeaspoorasabeggar.” Shelookedasifshewasgoingtocry.AndSarahurriedlyconsoledher. “Beggarshavenowheretolive,”shesaidcourageously.“Ihaveaplacetolivein.” “Wheredoyoulive?”persistedLottle.“Thenewgirlsleepsinyourroom,anditisn’tprettyanymore.” “Iliveinanotherroom,”saidSara. “Isitaniceone?”inquiredLottie.“Iwanttogoandseeit.” “Youmustnottalk,”saidSara.“MissMinchinislookingatus.Shewillbeangrywithmeforlettingyouwhisper.” Shehadfoundoutalreadythatshewastobeheldaccountableforeverythingwhichwasobjectedto. Ifthechildrenwerenotattentive,iftheytalked,iftheywererestless,itwasshewhowouldbereproved. ButLottiewasadeterminedlittleperson. IfSarawouldnottellherwhereshelived,shewouldfindoutinsomeotherway. Shetalkedtohersmallcompanionsandhungabouttheeldergirlsandlistenedwhentheyweregossiping;andactinguponcertaininformationtheyhadunconsciouslyletdrop,shestartedlateoneafternoononavoyageofdiscovery,climbingstairsshehadneverknowntheexistenceof,untilshereachedtheatticfloor. Thereshefoundtwodoorsneareachother,andopeningone,shesawherbelovedSarastandinguponanoldtableandlookingoutofawindow. “Sara!”shecried,aghast.“MammaSara!” Shewasaghastbecausetheatticwassobareanduglyandseemedsofarawayfromalltheworld. Hershortlegshadseemedtohavebeenmountinghundredsofstairs. Saraturnedroundatthesoundofhervoice.Itwasherturntobeaghast.Whatwouldhappennow? IfLottiebegantocryandanyonechancedtohear,theywerebothlost. Shejumpeddownfromhertableandrantothechild. “Don’tcryandmakeanoise,”sheimplored.“Ishallbescoldedifyoudo,andIhavebeenscoldedallday.It’s—it’snotsuchabadroom,Lottie.” “Isn’tit?”gaspedLottie,andasshelookedrounditshebitherlip. Shewasaspoiledchildyet,butshewasfondenoughofheradoptedparenttomakeanefforttocontrolherselfforhersake. Then,somehow,itwasquitepossiblethatanyplaceinwhichSaralivedmightturnouttobenice.“Whyisn’tit,Sara?”shealmostwhispered. Sarahuggedhercloseandtriedtolaugh.Therewasasortofcomfortinthewarmthoftheplump,childishbody.Shehadhadaharddayandhadbeenstaringoutofthewindowswithhoteyes. “Youcanseeallsortsofthingsyoucan’tseedownstairs,”shesaid. “Whatsortofthings?”demandedLottie,withthatcuriositySaracouldalwaysawakeneveninbiggergirls. “Chimneys—quiteclosetous—withsmokecurlingupinwreathsandcloudsandgoingupintothesky—andsparrowshoppingaboutandtalkingtoeachotherjustasiftheywerepeople—andotheratticwindowswhereheadsmaypopoutanyminuteandyoucanwonderwhotheybelongto. Anditallfeelsashighup—asifitwasanotherworld.” “Oh,letmeseeit!”criedLottie.“Liftmeup!” Saraliftedherup,andtheystoodontheoldtabletogetherandleanedontheedgeoftheflatwindowintheroof,andlookedout. Anyonewhohasnotdonethisdoesnotknowwhatadifferentworldtheysaw. Theslatesspreadoutoneithersideofthemandslanteddownintotheraingutter-pipes. Thesparrows,beingathomethere,twitteredandhoppedaboutquitewithoutfear. Twoofthemperchedonthechimneytopnearestandquarrelledwitheachotherfiercelyuntilonepeckedtheotheranddrovehimaway. Thegarretwindownexttotheirswasshutbecausethehousenextdoorwasempty. “Iwishsomeonelivedthere,”Sarasaid. “Itissoclosethatiftherewasalittlegirlintheattic,wecouldtalktoeachotherthroughthewindowsandclimbovertoseeeachother,ifwewerenotafraidoffalling.” Theskyseemedsomuchnearerthanwhenonesawitfromthestreet,thatLottiewasenchanted. Fromtheatticwindow,amongthechimneypots,thethingswhichwerehappeningintheworldbelowseemedalmostunreal. OnescarcelybelievedintheexistenceofMissMinchinandMissAmeliaandtheschoolroom,andtherollofwheelsinthesquareseemedasoundbelongingtoanotherexistence. “Oh,Sara!”criedLottie,cuddlinginherguardingarm.“Ilikethisattic—Ilikeit!Itisnicerthandownstairs!” “Lookatthatsparrow,”whisperedSara.“IwishIhadsomecrumbstothrowtohim.” “Ihavesome!”cameinalittleshriekfromLottie.“Ihavepartofabuninmypocket;Iboughtitwithmypennyyesterday,andIsavedabit.” Whentheythrewoutafewcrumbsthesparrowjumpedandflewawaytoanadjacentchimneytop. Hewasevidentlynotaccustomedtointimatesinattics,andunexpectedcrumbsstartledhim. ButwhenLottieremainedquitestillandSarachirpedverysoftly—almostasifshewereasparrowherself—hesawthatthethingwhichhadalarmedhimrepresentedhospitality,afterall. Heputhisheadononeside,andfromhisperchonthechimneylookeddownatthecrumbswithtwinklingeyes.Lottiecouldscarcelykeepstill. “Willhecome?Willhecome?”shewhispered. “Hiseyeslookasifhewould,”Sarawhisperedback.“Heisthinkingandthinkingwhetherhedare.Yes,hewill!Yes,heiscoming!” Heflewdownandhoppedtowardthecrumbs,butstoppedafewinchesawayfromthem,puttinghisheadononesideagain,asifreflectingonthechancesthatSaraandLottiemightturnouttobebigcatsandjumponhim. Atlasthishearttoldhimtheywerereallynicerthantheylooked,andhehoppednearerandnearer,dartedatthebiggestcrumbwithalightningpeck,seizedit,andcarrieditawaytotheothersideofhischimney. “Nowheknows”,saidSara.“Andhewillcomebackfortheothers.” Hedidcomeback,andevenbroughtafriend,andthefriendwentawayandbroughtarelative,andamongthemtheymadeaheartymealoverwhichtheytwitteredandchatteredandexclaimed,stoppingeverynowandthentoputtheirheadsononesideandexamineLottieandSara. Lottiewassodelightedthatshequiteforgotherfirstshockedimpressionoftheattic. Infact,whenshewaslifteddownfromthetableandreturnedtoearthlythings,asitwere,Sarawasabletopointouttohermanybeautiesintheroomwhichsheherselfwouldnothavesuspectedtheexistenceof. “Itissolittleandsohighaboveeverything,”shesaid,“thatitisalmostlikeanestinatree.Theslantingceilingissofunny. See,youcanscarcelystandupatthisendoftheroom;andwhenthemorningbeginstocomeIcanlieinbedandlookrightupintotheskythroughthatflatwindowintheroof.Itislikeasquarepatchoflight. Ifthesunisgoingtoshine,littlepinkcloudsfloatabout,andIfeelasifIcouldtouchthem. Andifitrains,thedropspatterandpatterasiftheyweresayingsomethingnice. Theniftherearestars,youcanlieandtrytocounthowmanygointothepatch.Ittakessuchalot. Andjustlookatthattiny,rustygrateinthecorner. Ifitwaspolishedandtherewasafireinit,justthinkhowniceitwouldbe. Yousee,it’sreallyabeautifullittleroom.” Shewaswalkingroundthesmallplace,holdingLottie’shandandmakinggestureswhichdescribedallthebeautiesshewasmakingherselfsee.ShequitemadeLottieseethem,too. LottiecouldalwaysbelieveinthethingsSaramadepicturesof. “Yousee,”shesaid,“therecouldbeathick,softblueIndianrugonthefloor;andinthatcornertherecouldbeasoftlittlesofa,withcushionstocurlupon;andjustoveritcouldbeashelffullofbookssothatonecouldreachthemeasily;andtherecouldbeafurrugbeforethefire,andhangingsonthewalltocoverupthewhitewash,andpictures. Theywouldhavetobelittleones,buttheycouldbebeautiful;andtherecouldbealampwithadeeprose-coloredshade;andatableinthemiddle,withthingstohaveteawith;andalittlefatcopperkettlesingingonthehob;andthebedcouldbequitedifferent. Itcouldbemadesoftandcoveredwithalovelysilkcoverlet.Itcouldbebeautiful. Andperhapswecouldcoaxthesparrowsuntilwemadesuchfriendswiththemthattheywouldcomeandpeckatthewindowandasktobeletin.” “Oh,Sara!”criedLottie.“Ishouldliketolivehere!” WhenSarahadpersuadedhertogodownstairsagain,and,aftersettingheronherway,hadcomebacktoherattic,shestoodinthemiddleofitandlookedabouther. TheenchantmentofherimaginingsforLottiehaddiedaway. Thebedwashardandcoveredwithitsdingyquilt. Thewhitewashedwallshoweditsbrokenpatches,thefloorwascoldandbare,thegratewasbrokenandrusty,andthebatteredfootstool,tiltedsidewaysonitsinjuredleg,theonlyseatintheroom. Shesatdownonitforafewminutesandletherheaddropinherhands. ThemerefactthatLottiehadcomeandgoneawayagainmadethingsseemalittleworse—justasperhapsprisonersfeelalittlemoredesolateaftervisitorscomeandgo,leavingthembehind. “It’salonelyplace,”shesaid.“Sometimesit’stheloneliestplaceintheworld.” Shewassittinginthiswaywhenherattentionwasattractedbyaslightsoundnearher. Sheliftedherheadtoseewhereitcamefrom,andifshehadbeenanervouschildshewouldhaveleftherseatonthebatteredfootstoolinagreathurry. Alargeratwassittinguponhishindquartersandsniffingtheairinaninterestedmanner. SomeofLottie’scrumbshaddroppeduponthefloorandtheirscenthaddrawnhimoutofhishole. Helookedsoqueerandsolikeagray-whiskereddwarforgnomethatSarawasratherfascinated. Helookedatherwithhisbrighteyes,asifhewereaskingaquestion. Hewasevidentlysodoubtfulthatoneofthechild’squeerthoughtscameintohermind. “Idaresayitisratherhardtobearat,”shemused.“Nobodylikesyou. Peoplejumpandrunawayandscreamout,`Oh,ahorridrat!’ Ishouldn’tlikepeopletoscreamandjumpandsay,`Oh,ahorridSara!’themomenttheysawme. Andsettrapsforme,andpretendtheyweredinner.It’ssodifferenttobeasparrow. Butnobodyaskedthisratifhewantedtobearatwhenhewasmade. Nobodysaid,`Wouldn’tyouratherbeasparrow?’” Shehadsatsoquietlythattherathadbeguntotakecourage. Hewasverymuchafraidofher,butperhapshehadaheartlikethesparrowandittoldhimthatshewasnotathingwhichpounced.Hewasveryhungry. Hehadawifeandalargefamilyinthewall,andtheyhadhadfrightfullybadluckforseveraldays. Hehadleftthechildrencryingbitterly,andfelthewouldriskagooddealforafewcrumbs,sohecautiouslydroppeduponhisfeet. “Comeon,”saidSara;“I’mnotatrap.Youcanhavethem,poorthing!PrisonersintheBastilleusedtomakefriendswithrats.SupposeImakefriendswithyou.” HowitisthatanimalsunderstandthingsIdonotknow,butitiscertainthattheydounderstand. Perhapsthereisalanguagewhichisnotmadeofwordsandeverythingintheworldunderstandsit. Perhapsthereisasoulhiddenineverythinganditcanalwaysspeak,withoutevenmakingasound,toanothersoul. Butwhatsoeverwasthereason,theratknewfromthatmomentthathewassafe—eventhoughhewasarat. Heknewthatthisyounghumanbeingsittingontheredfootstoolwouldnotjumpupandterrifyhimwithwild,sharpnoisesorthrowheavyobjectsathimwhich,iftheydidnotfallandcrushhim,wouldsendhimlimpinginhisscurrybacktohishole. Hewasreallyaverynicerat,anddidnotmeantheleastharm. Whenhehadstoodonhishindlegsandsniffedtheair,withhisbrighteyesfixedonSara,hehadhopedthatshewouldunderstandthis,andwouldnotbeginbyhatinghimasanenemy. Whenthemysteriousthingwhichspeakswithoutsayinganywordstoldhimthatshewouldnot,hewentsoftlytowardthecrumbsandbegantoeatthem. AshediditheglancedeverynowandthenatSara,justasthesparrowshaddone,andhisexpressionwassoveryapologeticthatittouchedherheart. Shesatandwatchedhimwithoutmakinganymovement. Onecrumbwasverymuchlargerthantheothers—infact,itcouldscarcelybecalledacrumb. Itwasevidentthathewantedthatpieceverymuch,butitlayquitenearthefootstoolandhewasstillrathertimid. “Ibelievehewantsittocarrytohisfamilyinthewall,”Sarathought.“IfIdonotstiratall,perhapshewillcomeandgetit.” Shescarcelyallowedherselftobreathe,shewassodeeplyinterested. Theratshuffledalittlenearerandateafewmorecrumbs,thenhestoppedandsniffeddelicately,givingasideglanceattheoccupantofthefootstool;thenhedartedatthepieceofbunwithsomethingverylikethesuddenboldnessofthesparrow,andtheinstanthehadpossessionofitfledbacktothewall,slippeddownacrackintheskirtingboard,andwasgone. “Iknewhewanteditforhischildren,”saidSara.“IdobelieveIcouldmakefriendswithhim.” Aweekorsoafterward,ononeoftherarenightswhenErmengardefounditsafetostealuptotheattic,whenshetappedonthedoorwiththetipsofherfingersSaradidnotcometoherfortwoorthreeminutes. Therewas,indeed,suchasilenceintheroomatfirstthatErmengardewonderedifshecouldhavefallenasleep. Then,tohersurprise,sheheardherutteralittle,lowlaughandspeakcoaxinglytosomeone. “There!”Ermengardeheardhersay.“Takeitandgohome,Melchisedec!Gohometoyourwife!” AlmostimmediatelySaraopenedthedoor,andwhenshedidsoshefoundErmengardestandingwithalarmedeyesuponthethreshold. “Who—whoareyoutalkingto,Sara?”shegaspedout. Saradrewherincautiously,butshelookedasifsomethingpleasedandamusedher. “Youmustpromisenottobefrightened—nottoscreamtheleastbit,orIcan’ttellyou,”sheanswered. Ermengardefeltalmostinclinedtoscreamonthespot,butmanagedtocontrolherself. Shelookedallroundtheatticandsawnoone. AndyetSarahadcertainlybeenspeakingtosomeone.Shethoughtofghosts. “Isit—somethingthatwillfrightenme?”sheaskedtimorously. “Somepeopleareafraidofthem,”saidSara.“Iwasatfirst—butIamnotnow.” “Wasit—aghost?”quakedErmengarde. “No,”saidSara,laughing.“Itwasmyrat.” Ermengardemadeonebound,andlandedinthemiddleofthelittledingybed.Shetuckedherfeetunderhernightgownandtheredshawl.Shedidnotscream,butshegaspedwithfright. “Oh!Oh!”shecriedunderherbreath.“Arat!Arat!” “Iwasafraidyouwouldbefrightened,”saidSara.“Butyouneedn’tbe.Iammakinghimtame.HeactuallyknowsmeandcomesoutwhenIcallhim.Areyoutoofrightenedtowanttoseehim?” Thetruthwasthat,asthedayshadgoneonand,withtheaidofscrapsbroughtupfromthekitchen,hercuriousfriendshiphaddeveloped,shehadgraduallyforgottenthatthetimidcreatureshewasbecomingfamiliarwithwasamererat. AtfirstErmengardewastoomuchalarmedtodoanythingbuthuddleinaheapuponthebedandtuckupherfeet,butthesightofSara’scomposedlittlecountenanceandthestoryofMelchisedec’sfirstappearancebeganatlasttorousehercuriosity,andsheleanedforwardovertheedgeofthebedandwatchedSaragoandkneeldownbytheholeintheskirtingboard. “He—hewon’trunoutquicklyandjumponthebed,willhe?”shesaid. “No,”answeredSara.“He’saspoliteasweare.Heisjustlikeaperson.Nowwatch!” Shebegantomakealow,whistlingsound—solowandcoaxingthatitcouldonlyhavebeenheardinentirestillness. Shediditseveraltimes,lookingentirelyabsorbedinit. Ermengardethoughtshelookedasifshewereworkingaspell. Andatlast,evidentlyinresponsetoit,agray-whiskered,bright-eyedheadpeepedoutofthehole.Sarahadsomecrumbsinherhand. Shedroppedthem,andMelchisedeccamequietlyforthandatethem. Apieceoflargersizethantheresthetookandcarriedinthemostbusinesslikemannerbacktohishome. “Yousee,”saidSara,“thatisforhiswifeandchildren.Heisverynice.Heonlyeatsthelittlebits. AfterhegoesbackIcanalwayshearhisfamilysqueakingforjoy.Therearethreekindsofsqueaks. Onekindisthechildren’s,andoneisMrs.Melchisedec’s,andoneisMelchisedec’sown.” “Oh,Sara!”shesaid.“Youarequeer—butyouarenice.” “IknowIamqueer,”admittedSara,cheerfully;“andItrytobenice.” Sherubbedherforeheadwithherlittlebrownpaw,andapuzzled,tenderlookcameintoherface. “Papaalwayslaughedatme,”shesaid;“butIlikedit. HethoughtIwasqueer,buthelikedmetomakeupthings.I—Ican’thelpmakingupthings. IfIdidn’t,Idon’tbelieveIcouldlive.” Shepausedandglancedaroundtheattic. “I’msureIcouldn’tlivehere,”sheaddedinalowvoice. Ermengardewasinterested,asshealwayswas.“Whenyoutalkaboutthings,”shesaid,“theyseemasiftheygrewreal.YoutalkaboutMelchisedecasifhewasaperson.” “Heisaperson,”saidSara.“Hegetshungryandfrightened,justaswedo;andheismarriedandhaschildren. Howdoweknowhedoesn’tthinkthings,justaswedo?Hiseyeslookasifhewasaperson.ThatwaswhyIgavehimaname.” Shesatdownonthefloorinherfavoriteattitude,holdingherknees. “Besides,”shesaid,“heisaBastilleratsenttobemyfriend.Icanalwaysgetabitofbreadthecookhasthrownaway,anditisquiteenoughtosupporthim.” “IsittheBastilleyet?”askedErmengarde,eagerly.“DoyoualwayspretenditistheBastille?” “Nearlyalways,”answeredSara.“SometimesItrytopretenditisanotherkindofplace;buttheBastilleisgenerallyeasiest—particularlywhenitiscold.” JustatthatmomentErmengardealmostjumpedoffthebed,shewassostartledbyasoundsheheard.Itwasliketwodistinctknocksonthewall. “Whatisthat?”sheexclaimed. Saragotupfromthefloorandansweredquitedramatically: “Itistheprisonerinthenextcell.” “Becky!”criedErmengarde,enraptured. “Yes,”saidSara.“Listen;thetwoknocksmeant,`Prisoner,areyouthere?’” Sheknockedthreetimesonthewallherself,asifinanswer. “Thatmeans,`Yes,Iamhere,andalliswell.’” FourknockscamefromBecky’ssideofthewall. “Thatmeans,”explainedSara,”`Then,fellow-sufferer,wewillsleepinpeace.Goodnight.’” Ermengardequitebeamedwithdelight. “Oh,Sara!”shewhisperedjoyfully.“Itislikeastory!” “Itisastory,”saidSara.“Everything’sastory.Youareastory—Iamastory.MissMinchinisastory.” AndshesatdownagainandtalkeduntilErmengardeforgotthatshewasasortofescapedprisonerherself,andhadtoberemindedbySarathatshecouldnotremainintheBastilleallnight,butmuststealnoiselesslydownstairsagainandcreepbackintoherdesertedbed.