OneofthefirstthingsthatJurgishaddoneafterhegotajobwastogoandseeMarija. Shecamedownintothebasementofthehousetomeethim,andhestoodbythedoorwithhishatinhishand,saying,“I’vegotworknow,andsoyoucanleavehere.” ButMarijaonlyshookherhead.Therewasnothingelseforhertodo,shesaid,andnobodytoemployher. Shecouldnotkeepherpastasecret—girlshadtriedit,andtheywerealwaysfoundout. Therewerethousandsofmenwhocametothisplace,andsoonerorlatershewouldmeetoneofthem. “Andbesides,”Marijaadded,“Ican’tdoanything.I’mnogood—Itakedope.Whatcouldyoudowithme?” “Can’tyoustop?”Jurgiscried. “No,”sheanswered,“I’llneverstop.What’stheuseoftalkingaboutit—I’llstayheretillIdie,Iguess.It’sallI’mfitfor.” Andthatwasallthathecouldgethertosay—therewasnousetrying. WhenhetoldherhewouldnotletElzbietatakehermoney,sheansweredindifferently:“Thenit’llbewastedhere—that’sall.” Hereyelidslookedheavyandherfacewasredandswollen;hesawthathewasannoyingher,thatsheonlywantedhimtogoaway.Sohewent,disappointedandsad. PoorJurgiswasnotveryhappyinhishome-life. Elzbietawassickagooddealnow,andtheboyswerewildandunruly,andverymuchtheworsefortheirlifeuponthestreets. Buthestuckbythefamilynevertheless,fortheyremindedhimofhisoldhappiness;andwhenthingswentwronghecouldsolacehimselfwithaplungeintotheSocialistmovement. Sincehislifehadbeencaughtupintothecurrentofthisgreatstream,thingswhichhadbeforebeenthewholeoflifetohimcametoseemofrelativelyslightimportance;hisinterestswereelsewhere,intheworldofideas. Hisoutwardlifewascommonplaceanduninteresting;hewasjustahotel-porter,andexpectedtoremainonewhilehelived;butmeantime,intherealmofthought,hislifewasaperpetualadventure. Therewassomuchtoknow—somanywonderstobediscovered! NeverinallhislifedidJurgisforgetthedaybeforeelection,whentherecameatelephonemessagefromafriendofHarryAdams,askinghimtobringJurgistoseehimthatnight;andJurgiswent,andmetoneofthemindsofthemovement. TheinvitationwasfromamannamedFisher,aChicagomillionairewhohadgivenuphislifetosettlementwork,andhadalittlehomeintheheartofthecity’sslums. Hedidnotbelongtotheparty,buthewasinsympathywithit;andhesaidthathewastohaveashisguestthatnighttheeditorofabigEasternmagazine,whowroteagainstSocialism,butreallydidnotknowwhatitwas. ThemillionairesuggestedthatAdamsbringJurgisalong,andthenstartupthesubjectof“purefood,”inwhichtheeditorwasinterested. YoungFisher’shomewasalittletwo-storybrickhouse,dingyandweather-beatenoutside,butattractivewithin. TheroomthatJurgissawwashalflinedwithbooks,anduponthewallsweremanypictures,dimlyvisibleinthesoft,yellowlight;itwasacold,rainynight,soalogfirewascracklingintheopenhearth. SevenoreightpeopleweregatheredaboutitwhenAdamsandhisfriendarrived,andJurgissawtohisdismaythatthreeofthemwereladies. Hehadnevertalkedtopeopleofthissortbefore,andhefellintoanagonyofembarrassment. Hestoodinthedoorwayclutchinghishattightlyinhishands,andmadeadeepbowtoeachofthepersonsashewasintroduced;then,whenhewasaskedtohaveaseat,hetookachairinadarkcorner,andsatdownupontheedgeofit,andwipedtheperspirationoffhisforeheadwithhissleeve. Hewasterrifiedlesttheyshouldexpecthimtotalk. Therewasthehosthimself,atall,athleticyoungman,cladineveningdress,asalsowastheeditor,adyspeptic-lookinggentlemannamedMaynard. Therewastheformer’sfrailyoungwife,andalsoanelderlylady,whotaughtkindergarteninthesettlement,andayoungcollegestudent,abeautifulgirlwithanintenseandearnestface. SheonlyspokeonceortwicewhileJurgiswasthere—therestofthetimeshesatbythetableinthecenteroftheroom,restingherchininherhandsanddrinkingintheconversation. Thereweretwoothermen,whomyoungFisherhadintroducedtoJurgisasMr.LucasandMr.Schliemann;heheardthemaddressAdamsas“Comrade,”andsoheknewthattheywereSocialists. TheonecalledLucaswasamildandmeek-lookinglittlegentlemanofclericalaspect;hehadbeenanitinerantevangelist,ittranspired,andhadseenthelightandbecomeaprophetofthenewdispensation. Hetraveledalloverthecountry,livingliketheapostlesofold,uponhospitality,andpreachinguponstreet-cornerswhentherewasnohall. TheothermanhadbeeninthemidstofadiscussionwiththeeditorwhenAdamsandJurgiscamein;andatthesuggestionofthehosttheyresumeditaftertheinterruption. Jurgiswassoonsittingspellbound,thinkingthatherewassurelythestrangestmanthathadeverlivedintheworld. NicholasSchliemannwasaSwede,atall,gauntperson,withhairyhandsandbristlingyellowbeard;hewasauniversityman,andhadbeenaprofessorofphilosophy—until,ashesaid,hehadfoundthathewassellinghischaracteraswellashistime. InsteadhehadcometoAmerica,wherehelivedinagarretroominthisslumdistrict,andmadevolcanicenergytaketheplaceoffire. Hestudiedthecompositionoffood-stuffs,andknewexactlyhowmanyproteidsandcarbohydrateshisbodyneeded;andbyscientificchewinghesaidthathetripledthevalueofallheate,sothatitcosthimelevencentsaday. AboutthefirstofJulyhewouldleaveChicagoforhisvacation,onfoot;andwhenhestrucktheharvestfieldshewouldsettoworkfortwodollarsandahalfaday,andcomehomewhenhehadanotheryear’ssupply—ahundredandtwenty-fivedollars. Thatwasthenearestapproachtoindependenceamancouldmake“undercapitalism,”heexplained;hewouldnevermarry,fornosanemanwouldallowhimselftofallinloveuntilaftertherevolution. Hesatinabigarm-chair,withhislegscrossed,andhisheadsofarintheshadowthatonesawonlytwoglowinglights,reflectedfromthefireonthehearth. Hespokesimply,andutterlywithoutemotion;withthemannerofateachersettingforthtoagroupofscholarsanaxiomingeometry,hewouldenunciatesuchpropositionsasmadethehairofanordinarypersonriseonend. Andwhentheauditorhadassertedhisnon-comprehension,hewouldproceedtoelucidatebysomenewproposition,yetmoreappalling. ToJurgistheHerrDr.Schliemannassumedtheproportionsofathunderstormoranearthquake. Andyet,strangeasitmightseem,therewasasubtlebondbetweenthem,andhecouldfollowtheargumentnearlyallthetime. Hewascarriedoverthedifficultplacesinspiteofhimself;andhewentplungingawayinmadcareer—averyMazeppa-rideuponthewildhorseSpeculation. NicholasSchliemannwasfamiliarwithalltheuniverse,andwithmanasasmallpartofit. Heunderstoodhumaninstitutions,andblewthemaboutlikesoapbubbles. Itwassurprisingthatsomuchdestructivenesscouldbecontainedinonehumanmind.Wasitgovernment? Thepurposeofgovernmentwastheguardingofproperty-rights,theperpetuationofancientforceandmodernfraud.Orwasitmarriage? Marriageandprostitutionweretwosidesofoneshield,thepredatoryman’sexploitationofthesex-pleasure. Thedifferencebetweenthemwasadifferenceofclass. Ifawomanhadmoneyshemightdictateherownterms:equality,alifecontract,andthelegitimacy—thatis,theproperty-rights—ofherchildren. Ifshehadnomoney,shewasaproletarian,andsoldherselfforanexistence. AndthenthesubjectbecameReligion,whichwastheArchfiend’sdeadliestweapon. Governmentoppressedthebodyofthewage-slave,butReligionoppressedhismind,andpoisonedthestreamofprogressatitssource. Theworking-manwastofixhishopesuponafuturelife,whilehispocketswerepickedinthisone;hewasbroughtuptofrugality,humility,obedience—inshorttoallthepseudo-virtuesofcapitalism. ThedestinyofcivilizationwouldbedecidedinonefinaldeathstrugglebetweentheRedInternationalandtheBlack,betweenSocialismandtheRomanCatholicChurch;whilehereathome,“thestygianmidnightofAmericanevangelicalism—” Andheretheex-preacherenteredthefield,andtherewasalivelytussle. “Comrade”Lucaswasnotwhatiscalledaneducatedman;heknewonlytheBible,butitwastheBibleinterpretedbyrealexperience. Andwhatwastheuse,heasked,ofconfusingReligionwithmen’sperversionsofit? Thatthechurchwasinthehandsofthemerchantsatthemomentwasobviousenough;butalreadythereweresignsofrebellion,andifComradeSchliemanncouldcomebackafewyearsfromnow— “Ah,yes,”saidtheother,“ofcourse,IhavenodoubtthatinahundredyearstheVaticanwillbedenyingthatiteveropposedSocialism,justasatpresentitdeniesthatitevertorturedGalileo.” “IamnotdefendingtheVatican,”exclaimedLucas,vehemently. “IamdefendingthewordofGod—whichisonelongcryofthehumanspiritfordeliverancefromtheswayofoppression. Takethetwenty-fourthchapteroftheBookofJob,whichIamaccustomedtoquoteinmyaddressesas‘theBibleupontheBeefTrust’;ortakethewordsofIsaiah—oroftheMasterhimself! Nottheelegantprinceofourdebauchedandviciousart,notthejeweledidolofoursocietychurches—buttheJesusoftheawfulreality,themanofsorrowandpain,theoutcast,despisedoftheworld,whohadnowheretolayhishead—” “IwillgrantyouJesus,”interruptedtheother. “Well,then,”criedLucas,“andwhyshouldJesushavenothingtodowithhischurch—whyshouldhiswordsandhislifebeofnoauthorityamongthosewhoprofesstoadorehim? Hereisamanwhowastheworld’sfirstrevolutionist,thetruefounderoftheSocialistmovement;amanwhosewholebeingwasoneflameofhatredforwealth,andallthatwealthstandsfor,—fortheprideofwealth,andtheluxuryofwealth,andthetyrannyofwealth;whowashimselfabeggarandatramp,amanofthepeople,anassociateofsaloon-keepersandwomenofthetown;whoagainandagain,inthemostexplicitlanguage,denouncedwealthandtheholdingofwealth:‘Laynotupforyourselvestreasuresonearth!’ —’Sellthatyehaveandgivealms!’ —’Blessedareyepoor,foryoursisthekingdomofHeaven!’ —’Woeuntoyouthatarerich,foryehavereceivedyourconsolation!’ —’Verily,Isayuntoyou,thatarichmanshallhardlyenterintothekingdomofHeaven!’ Whodenouncedinunmeasuredtermstheexploitersofhisowntime:‘Woeuntoyou,scribesandpharisees,hypocrites!’—’Woeuntoyoualso,youlawyers!’ —’Yeserpents,yegenerationofvipers,howcanyeescapethedamnationofhell?’ Whodroveoutthebusinessmenandbrokersfromthetemplewithawhip! Whowascrucified—thinkofit—foranincendiaryandadisturberofthesocialorder! Andthismantheyhavemadeintothehighpriestofpropertyandsmugrespectability,adivinesanctionofallthehorrorsandabominationsofmoderncommercialcivilization! Jeweledimagesaremadeofhim,sensualpriestsburnincensetohim,andmodernpiratesofindustrybringtheirdollars,wrungfromthetoilofhelplesswomenandchildren,andbuildtemplestohim,andsitincushionedseatsandlistentohisteachingsexpoundedbydoctorsofdustydivinity—” “Bravo!”criedSchliemann,laughing. Buttheotherwasinfullcareer—hehadtalkedthissubjecteverydayforfiveyears,andhadneveryetlethimselfbestopped.“ThisJesusofNazareth!”hecried.“Thisclass-consciousworking-man!Thisunioncarpenter! Thisagitator,law-breaker,firebrand,anarchist! He,thesovereignlordandmasterofaworldwhichgrindsthebodiesandsoulsofhumanbeingsintodollars—ifhecouldcomeintotheworldthisdayandseethethingsthatmenhavemadeinhisname,woulditnotblasthissoulwithhorror? Wouldhenotgomadatthesightofit,hethePrinceofMercyandLove! ThatdreadfulnightwhenhelayintheGardenofGethsemaneandwrithedinagonyuntilhesweatblood—doyouthinkthathesawanythingworsethanhemightseetonightupontheplainsofManchuria,wheremenmarchoutwithajeweledimageofhimbeforethem,todowholesalemurderforthebenefitoffoulmonstersofsensualityandcruelty? DoyounotknowthatifhewereinSt.Petersburgnow,hewouldtakethewhipwithwhichhedroveoutthebankersfromhistemple—” Herethespeakerpausedaninstantforbreath. “No,comrade,”saidtheother,dryly,“forhewasapracticalman. Hewouldtakeprettylittleimitationlemons,suchasarenowbeingshippedintoRussia,handyforcarryinginthepockets,andstrongenoughtoblowawholetempleoutofsight.” Lucaswaiteduntilthecompanyhadstoppedlaughingoverthis;thenhebeganagain:“Butlookatitfromthepointofviewofpracticalpolitics,comrade. Hereisanhistoricalfigurewhomallmenreverenceandlove,whomsomeregardasdivine;andwhowasoneofus—wholivedourlife,andtaughtourdoctrine. Andnowshallweleavehiminthehandsofhisenemies—shallweallowthemtostifleandstultifyhisexample? Wehavehiswords,whichnoonecandeny;andshallwenotquotethemtothepeople,andprovetothemwhathewas,andwhathetaught,andwhathedid?No,no,athousandtimesno! —weshallusehisauthoritytoturnouttheknavesandsluggardsfromhisministry,andweshallyetrousethepeopletoaction!—” Lucashaltedagain;andtheotherstretchedouthishandtoapaperonthetable. “Here,comrade,”hesaid,withalaugh,“hereisaplaceforyoutobegin. Abishopwhosewifehasjustbeenrobbedoffiftythousanddollars’worthofdiamonds! Andamostunctuousandoilyofbishops!Aneminentandscholarlybishop! Aphilanthropistandfriendoflaborbishop—aCivicFederationdecoyduckforthechloroformingofthewage-working-man!” Tothislittlepassageofarmstherestofthecompanysatasspectators. ButnowMr.Maynard,theeditor,tookoccasiontoremark,somewhatnaively,thathehadalwaysunderstoodthatSocialistshadacut-and-driedprogramforthefutureofcivilization;whereashereweretwoactivemembersoftheparty,who,fromwhathecouldmakeout,wereagreedaboutnothingatall. Wouldthetwo,forhisenlightenment,trytoascertainjustwhattheyhadincommon,andwhytheybelongedtothesameparty? Thisresulted,aftermuchdebating,intheformulatingoftwocarefullywordedpropositions:First,thataSocialistbelievesinthecommonownershipanddemocraticmanagementofthemeansofproducingthenecessitiesoflife;and,second,thataSocialistbelievesthatthemeansbywhichthisistobebroughtaboutistheclassconsciouspoliticalorganizationofthewage-earners. Thusfartheywereatone;butnofarther. ToLucas,thereligiouszealot,theco-operativecommonwealthwastheNewJerusalem,thekingdomofHeaven,whichis“withinyou.” Totheother,Socialismwassimplyanecessarysteptowardafar-distantgoal,asteptobetoleratedwithimpatience. Schliemanncalledhimselfa“philosophicanarchist”;andheexplainedthatananarchistwasonewhobelievedthattheendofhumanexistencewasthefreedevelopmentofeverypersonality,unrestrictedbylawssavethoseofitsownbeing. Sincethesamekindofmatchwouldlighteveryone’sfireandthesame-shapedloafofbreadwouldfilleveryone’sstomach,itwouldbeperfectlyfeasibletosubmitindustrytothecontrolofamajorityvote. Therewasonlyoneearth,andthequantityofmaterialthingswaslimited. Ofintellectualandmoralthings,ontheotherhand,therewasnolimit,andonecouldhavemorewithoutanother’shavingless;hence“Communisminmaterialproduction,anarchisminintellectual,”wastheformulaofmodernproletarianthought. Assoonasthebirthagonywasover,andthewoundsofsocietyhadbeenhealed,therewouldbeestablishedasimplesystemwherebyeachmanwascreditedwithhislaboranddebitedwithhispurchases;andafterthattheprocessesofproduction,exchange,andconsumptionwouldgoonautomatically,andwithoutourbeingconsciousofthem,anymorethanamanisconsciousofthebeatingofhisheart. Andthen,explainedSchliemann,societywouldbreakupintoindependent,self-governingcommunitiesofmutuallycongenialpersons;examplesofwhichatpresentwereclubs,churches,andpoliticalparties. Aftertherevolution,alltheintellectual,artistic,andspiritualactivitiesofmenwouldbecaredforbysuch“freeassociations”;romanticnovelistswouldbesupportedbythosewholikedtoreadromanticnovels,andimpressionistpainterswouldbesupportedbythosewholikedtolookatimpressionistpictures—andthesamewithpreachersandscientists,editorsandactorsandmusicians. Ifanyonewantedtoworkorpaintorpray,andcouldfindnoonetomaintainhim,hecouldsupporthimselfbyworkingpartofthetime. Thatwasthecaseatpresent,theonlydifferencebeingthatthecompetitivewagesystemcompelledamantoworkallthetimetolive,while,aftertheabolitionofprivilegeandexploitation,anyonewouldbeabletosupporthimselfbyanhour’sworkaday. Alsotheartist’saudienceofthepresentwasasmallminorityofpeople,alldebasedandvulgarizedbytheeffortithadcostthemtowininthecommercialbattle,oftheintellectualandartisticactivitieswhichwouldresultwhenthewholeofmankindwassetfreefromthenightmareofcompetition,wecouldatpresentformnoconceptionwhatever. AndthentheeditorwantedtoknowuponwhatgroundDr.Schliemannassertedthatitmightbepossibleforasocietytoexistuponanhour’stoilbyeachofitsmembers. “Justwhat,”answeredtheother,“wouldbetheproductivecapacityofsocietyifthepresentresourcesofsciencewereutilized,wehavenomeansofascertaining;butwemaybesureitwouldexceedanythingthatwouldsoundreasonabletomindsinuredtotheferociousbarbaritiesofcapitalism. Afterthetriumphoftheinternationalproletariat,warwouldofcoursebeinconceivable;andwhocanfigurethecostofwartohumanity—notmerelythevalueofthelivesandthematerialthatitdestroys,notmerelythecostofkeepingmillionsofmeninidleness,ofarmingandequippingthemforbattleandparade,butthedrainuponthevitalenergiesofsocietybythewarattitudeandthewarterror,thebrutalityandignorance,thedrunkenness,prostitution,andcrimeitentails,theindustrialimpotenceandthemoraldeadness? Doyouthinkthatitwouldbetoomuchtosaythattwohoursoftheworkingtimeofeveryefficientmemberofacommunitygoestofeedtheredfiendofwar?” AndthenSchliemannwentontooutlinesomeofthewastesofcompetition:thelossesofindustrialwarfare;theceaselessworryandfriction;thevices—suchasdrink,forinstance,theuseofwhichhadnearlydoubledintwentyyears,asaconsequenceoftheintensificationoftheeconomicstruggle;theidleandunproductivemembersofthecommunity,thefrivolousrichandthepauperizedpoor;thelawandthewholemachineryofrepression;thewastesofsocialostentation,themillinersandtailors,thehairdressers,dancingmasters,chefsandlackeys. “Youunderstand,”hesaid,“thatinasocietydominatedbythefactofcommercialcompetition,moneyisnecessarilythetestofprowess,andwastefulnessthesolecriterionofpower. Sowehave,atthepresentmoment,asocietywith,say,thirtypercentofthepopulationoccupiedinproducinguselessarticles,andonepercentoccupiedindestroyingthem. Andthisisnotall;fortheservantsandpandersoftheparasitesarealsoparasites,themillinersandthejewelersandthelackeyshavealsotobesupportedbytheusefulmembersofthecommunity. Andbearinmindalsothatthismonstrousdiseaseaffectsnotmerelytheidlersandtheirmenials,itspoisonpenetratesthewholesocialbody. Beneaththehundredthousandwomenoftheeliteareamillionmiddle-classwomen,miserablebecausetheyarenotoftheelite,andtryingtoappearofitinpublic;andbeneaththem,inturn,arefivemillionfarmers’wivesreading‘fashionpapers’andtrimmingbonnets,andshop-girlsandserving-maidssellingthemselvesintobrothelsforcheapjewelryandimitationseal-skinrobes. Andthenconsiderthat,addedtothiscompetitionindisplay,youhave,likeoilontheflames,awholesystemofcompetitioninselling! Youhavemanufacturerscontrivingtensofthousandsofcatchpennydevices,storekeepersdisplayingthem,andnewspapersandmagazinesfilledupwithadvertisementsofthem!” “Anddon’tforgetthewastesoffraud,”putinyoungFisher. “Whenonecomestotheultra-modernprofessionofadvertising,”respondedSchliemann—”thescienceofpersuadingpeopletobuywhattheydonotwant—heisintheverycenteroftheghastlycharnelhouseofcapitalistdestructiveness,andhescarcelyknowswhichofadozenhorrorstopointoutfirst. Butconsiderthewasteintimeandenergyincidentaltomakingtenthousandvarietiesofathingforpurposesofostentationandsnobbishness,whereonevarietywoulddoforuse! Considerallthewasteincidentaltothemanufactureofcheapqualitiesofgoods,ofgoodsmadetosellanddeceivetheignorant;considerthewastesofadulteration,—theshoddyclothing,thecottonblankets,theunstabletenements,theground-corklife-preservers,theadulteratedmilk,theanilinesodawater,thepotato-floursausages—” “Andconsiderthemoralaspectsofthething,”putintheex-preacher. “Precisely,”saidSchliemann;“thelowknaveryandtheferociouscrueltyincidentaltothem,theplottingandthelyingandthebribing,theblusteringandbragging,thescreamingegotism,thehurryingandworrying. Ofcourse,imitationandadulterationaretheessenceofcompetition—theyarebutanotherformofthephrase‘tobuyinthecheapestmarketandsellinthedearest.’ Agovernmentofficialhasstatedthatthenationsuffersalossofabillionandaquarterdollarsayearthroughadulteratedfoods;whichmeans,ofcourse,notonlymaterialswastedthatmighthavebeenusefuloutsideofthehumanstomach,butdoctorsandnursesforpeoplewhowouldotherwisehavebeenwell,andundertakersforthewholehumanracetenortwentyyearsbeforethepropertime. Thenagain,considerthewasteoftimeandenergyrequiredtosellthesethingsinadozenstores,whereonewoulddo. Thereareamillionortwoofbusinessfirmsinthecountry,andfiveortentimesasmanyclerks;andconsiderthehandlingandrehandling,theaccountingandreaccounting,theplanningandworrying,thebalancingofpettyprofitandloss. Considerthewholemachineryofthecivillawmadenecessarybytheseprocesses;thelibrariesofponderoustomes,thecourtsandjuriestointerpretthem,thelawyersstudyingtocircumventthem,thepettifoggingandchicanery,thehatredsandlies! Considerthewastesincidentaltotheblindandhaphazardproductionofcommodities—thefactoriesclosed,theworkersidle,thegoodsspoilinginstorage;considertheactivitiesofthestockmanipulator,theparalyzingofwholeindustries,theoverstimulationofothers,forspeculativepurposes;theassignmentsandbankfailures,thecrisesandpanics,thedesertedtownsandthestarvingpopulations! Considertheenergieswastedintheseekingofmarkets,thesteriletrades,suchasdrummer,solicitor,bill-poster,advertisingagent. Considerthewastesincidentaltothecrowdingintocities,madenecessarybycompetitionandbymonopolyrailroadrates;considertheslums,thebadair,thediseaseandthewasteofvitalenergies;considertheofficebuildings,thewasteoftimeandmaterialinthepilingofstoryuponstory,andtheburrowingunderground! Thentakethewholebusinessofinsurance,theenormousmassofadministrativeandclericallaboritinvolves,andallutterwaste—” “Idonotfollowthat,”saidtheeditor. “TheCooperativeCommonwealthisauniversalautomaticinsurancecompanyandsavingsbankforallitsmembers. Capitalbeingthepropertyofall,injurytoitissharedbyallandmadeupbyall. Thebankistheuniversalgovernmentcredit-account,theledgerinwhicheveryindividual’searningsandspendingsatebalanced. Thereisalsoauniversalgovernmentbulletin,inwhicharelistedandpreciselydescribedeverythingwhichthecommonwealthhasforsale. Asnoonemakesanyprofitbythesale,thereisnolongeranystimulustoextravagance,andnomisrepresentation;nocheating,noadulterationorimitation,nobriberyor‘grafting.’” “Howisthepriceofanarticledetermined?” “Thepriceisthelaborithascosttomakeanddeliverit,anditisdeterminedbythefirstprinciplesofarithmetic. Themillionworkersinthenation’swheatfieldshaveworkedahundreddayseach,andthetotalproductofthelaborisabillionbushels,sothevalueofabushelofwheatisthetenthpartofafarmlabor-day. Ifweemployanarbitrarysymbol,andpay,say,fivedollarsadayforfarmwork,thenthecostofabushelofwheatisfiftycents.” “Yousay‘forfarmwork,’”saidMr.Maynard.“Thenlaborisnottobepaidalike?” “Manifestlynot,sincesomeworkiseasyandsomehard,andweshouldhavemillionsofruralmailcarriers,andnocoalminers. Ofcoursethewagesmaybeleftthesame,andthehoursvaried;oneortheotherwillhavetobevariedcontinually,accordingasagreaterorlessnumberofworkersisneededinanyparticularindustry. Thatispreciselywhatisdoneatpresent,exceptthatthetransferoftheworkersisaccomplishedblindlyandimperfectly,byrumorsandadvertisements,insteadofinstantlyandcompletely,byauniversalgovernmentbulletin.” “Howaboutthoseoccupationsinwhichtimeisdifficulttocalculate?Whatisthelaborcostofabook?” “Obviouslyitisthelaborcostofthepaper,printing,andbindingofit—aboutafifthofitspresentcost.” “Ihavealreadysaidthatthestatecouldnotcontrolintellectualproduction. Thestatemightsaythatithadtakenayeartowritethebook,andtheauthormightsayithadtakenthirty. Goethesaidthateverybonmotofhishadcostapurseofgold. WhatIoutlinehereisanational,orratherinternational,systemfortheprovidingofthematerialneedsofmen. Sinceamanhasintellectualneedsalso,hewillworklonger,earnmore,andprovideforthemtohisowntasteandinhisownway. Iliveonthesameearthasthemajority,Iwearthesamekindofshoesandsleepinthesamekindofbed;butIdonotthinkthesamekindofthoughts,andIdonotwishtopayforsuchthinkersasthemajorityselects. Iwishsuchthingstobelefttofreeeffort,asatpresent. Ifpeoplewanttolistentoacertainpreacher,theygettogetherandcontributewhattheyplease,andpayforachurchandsupportthepreacher,andthenlistentohim;I,whodonotwanttolistentohim,stayaway,anditcostsmenothing. InthesamewaytherearemagazinesaboutEgyptiancoins,andCatholicsaints,andflyingmachines,andathleticrecords,andIknownothingaboutanyofthem. Ontheotherhand,ifwageslaverywereabolished,andIcouldearnsomesparemoneywithoutpayingtributetoanexploitingcapitalist,thentherewouldbeamagazineforthepurposeofinterpretingandpopularizingthegospelofFriedrichNietzsche,theprophetofEvolution,andalsoofHoraceFletcher,theinventorofthenoblescienceofcleaneating;andincidentally,perhaps,forthediscouragingoflongskirts,andthescientificbreedingofmenandwomen,andtheestablishingofdivorcebymutualconsent.” Dr.Schliemannpausedforamoment.“Thatwasalecture,”hesaidwithalaugh,“andyetIamonlybegun!” “Whatelseisthere?”askedMaynard. “Ihavepointedoutsomeofthenegativewastesofcompetition,”answeredtheother. “Ihavehardlymentionedthepositiveeconomiesofco-operation. Allowingfivetoafamily,therearefifteenmillionfamiliesinthiscountry;andatleasttenmillionoftheseliveseparately,thedomesticdrudgebeingeitherthewifeorawageslave. Nowsetasidethemodernsystemofpneumatichouse-cleaning,andtheeconomiesofco-operativecooking;andconsideronesingleitem,thewashingofdishes. Surelyitismoderatetosaythatthedishwashingforafamilyoffivetakeshalfanhouraday;withtenhoursasaday’swork,ittakes,therefore,halfamillionable-bodiedpersons—mostlywomentodothedishwashingofthecountry. Andnotethatthisismostfilthyanddeadeningandbrutalizingwork;thatitisacauseofanemia,nervousness,ugliness,andill-temper;ofprostitution,suicide,andinsanity;ofdrunkenhusbandsanddegeneratechildren—forallofwhichthingsthecommunityhasnaturallytopay. Andnowconsiderthatineachofmylittlefreecommunitiestherewouldbeamachinewhichwouldwashanddrythedishes,anddoit,notmerelytotheeyeandthetouch,butscientifically—sterilizingthem—anddoitatasavingofallthedrudgeryandnine-tenthsofthetime! AllofthesethingsyoumayfindinthebooksofMrs.Gilman;andthentakeKropotkin’sFields,Factories,andWorkshops,andreadaboutthenewscienceofagriculture,whichhasbeenbuiltupinthelasttenyears;bywhich,withmadesoilsandintensiveculture,agardenercanraisetenortwelvecropsinaseason,andtwohundredtonsofvegetablesuponasingleacre;bywhichthepopulationofthewholeglobecouldbesupportedonthesoilnowcultivatedintheUnitedStatesalone! Itisimpossibletoapplysuchmethodsnow,owingtotheignoranceandpovertyofourscatteredfarmingpopulation;butimaginetheproblemofprovidingthefoodsupplyofournationoncetakeninhandsystematicallyandrationally,byscientists! Allthepoorandrockylandsetapartforanationaltimberreserve,inwhichourchildrenplay,andouryoungmenhunt,andourpoetsdwell! Themostfavorableclimateandsoilforeachproductselected;theexactrequirementsofthecommunityknown,andtheacreagefiguredaccordingly;themostimprovedmachineryemployed,underthedirectionofexpertagriculturalchemists! Iwasbroughtuponafarm,andIknowtheawfuldeadlinessoffarmwork;andIliketopictureitallasitwillbeaftertherevolution. Topicturethegreatpotato-plantingmachine,drawnbyfourhorses,oranelectricmotor,ploughingthefurrow,cuttinganddroppingandcoveringthepotatoes,andplantingascoreofacresaday! Topicturethegreatpotato-diggingmachine,runbyelectricity,perhaps,andmovingacrossathousand-acrefield,scoopingupearthandpotatoes,anddroppingthelatterintosacks! Toeveryotherkindofvegetableandfruithandledinthesameway—applesandorangespickedbymachinery,cowsmilkedbyelectricity—thingswhicharealreadydone,asyoumayknow. Topicturetheharvestfieldsofthefuture,towhichmillionsofhappymenandwomencomeforasummerholiday,broughtbyspecialtrains,theexactlyneedfulnumbertoeachplace! Andtocontrastallthiswithourpresentagonizingsystemofindependentsmallfarming,—astunted,haggard,ignorantman,matedwithayellow,lean,andsad-eyeddrudge,andtoilingfromfouro’clockinthemorninguntilnineatnight,workingthechildrenassoonastheyareabletowalk,scratchingthesoilwithitsprimitivetools,andshutoutfromallknowledgeandhope,fromalltheirbenefitsofscienceandinvention,andallthejoysofthespirit—heldtoabareexistencebycompetitioninlabor,andboastingofhisfreedombecauseheistooblindtoseehischains!” Dr.Schliemannpausedamoment.“Andthen,”hecontinued,“placebesidethisfactofanunlimitedfoodsupply,thenewestdiscoveryofphysiologists,thatmostoftheillsofthehumansystemareduetooverfeeding! Andthenagain,ithasbeenproventhatmeatisunnecessaryasafood;andmeatisobviouslymoredifficulttoproducethanvegetablefood,lesspleasanttoprepareandhandle,andmorelikelytobeunclean. Butwhatofthat,solongasitticklesthepalatemorestrongly?” “HowwouldSocialismchangethat?”askedthegirl-student,quickly.Itwasthefirsttimeshehadspoken. “Solongaswehavewageslavery,”answeredSchliemann,“itmattersnotintheleasthowdebasingandrepulsiveataskmaybe,itiseasytofindpeopletoperformit. Butjustassoonaslaborissetfree,thenthepriceofsuchworkwillbegintorise. Soonebyonetheold,dingy,andunsanitaryfactorieswillcomedown—itwillbecheapertobuildnew;andsothesteamshipswillbeprovidedwithstokingmachinery,andsothedangeroustradeswillbemadesafe,orsubstituteswillbefoundfortheirproducts. Inexactlythesameway,asthecitizensofourIndustrialRepublicbecomerefined,yearbyyearthecostofslaughterhouseproductswillincrease;untileventuallythosewhowanttoeatmeatwillhavetodotheirownkilling—andhowlongdoyouthinkthecustomwouldsurvivethen? —Togoontoanotheritem—oneofthenecessaryaccompanimentsofcapitalisminademocracyispoliticalcorruption;andoneoftheconsequencesofcivicadministrationbyignorantandviciouspoliticians,isthatpreventablediseaseskilloffhalfourpopulation. Andevenifsciencewereallowedtotry,itcoulddolittle,becausethemajorityofhumanbeingsarenotyethumanbeingsatall,butsimplymachinesforthecreatingofwealthforothers. Theyarepennedupinfilthyhousesandlefttorotandstewinmisery,andtheconditionsoftheirlifemakethemillfasterthanallthedoctorsintheworldcouldhealthem;andso,ofcourse,theyremainascentersofcontagion,poisoningthelivesofallofus,andmakinghappinessimpossibleforeventhemostselfish. ForthisreasonIwouldseriouslymaintainthatallthemedicalandsurgicaldiscoveriesthatsciencecanmakeinthefuturewillbeoflessimportancethantheapplicationoftheknowledgewealreadypossess,whenthedisinheritedoftheearthhaveestablishedtheirrighttoahumanexistence.” AndheretheHerrDoctorrelapsedintosilenceagain. Jurgishadnoticedthatthebeautifulyounggirlwhosatbythecenter-tablewaslisteningwithsomethingofthesamelookthathehimselfhadworn,thetimewhenhehadfirstdiscoveredSocialism. Jurgiswouldhavelikedtotalktoher,hefeltsurethatshewouldhaveunderstoodhim. Lateronintheevening,whenthegroupbrokeup,heheardMrs.Fishersaytoher,inalowvoice,“IwonderifMr.MaynardwillstillwritethesamethingsaboutSocialism”;towhichsheanswered,“Idon’tknow—butifhedoesweshallknowthatheisaknave!” Andonlyafewhoursafterthiscameelectionday—whenthelongcampaignwasover,andthewholecountryseemedtostandstillandholditsbreath,awaitingtheissue. JurgisandtherestofthestaffofHinds’sHotelcouldhardlystoptofinishtheirdinner,beforetheyhurriedofftothebighallwhichthepartyhadhiredforthatevening. Butalreadytherewerepeoplewaiting,andalreadythetelegraphinstrumentonthestagehadbegunclickingoffthereturns. Whenthefinalaccountsweremadeup,theSocialistvoteprovedtobeoverfourhundredthousand—anincreaseofsomethinglikethreehundredandfiftypercentinfouryears. Andthatwasdoingwell;butthepartywasdependentforitsearlyreturnsuponmessagesfromthelocals,andnaturallythoselocalswhichhadbeenmostsuccessfulweretheoneswhichfeltmostlikereporting;andsothatnighteveryoneinthehallbelievedthatthevotewasgoingtobesix,orseven,oreveneighthundredthousand. JustsuchanincredibleincreasehadactuallybeenmadeinChicago,andinthestate;thevoteofthecityhadbeen6,700in1900,andnowitwas47,000;thatofIllinoishadbeen9,600,andnowitwas69,000! So,astheeveningwaxed,andthecrowdpiledin,themeetingwasasighttobeseen. Bulletinswouldberead,andthepeoplewouldshoutthemselveshoarse—andthensomeonewouldmakeaspeech,andtherewouldbemoreshouting;andthenabriefsilence,andmorebulletins. Therewouldcomemessagesfromthesecretariesofneighboringstates,reportingtheirachievements;thevoteofIndianahadgonefrom2,300to12,000,ofWisconsinfrom7,000to28,000;ofOhiofrom4,800to36,000! Thereweretelegramstothenationalofficefromenthusiasticindividualsinlittletownswhichhadmadeamazingandunprecedentedincreasesinasingleyear:Benedict,Kansas,from26to260;Henderson,Kentucky,from19to111;Holland,Michigan,from14to208;Cleo,Oklahoma,from0to104;Martin’sFerry,Ohio,from0to296—andmanymoreofthesamekind. Therewereliterallyhundredsofsuchtowns;therewouldbereportsfromhalfadozenoftheminasinglebatchoftelegrams. Andthemenwhoreadthedespatchesofftotheaudiencewereoldcampaigners,whohadbeentotheplacesandhelpedtomakethevote,andcouldmakeappropriatecomments:Quincy,Illinois,from189to831—thatwaswherethemayorhadarrestedaSocialistspeaker! CrawfordCounty,Kansas,from285to1,975;thatwasthehomeofthe“AppealtoReason”! BattleCreek,Michigan,from4,261to10,184;thatwastheansweroflabortotheCitizens’AllianceMovement! Andthentherewereofficialreturnsfromthevariousprecinctsandwardsofthecityitself! Whetheritwasafactorydistrictoroneofthe“silk-stocking”wardsseemedtomakenoparticulardifferenceintheincrease;butoneofthethingswhichsurprisedthepartyleadersmostwasthetremendousvotethatcamerollinginfromthestockyards. Packingtowncomprisedthreewardsofthecity,andthevoteinthespringof1903hadbeen500,andinthefallofthesameyear,1,600. Now,onlyoneyearlater,itwasover6,300—andtheDemocraticvoteonly8,800! TherewereotherwardsinwhichtheDemocraticvotehadbeenactuallysurpassed,andintwodistricts,membersofthestatelegislaturehadbeenelected. ThusChicagonowledthecountry;ithadsetanewstandardfortheparty,ithadshowntheworkingmentheway! —Sospokeanoratorupontheplatform;andtwothousandpairsofeyeswerefixeduponhim,andtwothousandvoiceswerecheeringhiseverysentence. Theoratorhadbeentheheadofthecity’sreliefbureauinthestockyards,untilthesightofmiseryandcorruptionhadmadehimsick. Hewasyoung,hungry-looking,fulloffire;andasheswunghislongarmsandbeatupthecrowd,toJurgisheseemedtheveryspiritoftherevolution.“Organize!Organize!Organize!”—thatwashiscry. Hewasafraidofthistremendousvote,whichhispartyhadnotexpected,andwhichithadnotearned.“ThesemenarenotSocialists!”hecried. “Thiselectionwillpass,andtheexcitementwilldie,andpeoplewillforgetaboutit;andifyouforgetaboutit,too,ifyousinkbackandrestuponyouroars,weshalllosethisvotethatwehavepolledto-day,andourenemieswilllaughustoscorn! Itrestswithyoutotakeyourresolution—now,intheflushofvictory,tofindthesemenwhohavevotedforus,andbringthemtoourmeetings,andorganizethemandbindthemtous! Weshallnotfindallourcampaignsaseasyasthisone. Everywhereinthecountrytonighttheoldpartypoliticiansarestudyingthisvote,andsettingtheirsailsbyit;andnowherewilltheybequickerormorecunningthanhereinourowncity. FiftythousandSocialistvotesinChicagomeansamunicipal-ownershipDemocracyinthespring! Andthentheywillfoolthevotersoncemore,andallthepowersofplunderandcorruptionwillbesweptintoofficeagain! Butwhatevertheymaydowhentheygetin,thereisonethingtheywillnotdo,andthatwillbethethingforwhichtheywereelected! Theywillnotgivethepeopleofourcitymunicipalownership—theywillnotmeantodoit,theywillnottrytodoit;allthattheywilldoisgiveourpartyinChicagothegreatestopportunitythathasevercometoSocialisminAmerica! Weshallhavetheshamreformersself-stultifiedandself-convicted;weshallhavetheradicalDemocracyleftwithoutaliewithwhichtocoveritsnakedness! Andthenwillbegintherushthatwillneverbechecked,thetidethatwillneverturntillithasreacheditsflood—thatwillbeirresistible,overwhelming—therallyingoftheoutragedworkingmenofChicagotoourstandard! Andweshallorganizethem,weshalldrillthem,weshallmarshalthemforthevictory! Weshallbeardowntheopposition,weshallsweepifbeforeus—andChicagowillbeours!Chicagowillbeours!CHICAGOWILLBEOURS!”